Example: the 1Ds Mark II has a native file resolution of 4992 x 3328. Without any interpolation, this yields a printed file roughly 11.5 x 17.5 in size @ 285 pixels per linear inch -- no problem.
Eric, I'm afraid we're going to have to agree to disagree on this point. In the earlier days of digital we were mainly limited by the number of pixels at our disposal. So it made sense to measure enlargement capabilities just in terms of pixels, using the 240-360 dpi measure that you referenced. However, we're now getting to the stage IMO where we have to temper that simple linear relationship with some other factors.
Let me give you one example, depth of field. The DOF engravings on manual focus lenses were established in the 1930's, apart from the ASA/ISO standards for film it's one of the few examples where the photographic industry has ever agreed on anything! Rather than have different lens and camera manufacturers competing on who's products gave the greatest depth of field they agreed on a convention that said the image recorded on 35mm film would be considered as "in focus" if an infinitesimal spot in the subject was rendered in the negative as a "blur circle", or "circle of confusion" no more than about 0.030mm in diameter. There was in fact some departure from this standard, Leica engraved their lenses to a slightly more rigorous depth of field standard of about 0.025mm. But basically the convention has held for the last 70 years.
And if you enlarge a 35mm negative say x4, to get the common 4"x6" print, then it's a pretty good guide. That will render the point in the subject as a little blur circle about 0.1mm in diameter. Not quite up to the standard you spoke about but pretty good. And in the good old days of silver darkrooms 35mm enthusiasts like myself regularly achieved really sharp and satisfying 10"x8" prints, and on rare occasions with a really lucky negative we could even go a bit larger.
But suddenly with 11MP, 12MP, and 17MP DSLR's we seem to think that we can enlarge to x12 or x15 with impunity. Well, that takes the blur circle on the print up to about half a millimetre, and even to my middle aged eyes that just looks plain soft! Let alone guaged against the stern standards you've advanced for the limits of resolution.
Let me give you a practical example. Here's a 100% crop from a P25 back with a Hasselblad 100mm lens, it's precisely focused at a distance of 10 metres at an aperture of f11, no sharpening, no nothing.
In the second shot I've shifted the focus by turning the 10m focus mark around the lens, not to the f11 position that Zeiss/Hasselblad say is acceptable, but just a little way to the f5.6 position. So two full stops more restrictive than the recommended DOF limits. To my eye it looks like rubbish!
This is why I say that we've now moved beyond pixel limited enlargement barriers, and we're basically back to the same physical and optical constraints that have capped our photographic ambitions for the last seventy years.
[attachment=316:attachment]
[attachment=317:attachment]