Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Down

Author Topic: How Big Is Too Big?  (Read 23579 times)

Ray

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10475
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #20 on: February 23, 2006, 06:21:17 am »

Quote
As I stated above, we can at this time convert a digital image, or a film image to digital, and then convert that to a vector graphic, which is a mathmatical computation of tonality. Now we can rezise it to infinity without degradation. The technology, however, is not nearly ready for the consumer. How far off is that? I don;t know becsaue I haven't kept up with it, but barring any huge leaps in storage, storage speeds, and processing power in teh next 5 years, I'd say it's decades off. [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=58880\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I think there's certainly room for improvement of interpolation algorithms and this will no doubt take place in step with increases in computer power, but I can't help getting the impression here that you have been unduly influenced by certain scenes in Hollywood movies   . I think you might know the type I'm referring to. The CIA is given a satellite image of suspicious installations or camps in the Arabian desert but they can't quite make out what's going on, so they bring in the imaging guys with their state-of-the-art computers who miraculously zoom in on the minutest detail until the bearded face of Usama Bin Laden becomes as clear as a family album snapshot.

There's a fundamental flaw in such imagined processes. If the detail has not been recorded to begin with, then no amount of interpolation can accurately create it. For example, if your 3mp camera does not have the resolving power to capture say, a single strand of hair blowing in the wind when you take a portrait shot from a particular distance, then you can't expect an interpolation program to 'divine' that a single strand of hair in a particular location should have been recorded and 'create' it for you.

However, I would admit that a really smart computer might be able to recognise tell-tale signs of windy conditions in a scene as well as a human head of hair and recreate a few single strands for the sake of realism, but that would be of no use to the CIA. They might end up arresting the wrong person.  
Logged

BJL

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6600
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #21 on: February 23, 2006, 04:09:39 pm »

Quote
Do I get a sense here that you are coming around to my point of view on this issue, BJL. Ie., it might be easier to build an MF lens that's fully diffraction limited at f16 than it is to build a 35mm lens that's fully diffraction limited at f8.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=58871\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
No.
Mostly because I was not comparing performance of different formats at all!
Also because I think that your standard of "maximum diffraction limited resolution" is a red herring, ignoring the real-world balancing of diffraction, aberration, out of focus effects, sensor resolution, as well as bulk and cost. What I was thinking of with my previous post was roughly "lines per picture height with appropriate DOF, within a given budget". And I believe that the most cost effective strategy for increasing the resolution of images is the one being almost universally pursued by sensor and camera makers: increasing pixel density at each sensor size, (while keeping sensor sizes the same or reducing them).
Logged

Ray

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10475
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #22 on: February 23, 2006, 08:23:54 pm »

Quote
No.
Mostly because I was not comparing performance of different formats at all!
Also because I think that your standard of "maximum diffraction limited resolution" is a red herring, ignoring the real-world balancing of diffraction, aberration, out of focus effects, sensor resolution, as well as bulk and cost. What I was thinking of with my previous post was roughly "lines per picture height with appropriate DOF, within a given budget". And I believe that the most cost effective strategy for increasing the resolution of images is the one being almost universally pursued by sensor and camera makers: increasing pixel density at each sensor size, (while keeping sensor sizes the same or reducing them).
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=58933\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

BJL,
That large format cameras tend to be bulkier and heavier than small format cameras is a given. We can't do much about that, although it is perhaps worth mentioning that my Fuji GSW-690 lll, a 6x9cm film format camera with fixed wide-angle lens, is considerably lighter than a 1Ds with equivalent 35/1.4 lens and hardly heavier than a D60 or 5D with the same lens. Of course the GSW-690 lll has the weight advantage of being a manual rangefinder camera with fixed lens and carbon fibre body. It's designed to be light.

What I find interesting in your argument above is the way you've ignored technological solutions to the DoF disadvantage of the larger format whilst advocating other technological solutions to the dynamic range disadvantage of the smaller format.

