Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Help - large prints from M8?  (Read 5886 times)

rvamos

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 41
Help - large prints from M8?
« on: November 15, 2007, 07:19:56 am »

I am looking for some advice on whether the Leica M8 is appropriate for me.  I curently use a Nikon D2X, but it's a very heavy camera with all those lenses and stuff.  I would like to travel with a lighter system.  Most of my photography focuses on people and their environment - portraits, landscapes, etc.  I have a 70-200 zoom (which because of the sensor conversion factor is actually a 105-300), but I find that I rarely use it when travelling.  On the other hand, I see all these wonderful photographs taken by Leica users - except that they use film.  What makes them so wonderful?  The contrast - there really is a "Leica look" that I cannot describe in words.  Now, here is my conundrum: I like making big prints - up to 24x36 inches, sometimes.  Will a 10 mp 8-bit camera like the M8 give me files that can be made into 24x36 prints?  Does the M8 sensor register the "Leica look" just like film does?  Any advice or user experience you can share with me?
Many thanks!!!!

Roberto
Logged

alba63

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 72
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #1 on: November 15, 2007, 12:48:09 pm »

Quote
Will a 10 mp 8-bit camera like the M8 give me files that can be made into 24x36 prints?  Does the M8 sensor register the "Leica look" just like film does?  Any advice or user experience you can share with me?

Hello Roberto, I was almost buying a Leica M8, I had it for a few hours from Leica shop here and read a lot of discussions in the internet about it's qualities and issues. There was one thread on leica-user- forum where a prominent printer from the US who is printing a lot for well- known photographers claimed over a fe weeks that up to 30x40 inches the M8 files hold their own against any MF film scanned and even against 4x5 film.

I processed many of the roughly 100 RAW files I made with the M8 and I must say due to their cleanness at ISO160 and the biting sharpness of the lenses they uprezz very well to 16x24 and even 20x30. But it depends on both, the skills of the printer and the nature of the file: If there is not much of very fine detail (like landscape with foliage) the M8 files are excellent to rez up, however at those sizes in 100% view you can see that there is just not that much there in the finest details. But it looks still quite good so that I would say hte M8 uprezzes at least as good as the 5d (which I have) but 24x36 while possible with certain images is certainly a stretch with this camera. I would say those are print sizes for other formats.

Also don't forget that with the M8 there will be misfocus which reduces sharpness...

Myself I have decided against it in the end, there are just too many imperfections like very unprecise rangefinder frames (it is more guessing that real framing), manual focussing can be slow at times, and more than anything else, a complete Leica system with body + 3 lenses costs easily 10k USD. Would it be perfect, maybe, but it isn't.

Be sure to test it before you spend the money.

Bernie
Logged

StuartR

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
    • http://www.stuartrichardson.com
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #2 on: November 15, 2007, 01:33:19 pm »

Bernie has some very good and sensible points. The M8 is not a camera to just waltz into. It is quite different from DSLR's in both operation and workflow. It is a great performer in certain tasks, but at others it is not well suited. To get good color you need to use IR filters on your lenses, and these increase flare and cause secondary reflections in high contrast situations. If you remove them, you will get IR contamination which can affect color and do odd things like make black synthetic fibers look magenta. If you don't use Leica's special 6 bit coding for the lenses or resort to tricking the system, wide angle lenses that use the filters will have cyan fringing, increasing with the wider lenses. 21mm and wider and the effect will be quite pronounced.

Of course, there is also the differences in its use -- the rangefinder focusing which for some is second nature is a huge pain for others. It has only AE and all the other settings are manual. The framelines are not particularly accurate, even compared to previous M models. High ISO performance is good, but not great...definitely not in 5D, territory, and it is likely to be way behind the D3 in this sense.

