can you see a difference? if so, do what looks better. if not it's not there.
I know it's fun for some people to geek out and do what's better by the math, but really if you can't see it, it's not there. Resolution, bokeh and sharpness are some of the discussions that get most under my skin, they can all be done by the math or by the look/feel and I argue that wasting time discussing the math absent the feel is just pointless.
In art, if it looks good then it is good.