I'm not qualified to comment on the technological difficulty of rapidly filling and emptying small photosites within one long exposure that is more comparable to the longer exposures of the larger formats with their bigger f stops, but the technology of merging a number of slightly differently focussed shots to produce one image with tremendous DoF, already exists. All that remains is for that process to be refined and automatized within the camera.

I also find it slightly frustrating that, despite your avowed knowledge in the field of optics and lens design, you seem unable to shed any light on this vexed question of precisely at what apertures are lenses diffraction limited. I hope you don't think I'm trying to 'put you on the spot' here. I mean, nobody else on these forums seems to be able to comment on these matters either. Michael seems to have lost interest in his DXO Analyzer, but the few lenses he has tested sometimes show surprising performance variation at big f stops where one might expect diffraction to dominate and be the great equaliser.

This might seem like a red herring, but I don't believe it is. Sensor prices are coming down for both large and small formats. If we ever get to the stage when all sensors will have smaller pixels than the smallest detail their associated lenses can resolve, there may well be an economic/quality shift to the larger format as the lens limitations of the smaller formats (ie 35mm) are reached.
Logged

dwdallam

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2044
    • http://www.dwdallam.com
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #23 on: February 24, 2006, 04:57:55 am »

No, I didn't say that. Vector conversion will not add information to the picture. However, what you capture will be resizable--blurry, fuzzy, or what have you--to infinity with no further degradation. I was influenced not by Hollywood but by the mathmatics behind vector creation, and then had my first practical experience--with Flash--by converting small graphics to vector images, and tehn resizing them to 200 time their original size--with no loss in quality compared to the original at the originals size. You never see dots or blocks--ever.  The problem is that of today, vector graphics are used mainly for flat drawing type images, wiht teh exception of CADD systems and programs like Maya, which are still animation type drawings, and not a ceonversion of a true photograph in to a true vector image--the tonality of a real picture, like I said, would take days to convert to a true vector image and would be just HUGE in size. Even Maya rendering into a vector graphic on a dual Mac G-X whatever the top of the line Mac comuter is sometimes take more than 24 hours, or more. Mathmatical computation of tonality will eventually take over bit maps. There will need to be vast increases in computational power along with vast improvments in storage before this comes about. We're talking about crytal storage devices that act like solid state RAM, but vastly faster and larger--like as in a desktop computer handling RAW images and converting them would need to be something like a Petabye, which is something like a 1, 000 times greater than a Terabyte, which is 1, 000 MBs. waht will really be interesting is when cameras can offer vector images themselves, again, probably when I'm around 200 years old.

Quote
I think there's certainly room for improvement of interpolation algorithms and this will no doubt take place in step with increases in computer power, but I can't help getting the impression here that you have been unduly influenced by certain scenes in Hollywood movies   . I think you might know the type I'm referring to. The CIA is given a satellite image of suspicious installations or camps in the Arabian desert but they can't quite make out what's going on, so they bring in the imaging guys with their state-of-the-art computers who miraculously zoom in on the minutest detail until the bearded face of Usama Bin Laden becomes as clear as a family album snapshot.

There's a fundamental flaw in such imagined processes. If the detail has not been recorded to begin with, then no amount of interpolation can accurately create it. For example, if your 3mp camera does not have the resolving power to capture say, a single strand of hair blowing in the wind when you take a portrait shot from a particular distance, then you can't expect an interpolation program to 'divine' that a single strand of hair in a particular location should have been recorded and 'create' it for you.

However, I would admit that a really smart computer might be able to recognise tell-tale signs of windy conditions in a scene as well as a human head of hair and recreate a few single strands for the sake of realism, but that would be of no use to the CIA. They might end up arresting the wrong person. 
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=58903\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Logged

tpassin

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #24 on: March 07, 2006, 01:45:42 am »

Quote
As I stated above, we can at this time convert a digital image, or a film image to digital, and then convert that to a vector graphic, which is a mathmatical computation of tonality. Now we can rezise it to infinity without degradation.

Well, no, it just doesn't work like that.  To get the benefits of vector graphics that you mention, you have to have an accurate mathematical description of the image.  But in general, there isn't any such description of a photograph.  To be more precise, you can get a mathematical description (e.g., a spatial fourier transform and a wavelet transform), and we can do that now (given lots of computing power), but it won't help blow the print up to arbitrary sizes.  

