You guys remind me of the old codger at the political debate.
After the first pol spoke, codger turns to his neighbor and says, "By golly, he's right!"
After the second pol tore apart the first one's arguments, the codger says to his neighbor, "By golly, he's right!"
Neighbor then says, "But wait: they can't both be right."
Codger thinks about that a moment and says, "By golly, you're right, too!"
Eric