That's so interesting. These are high ISO files, as I was trying to keep the lights on the chandelier from getting too blown out...so I just used modeling lights...And when I zoom in, they do look similar! Very strange! Unfortunately, it makes C1 useless for this type of toning, since I can't tell what the final output will look like, I guess LR does have it's advantages! I was hoping to wean myself from LR, but I guess I'll keep it!