That's because the basic information just isn't there in the data.  You're limited by the pixel density.  Otherwise, good interpolation algorithms would already let us blow up pictures way bigger they they can be.  Basically, you can't know what happens between the pixels, so you have to assume that there is only a smooth variation between them.  But at a very large, blown up scale, a real subject would have more detail in between the (now spaced out by enlargement) pixels.  So the enlargement looks artificially smooth.  And using vector graphics can do nothing about this.
Logged

dwdallam

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2044
    • http://www.dwdallam.com
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #25 on: March 07, 2006, 02:51:55 am »

So what type of enlargement can you get with vector graphics compared to bitmap, once the conversion is made.

Also, are you saying that we will never had the ability to define a shape with tones in a image mathmatically that will allow an infinite--not arbitrary--enlargement--which means keeping all of the tonal scales that are originally in the image?

Quote
Well, no, it just doesn't work like that.  To get the benefits of vector graphics that you mention, you have to have an accurate mathematical description of the image.  But in general, there isn't any such description of a photograph.  To be more precise, you can get a mathematical description (e.g., a spatial fourier transform and a wavelet transform), and we can do that now (given lots of computing power), but it won't help blow the print up to arbitrary sizes. 

That's because the basic information just isn't there in the data.  You're limited by the pixel density.  Otherwise, good interpolation algorithms would already let us blow up pictures way bigger they they can be.  Basically, you can't know what happens between the pixels, so you have to assume that there is only a smooth variation between them.  But at a very large, blown up scale, a real subject would have more detail in between the (now spaced out by enlargement) pixels.  So the enlargement looks artificially smooth.  And using vector graphics can do nothing about this.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59663\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Logged

madmanchan

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2115
    • Web
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #26 on: March 07, 2006, 01:45:21 pm »

Quote
However, the quality test that I'd advocate is sterner; I'd ask at what point does an enlargement start to look significantly inferior to one made from a larger negative? In the days of film IMO a 35mm could generally hold its own up to a 10"x8" print, for a really good negative you could push that up to an 11"x14". After which the challenge becomes almost impossible as you pushed further into medium format territory.

What I see in my prints (using a 5D, 1Ds Mk II, P25 with a Hasselblad, and a P25 on a Linhof movement camera stitched to a sensor equivilant size of 49mmx71mm) is that even though digital gives a little more enlargement capability than film, especially with longer prime lenses, it's not that much more. And why should it be?

To go back to the 28MP Canon you mentioned (and I agree that something like it is sure to arrive before too long), some will look at that pixel spec and conclude that 240 dpi will get them pretty close to a 20" x 30" print. From 35mm? Surely it's time for a sanity check. What would the practical depth of field constraints be for an 18x or 20x enlargement? What back-breakingly heavy tripod would be required to still every last micron of vibration? And if there's a growing sense of dissatisfaction now with Canon's wide angles, what would the feeling be when those same optics are scrutinised at massive enlargement scales?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=58624\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Hi Gary,  as others have suggested in this thread, I think the right way to look at the enlargement issue with digital is to look at the number of pixels.  (Of course there's the issue of the quality of the pixels themselves, but let's put that issue aside for now.)

Now, the human eye can resolve features as small as ~1 minute of 1 arc, assuming 20/20 vision.  Let's say the eye is 6 inches away from the print, i.e. we really want to examine features closely.  At this distance, the average eye can resolve features as fine as 0.0017 inches, i.e. two black lines spaced any closer than that will start to appear as a single gray line with no space in between.  This means that we need at least 285 pixels printed per (linear) inch.  More than that will yield diminishing returns, even for people with unusually good vision.  This number holds regardless of the size of the print itself.

So, to get back to your original question:  if a digital system can produce 285 "good" pixels per linear inch, then the print should be rich with detail.

