Ice

[thierrylegros396]

Ice, especially for Wayne

Any idea to further improve processing

Thierry

[luxborealis]

Each photograph has its strong point, but none stand out except for the fourth.

If you are able to further simplify the image by reducing the distracting bits (like the small highlights on sticks, etc that are to the left and above the main subject, the icicles) then this had a chance.

It certainly has some rich tones that would benefit from B&W.

[Paulo Bizarro]

Indeed #4 is the strongest, well done.

[francois]

I also chose image #4. Compared to the three other photos, it is very simple with less elements - no distraction. I see this set as a work in progress with the final result being #4.