In any case, despite all those negatives, it can be a great camera to shoot. It is compact, fairly quiet and unobtrusive, easy to work with if you like rangefinders and it produces beautiful sharp files. The lenses are of course tremendous. Used with the IR filters, color is excellent, contrast is excellent and there is loads of detail. I have printed to 17x22 and it looks great, but I cannot comment on 24x36. It seems a bit optimistic to me. So anyway, if you are a dedicated rangefinder shooter and already have the lenses, I think it is a no-brainer...or at least a good choice, but if you are considering switching totally from Nikon digital, I think you would want to consider it very carefully. Dante Stella has a very good and sensible commentary on the camera at his website. I suggest you read it. http://www.dantestella.com/technical/m8.html

Here are some shots that I have taken with the camera:
This is an image that I shot at ISO 320 with the 35/1.4 ASPH at 2.8 and an IR filter:

This is the 100% crop:

Notice the slight moire in the eyelashes and eyebrow...the lack of an AA filter can cause this...it is worst with details like shimmering water and so on.



Logged

thompsonkirk

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 208
    • http://www.red-green-blue.com
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #3 on: November 15, 2007, 07:05:40 pm »

I can't give just the comparison you want, because I use a 5D/24-105 & an M8, & print 14x21.  

Comparing images from these two cameras, the Leica's images w/ 28mm Elmarit are a bit sharper - certainly in the corners - than the 5D, & small details such as leaves look, well, more leaf-like, because of the absence of an anti-aliasing filter.  

But the difference is slight, & images made with both cameras can be used in the same portfolio.  Only the difference corner sharpness will betray which were taken with which.

For me, at least, the difference has to do mostly with how the camera is to be used, rather than with the last nano-unit of image quality.  I will never again walk across Britain carrying a full-frame DSLR.  But I wouldn't shoot architecture or try to work in a studio or claim to be 100% reliable with a Leica.  Parallax & poor frame-line engineering seem to rule that out, & often a zoom lens is preferable to changing primes &/or cropping.  It's not a work-horse that will do everything.  But it's a camera that is happy to be carried all day, in search of surprises.

So my 2 cents is:

--Read the Stella review, above, & ReidReviews.  

--Decide mainly by shooting style.    

Kirk
Logged

rvamos

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 41
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #4 on: November 15, 2007, 08:30:54 pm »

Thanks for the input, guys.  I'm not thinking of giving up my D2X - it has its applications.  I did have an M8 in my hands for an hour, and really enjoyed the fact that I could NOT shoot quickly with it!  DSLRs are too much of a no-brainer, and sometimes you end up not using your brain, if you know what I mean...  The image quality of the M8 does seem to be superior to DSLRs in terms of sharpness and contrast, and that matters a lot.  If only hte price tag were lower or lotteries easier to win
Logged

william

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 472
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #5 on: November 15, 2007, 09:23:15 pm »

In my old studio in Cleveland, I had 3 36x36 prints on my wall, all printed with an Epson 9800: One from a Canon 1Ds (the original 11 megapixel version), one shot with a Contax 645 with T-max 100 film which I then scanned, and one with an M8.  All were shot handheld.  The M8 file held up to that size every bit as well as the Canon image.  I should note that 36x36 was, however, pushing it for both of these cameras.  The T-Max scan held up much bette).

In short, given good technique and the appropriate subject, yes, you should be able to get acceptable 24x36 images from the M8, but only "acceptable" (not stellar), in my opinion.

I should also note that I had a Phase One P30 medium format back for a while until I sold it recently.  I printed several really large images from the P30, including 36x36 and beyond, and those big prints were head and shoulders above similar size prints from any of my other cameras.  (I know you're looking for portability, so a MF digital kit isn't your goal presumably)
« Last Edit: November 15, 2007, 09:35:00 pm by william »
Logged

rvamos

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 41
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #6 on: November 16, 2007, 06:58:04 am »

Quote
In my old studio in Cleveland, I had 3 36x36 prints on my wall, all printed with an Epson 9800: One from a Canon 1Ds (the original 11 megapixel version), one shot with a Contax 645 with T-max 100 film which I then scanned, and one with an M8.  All were shot handheld.  The M8 file held up to that size every bit as well as the Canon image.  I should note that 36x36 was, however, pushing it for both of these cameras.  The T-Max scan held up much bette).