Example:  the 1Ds Mark II has a native file resolution of 4992 x 3328.  Without any interpolation, this yields a printed file roughly 11.5 x 17.5 in size @ 285 pixels per linear inch -- no problem.  Of course, we can make larger prints through interpolation, but in doing so we can only add artificial detail.

Eric
Logged
Eric Chan

benInMA

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 186
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #27 on: March 07, 2006, 02:15:56 pm »

What you would really need to build a digital camera that could create arbitrarily size enlargements is a device that does not capture a 2D projection of the 3D world at all.

What you need is something that can build a programmatic description of the entire scene and all the light sources involved.   Then you can render the entire scene at an arbitrary size just like raycasting/tracing software.

If you get behind the scenes a little and ignore the big commercial applications with their simplified user interfaces this is what they're doing, they're building a programmatic description of a scene, when you render it, you are projecting it into a two dimensional image.   This is the same way video games work, the renderings can be done in hardware or software.

There is no such device to capture a model of an arbitrary scene just by pointing a camera at it.   If I was to envision a device that could do this it would have to be some kind of floating robot which flew around the area measuring everything with robots.

And even then everything I just mentioned ignores that even with the model of everything in the scene and all the lighting information you still need textures of every object in the scene at an arbitrary level of detail.

It's orders of magnitude more complex then converting a 2D bitmap to a 2D vector graphics description in flash.

There is a lot of good information about this in computer science texts.

One really fun place to play around with this is POVRay, the free ray tracer... lots of fun to learn to program that.   I played around with it a lot about 10 years ago in college.   There is a lot of fantastic art being done with it.

Just don't hold your breath for a device or computer program which can capture that kind of information from a photograph.... that's very much in the realm of science fiction today.

Check out the internet ray tracing competition too... lots of awesome stuff to look at.    

Internet Ray Tracing Competition

These could all be rendered at arbitrary sizes.. but you've got to remember they are the product of:

- Someone composing the scene mathematically
- Lots of 2 dimensional textures captured with a camera or produced in photoshop, etc..
- Lots and lots of computational power & time.   (Hours, days even)
Logged

BJL

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6600
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #28 on: March 08, 2006, 02:09:02 pm »

Quote
What I find interesting in your argument above is the way you've ignored technological solutions to the DoF disadvantage of the larger format ... merging a number of slightly differently focussed shots to produce one image with tremendous DoF, already exists.

you seem unable to shed any light on this vexed question of precisely at what apertures are lenses diffraction limited.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=58959\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Firstly, what DOF disadvantage of larger formats? Use the larger format with same aperture diameter (so higher aperture ratio) and you get the same DOF, and then using the same shutter speed (but higher ISO) will give similar noise levels (mayne a little higher), and you also have the option of using same ISO (so lower shutter speed) to get less noise and more dynamic range.

The option you describe of merging multiple frames for increased DOF is clearly a very "low speed" one, for working with completely stationary subjects and a tripd mounted camera. That is exactly the territory where I do expect larger formats to continue to have an advantage, with electronic sensors just as with film.


As to diffraction limitation, all I can say in general (as opposed to about particular current lenses) is that to avoid losing a significant amount of the resolution that is possible from a Bayer CFA sensor of a particular pixel spacing, it seems that the f-stop should not be higher than about twice the pixel spacing. So about f/8-f/11 for the smallest current DSLR pixels of 5.3-5.4 microns. Thes f-stops are easily high enough that good lenses are performing at very close to the diffraction limited performance of a "perfect" lens. Indeed, looking at some good recent lenses, I would not worry about lens abberations significantly limiting resolution until about f/4 - f/5.6, corresponding to about 2 - 2.8 micron minimum useful pixel spacing.That gives 20-40MP in 4/3 format, 30-60MP in EF-S/DX, etc.

I do not expect 4/3, EF-S or DX format to ever give print resolution significantly beyond what the current 22MP "digital large format" sensors offer. Then again, I do not expect more than one in a thouand SLR users to care about such extremes of resolution either ... especially if it involves fiddling with taking and merging multiple exposures to get adequate DOF.
Logged

benInMA

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 186
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #29 on: March 08, 2006, 02:53:16 pm »

How many people are actually merging multiple shots for DoF on a regular basis?

