A couple of years ago when renewing my camera insurance (at a cost which has now overtaken my car insurance) I asked a couple of questions that had been going through my fevered brain. Having had a policy with this company for about 4 years without making a claim I enquired whether there might be any no-claim discount - as is conventionally applied, in the UK at least, with car insurance. The response was something along the lines "it doesn't work like that..." Ie; no.
Hmm, I see. So I asked what to me was the obvious corollary question. If I make a claim, what impact, bearing in mind the size of the claim, would that have on future renewal premiums? In this scenario the answer was "it would increase your premium..." Ok, so what's the relationship between claim size and premium loading? "I couldn't say, sir..." No doubt there are actuarial tables out there that specify exactly what the relationship is but the punters must be protected from them.
So, to summarise: no benefit if you don't claim; a penalty if you do claim.
In the UK the car insurance industry, which complains incessantly about being abused, has inflated premiums based - and I admit I'm guessing - as much on the cost of fictitious competition and the ludicrous volume of advertising which underpins the fiction as on fraudulent claims. In my own case I have had frequent offers to "reduce my premium" from a company who, in fact, already seem to hold my policy - issued through another insurer.
When I investigate the cost savings I discover, unsurprisingly, that once the cover is made exactly equivalent to that which I already have (eg a hire car in the event of an immobilising accident) the premium will be identical. The "savings" which they are offering are based on reduced cover. A friend who works in a specialised area of insurance tells me that the ultimate insurance cover in the UK car sector comes down to only two companies. How much does this edifice of smoke and mirrors add to the premiums we pay?
That's the insurance industry folks, a branch of banking and financial services.
Roy