Sounds like way more of a PITA then it's worth.    Why not go to a tilt/shift lens or a medium/large format camera with camera movements if you need something that specialized?

Merging the files has got to be even more of a PITA then using film and then having to scan it.

Merging for exposure sounds like a PITA to me, merging for DoF sounds even more crazy... talk about a post processing nightmare.
Logged

Gary Ferguson

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 550
    • http://
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #30 on: March 08, 2006, 06:36:41 pm »

Quote
Example: the 1Ds Mark II has a native file resolution of 4992 x 3328. Without any interpolation, this yields a printed file roughly 11.5 x 17.5 in size @ 285 pixels per linear inch -- no problem.

Eric, I'm afraid we're going to have to agree to disagree on this point. In the earlier days of digital we were mainly limited by the number of pixels at our disposal. So it made sense to measure enlargement capabilities just in terms of pixels, using the 240-360 dpi measure that you referenced. However, we're now getting to the stage IMO where we have to temper that simple linear relationship with some other factors.

Let me give you one example, depth of field. The DOF engravings on manual focus lenses were established in the 1930's, apart from the ASA/ISO standards for film it's one of the few examples where the photographic industry has ever agreed on anything! Rather than have different lens and camera manufacturers competing on who's products gave the greatest depth of field they agreed on a convention that said the image recorded on 35mm film would be considered as "in focus" if an infinitesimal spot in the subject was rendered in the negative as a "blur circle", or "circle of confusion" no more than about 0.030mm in diameter. There was in fact some departure from this standard, Leica engraved their lenses to a slightly more rigorous depth of field standard of about 0.025mm. But basically the convention has held for the last 70 years.

And if you enlarge a 35mm negative say x4, to get the common 4"x6" print, then it's a pretty good guide. That will render the point in the subject as a little blur circle about 0.1mm in diameter. Not quite up to the standard you spoke about but pretty good. And in the good old days of silver darkrooms 35mm enthusiasts like myself regularly achieved really sharp and satisfying 10"x8" prints, and on rare occasions with a really lucky negative we could even go a bit larger.

But suddenly with 11MP, 12MP, and 17MP DSLR's we seem to think that we can enlarge to x12 or x15 with impunity. Well, that takes the blur circle on the print up to about half a millimetre, and even to my middle aged eyes that just looks plain soft! Let alone guaged against the stern standards you've advanced for the limits of resolution.

Let me give you a practical example. Here's a 100% crop from a P25 back with a Hasselblad 100mm lens, it's precisely focused at a distance of 10 metres at an aperture of f11, no sharpening, no nothing.

In the second shot I've shifted the focus by turning the 10m focus mark around the lens, not to the f11 position that Zeiss/Hasselblad say is acceptable, but just a little way to the f5.6 position. So two full stops more restrictive than the recommended DOF limits. To my eye it looks like rubbish!

This is why I say that we've now moved beyond pixel limited enlargement barriers, and we're basically back to the same physical and optical constraints that have capped our photographic ambitions for the last seventy years.



[attachment=316:attachment]

[attachment=317:attachment]
Logged

madmanchan

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2115
    • Web
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #31 on: March 08, 2006, 07:51:02 pm »

Quote
Let me give you one example, depth of field.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59820\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Aha, Gary -- now I see what you are getting at.  I misunderstood your original post.  

What you are saying is that there are other factors besides the # of pixels that affect the enlargeability, with optical phenomena (or limitations, so to speak) such as depth of field playing a role.  To put it another way, there are these other factors that can limit the quality of each pixel, and therefore the overall potential to magnify is diminished.  I think we're in agreement here ...

Eric
Logged
Eric Chan

Ray

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10475
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #32 on: March 08, 2006, 08:18:28 pm »

Quote
As to diffraction limitation, all I can say in general (as opposed to about particular current lenses) is that to avoid losing a significant amount of the resolution that is possible from a Bayer CFA sensor of a particular pixel spacing, it seems that the f-stop should not be higher than about twice the pixel spacing.


BJL,
Not sure what you mean here. The problem for most of us when thinking about lens performance is that the results we are used to seeing have either been filtered through the crud and large grain-clumps of film and then re-photographed with a scanner, or they are simply limited by a combination of digital noise and insufficient pixel density of the sensor and/or insufficient sensitivity and quantum efficiency of the photosites.

Either way, we never get to appreciate what a camera lens is really capable of.

My understanding is that a lens that is resolution limited only by diffraction at f8 should be capable of double the resolution of a lens that is diffraction limited at f16.

The difference in resolution between these two f/stops should be comparable to the difference in total picture resolution between the D30 (not the 30D) and the 5D., ie. 4x the pixel count equates to double the resolution.

When I compare f16 with f8, using either my 5D or 20D, I do not see a substantial difference. I do see some difference, but such differences seem far less significant than the differences I sometimes see when comparing two similar lenses in a store before buying. I therefore can't help getting the impression that there really are no 35mm lenses currently available that are diffraction limited at f8.

Furthermore, this impression is reinforced by statements from many professional photographers who claim that 35mm lenses are now the weak point in the chain and futher pixel density will not serve any purpose without improvement in lenses.

If for argument sake, one of my lenses is diffraction limited at f16 and transmits detail at 50lp/mm to my sensor at 50% MTF, I would expect a result that is quite close to the resolution limits of a 5D sensor. If a 35mm lens exists which is diffraction limited at f8, then by the same standard it should be capable of transmitting detail equivalent to 100 lp/mm at 50% MTF.

To capture such detail on a Bayer type 35mm sensor, one would need a 48mp sensor (4x the pixel count of the 5D) with 'yet to be developed' technology to reduce noise and increase sensitivity. Would this not be the case? Seems logical to me   .
Logged

Ray

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10475
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #33 on: March 08, 2006, 09:30:42 pm »

Quote
But suddenly with 11MP, 12MP, and 17MP DSLR's we seem to think that we can enlarge to x12 or x15 with impunity. Well, that takes the blur circle on the print up to about half a millimetre, and even to my middle aged eyes that just looks plain soft! Let alone guaged against the stern standards you've advanced for the limits of resolution.


Gary,
If I've understood your post, you are actually giving an example here of something BJL and I have been discussing on other threads. Increased resolution pays the penalty of shallower DoF.

In all DoF calculators, a specified CoC is required (or assumed by the calculator). If you intend blowing up your digital images to their maximum size at 240ppi without interpolation (about 14"x21" with the 1Ds2) and if you insist on scrutinising these largish prints from the usual close distance you would view a postcard, then the CoC size for DoF purposes should be equal to the pixel pitch of your sensor.

If you are aiming for 'pixel sharpness', which probably requires detail at the resolution limits of the sensor to be transmitted by the lens at 'at least 50% MTF' and possibly 70%, then on a print at 240ppi without interpolation (14x21" with 1Ds2) anything that's not in the focal plane, ie. not in fous, will be seen as such, ie., slightly (or greatly) OOF.

This is actually a serious problem for all pixel peepers. It's due to the fact that a lens can only ever be truly focussed at one plane (although I suspect this might not be true in an absolute sense).

A shining example of this principle would be the pin-hole camera. It achieves tremendous DoF by not being sharp anywhere   .
Logged

BJL

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6600
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #34 on: March 09, 2006, 02:56:33 pm »

Quote
BJL,
Not sure what you mean here.

When I compare f16 with f8, using either my 5D or 20D, I do not see a substantial difference. ... I therefore can't help getting the impression that there really are no 35mm lenses currently available that are diffraction limited at f8.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59830\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Ray,
   which lenses are you talking about?

Do no presume that because your Canon lenses designed for 35mm film cameras (and targetted at good MTF at 10 and 30 lp/mm) are abberation limited rather than diffraction limited at f/8, then so are all current lenses, including ones specifically designed for smaller image circles and the higher resolution of current and future electronic sensors. The other authorities you refer to seem also to be talking about 35mm film camera lens designs.

On the other hand, Thom Hogan sees diffraction limitation with the D2X and Nikon (DX?) lenses from about f/11, and so definitely a difference between f/8 and f/16. And you might remember that Didger said a similar thing about combinations like the D2X and 12-24 DX, making f/8 his diffraction based limit. To examine the state of the art for lp/mm resolution in sensor/lens combinations, you might want to look at a combination like a D2X with a good Nikon prime, or an Olympus E-500 or E-330 with 50/2 or 35/3.5 macro.
Logged

Ray

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10475
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #35 on: March 09, 2006, 10:30:53 pm »

Quote
Do not presume that because your Canon lenses designed for 35mm film cameras (and targetted at good MTF at 10 and 30 lp/mm) are abberation limited rather than diffraction limited at f/8, then so are all current lenses, including ones specifically designed for smaller image circles and the higher resolution of current and future electronic sensors. The other authorities you refer to seem also to be talking about 35mm film camera lens designs.


BJL,
My highest resolving lens is the Canon 50/1.8 ll with a quite respectable Photodo rating of 4.2. I remember the occasion when I bought it. I was curious if this lens could actually deliver more 'absolute' resolution than my medium quality Canon 28-135 IS zoom at 50mm, using my D60 and photographing a Norman Koren test chart. Surprisingly I found that it couldn't.

I then did a number of 'real world' field tests and assiduously searched for detail at 200% and 400% on my monitor,  that might exist in the 50/1.8 shot (at f8) and not in the zoom shot at the same focal length. Surprisingly again, I could not find any such detail.

What I did find, however, was greater accutance in the 50/1.8 shots, and that gave the impression that all 50/1.8 shots were slightly sharper. Even the test chart lines appeared sharper, although there were no more of them to be seen.

For this reason, I use my 50/1.8 in place of the 28-125 IS zoom whenever the shot requires a 50mm FL, provided I am not in a situation where IS would be a definite advantage, and provided I am not feeling too lazy to change lenses.

However, this 'accutance' concept causes me to wonder just how much a really expert and experienced PS user familiar with the best of the 3rd party sharpening routines might be able to achieve in narrowing that accutance gap between the two lenses.

In general, I'd agree that it's better to start off with a 'natural' sharpening, but I'm still surprised at that difficulty I experienced in finding just one iota of significant detail that the higher resolving 50/1.8 might be able to deliver, with a camera, by the way, that has the same resolving power as the 1Ds2. (lp/mm not total picture resolution, for the benefit of those who might get confused).
Logged

BJL

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6600
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #36 on: March 10, 2006, 04:36:11 pm »

Quote
BJL,
My highest resolving lens is the Canon 50/1.8 ll
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59950\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
That is what I thought. Comparing MTF charts, the 50/1.8 II has MTF at 30lp/mm and f/8 comparable to what the Olympus 35/3.5 macro has wide open at f/3.5 and at twice the resolution, 60lp/mm. Except that the 35/3.5 holds resolution far better towards the corners of the frame. Some of the new Schneider and Rodenstock "digital large format" lenses are comparably good at 60lp/mm.

If this appearance that thes new lenses designed for digital cameras roughly double resolution is real, it would move the threshhold of diffraction limitation down to half the f-stop (so it is nice to be able to compare the 35/3.5 at roughly half the f-stop of the 50/1.8.) If so, your observation of diffraction limitation starting between f/8 to f/16 probably moves to the range f/4 to f/8 with at least some of the new digital oriented lenses.
Logged

Ray

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10475
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #37 on: March 10, 2006, 08:02:40 pm »

Quote
That is what I thought. Comparing MTF charts, the 50/1.8 II has MTF at 30lp/mm and f/8 comparable to what the Olympus 35/3.5 macro has wide open at f/3.5 and at twice the resolution, 60lp/mm. Except that the 35/3.5 holds resolution far better towards the corners of the frame. Some of the new Schneider and Rodenstock "digital large format" lenses are comparably good at 60lp/mm.


When I first read the specs of the new Rodenstock 35mm f4 HR, I immediately thought, 'this lens looks as good as some of those Zuiko primes for the 4/3rds format, yet with a much larger image circle'. What's also surprising is that it's a retrofocus design. It would therefore seem that lens design and technology has reached the stage where it should be possible for Canon (perhaps through a contractual deal with Rodenstock) to start offering us Zuiko quality lenses.

Nevertheless, there is a conundrum in this 'sensor quality versus lens quality' issue which I'm having difficulty fathoming.

I've already established for my own purposes that a good prime like the 50/1.8 (good within the panoply of Canon lenses, that is) is capable of imparting greater accutance to an image than a lesser lens, but not capable of greater 'absolute' resolving power of any significance. Of course, the lens is almost certainly capable of greater absolute resolving power than the 28-135 IS at 50mm, but the sensor is capping the results.

This debate about current lenses being inadequate for current sensors is really all about accutance rather than absolute resolution. Just as my modest 50/1.8 produces images that 'appear' sharper than an equivalent image from a zoom lens without providing additional detail in any obvious way, a Zuiko quality lens or Rodenstock HR lens on one of my Canon DSLRs would, I expect. produce images with even greater accutance but probably only a very marginal increase in absolute resolution.

Okay! Here's the conundrum, in big letters in case it's missed.

WHY DO THE OLYMPUS 8MP 4/3RDS CAMERAS NOT SHOW THIS GREATER ACCUTANCE WHICH ONE WOULD EXPECT FROM THE SUPERIOR ZUIKO LENSES?

(compared with the 20D and its low MTF Canon lenses)  
Logged

Lin Evans

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 269
    • http://www.lin-evans.net
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #38 on: March 13, 2006, 04:34:20 pm »

Quote
How many people are actually merging multiple shots for DoF on a regular basis?

Sounds like way more of a PITA then it's worth.    Why not go to a tilt/shift lens or a medium/large format camera with camera movements if you need something that specialized?

Merging the files has got to be even more of a PITA then using film and then having to scan it.

Merging for exposure sounds like a PITA to me, merging for DoF sounds even more crazy... talk about a post processing nightmare.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59802\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Actually more people than you might imagine, and it's extremely easy to do - not a PITA at all. The issue is that for some situations it's the "only" solution where for others it's not the best solution.

Let's take a few examples. Let's say you are doing photomicrography of cell structures or even something as large as tiny insects. A microscope has tremendously small DOF so it's impossible to get all the subject into focus simultaneously. With easily obtainable software I can take a number of frames each with separate focus points using the "best" optical sharpness aperture for the particular lens and combine them into an infinite focus single image in seconds.

To carry this further and even into the realm of landscape photography. I can shoot multiple frames (even as few as three) using the sharpest aperture of my lens and combine them into a single hyperfocal landscape image which is "better" than anything I can get with any single lens.

Now the down side. If the subject or something else moves between frames due to wind, intrusions into the frame from animals, birds, insects, etc., then this method fails. The other downside is that it take two or more frames to accomplish this. But don't sell this short, it's a viable means of increasing DOF and producing incredible results which can't be accomplished any other way.

Lin
Logged
Lin

Gary Ferguson

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 550
    • http://
How Big Is Too Big?
« Reply #39 on: March 13, 2006, 05:22:13 pm »

Quote
With easily obtainable software I can take a number of frames each with separate focus points using the "best" optical sharpness aperture for the particular lens and combine them into an infinite focus

That sounds interesting, can you tell us more about this software?

By the way, I stitch shots all the time with a Phase One P25 on a large format camera, there's several manufacturers now making "sliding carriage" backs for large format cameras. You basically attach the digital back to the carriage and shuffle it around inside the image circle, you don't need software to bring the frames together, the sliding carriage handles it all with pixel accuracy.

I use it for architectural work where it's a breeze. Even if there's people or cars in the shot unless they're actually straddling the dividing line it doesn't matter, even then you can Photoshop them out. The only really tricky problem is when photographing a building across water, then stitching becomes a marathon Photoshop exercise in blending in waves and ripples. But for a 20" x 30" print this delivers the goods with sumptious, "nose to the print" quality.
Logged
Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Up