In short, given good technique and the appropriate subject, yes, you should be able to get acceptable 24x36 images from the M8, but only "acceptable" (not stellar), in my opinion.

I should also note that I had a Phase One P30 medium format back for a while until I sold it recently.  I printed several really large images from the P30, including 36x36 and beyond, and those big prints were head and shoulders above similar size prints from any of my other cameras.  (I know you're looking for portability, so a MF digital kit isn't your goal presumably)
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=153220\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

William, thanks for your input.  How about smaller print sizes, like 16x24 - can the M8 make "stellar" prints in these sizes?  I use an Epson 7600 (yes, a bit old, but they´re very expensive in Brazil, so I need to beat it to death before buying a new one   ).  My goal is to attain the same print quality Sebastiao Salgado´s (ever seen prints of his photos up close? - they are amazing!!!) 16x24 prints have.  I know the standard is very high - I just want to make sure that I won´t be impeded by the equipment to achieve it.  

Also, is the fact that the M8 is an 8-bit camera (according to Michael R.´s review) a limiting factor in terms of final image quality (i.e. do you notice any limitations vs. the Canon, for example)?

THANKS!
Logged

StuartR

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
    • http://www.stuartrichardson.com
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #7 on: November 16, 2007, 08:32:54 am »

When it comes to truly exhibition quality prints, the operator is more important than the camera in many cases. There is a heck of a lot more that goes into a good print than just sharpness. In the wet darkroom for example, I took a class at ICP with Brian Young. He prints for James Nachtwey, Bruce Davidson and many other great photographers. What he was capable of doing with negatives was incredible. Knowledge and skill go a long long way. He had 30x40s from 35mm Tri-X to show us that looked excellent next to 4x5 images of the same size. Were the 4x5's sharper and less grainy? Of course, but the overall impression of the prints from 35mm did not suffer. They were grainy, but sharp and detailed, they had beautiful tonality and richness. This comes from understanding the strengths and weaknesses of the film, developer and lens, choosing the right developer not only in processing but also in developing the paper, dodging and burning precisely and appropriately to maintain a long and consistent tonal range, choosing the right paper, using a glass negative carrier, making sure the enlarger is perfectly aligned, using a great enlarging lens at the optimum aperture, understanding flashing, bleaching, toning and when they can help or hurt your print. There is so much that influences print quality that it is really up to the person making the print whether or not it will come out well. A bigger negative gives you more leeway, but it does not guarantee a good print.

 This is just as true for digital as it is for film. People who understand the digital workflow can upsize very well, they understand when to add and remove noise, how to manipulate the curves for optimum results on paper, how to sharpen for different paper types and printers and so on and so on.

Sorry to carry on, but the reason Salgado's prints look excellent is because the person making them is an expert! I am not saying you are not, but your skill will have the largest impact on the process.

Quote
William, thanks for your input.  How about smaller print sizes, like 16x24 - can the M8 make "stellar" prints in these sizes?  I use an Epson 7600 (yes, a bit old, but they´re very expensive in Brazil, so I need to beat it to death before buying a new one   ).  My goal is to attain the same print quality Sebastiao Salgado´s (ever seen prints of his photos up close? - they are amazing!!!) 16x24 prints have.  I know the standard is very high - I just want to make sure that I won´t be impeded by the equipment to achieve it. 

Also, is the fact that the M8 is an 8-bit camera (according to Michael R.´s review) a limiting factor in terms of final image quality (i.e. do you notice any limitations vs. the Canon, for example)?

THANKS!
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=153295\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Logged

rvamos

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 41
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #8 on: November 16, 2007, 10:16:39 am »

Right you are, Stuart, and I am a long ways from the skill of whoever prints Salgado's photos, but I do hope to get close one of these days...  I just wanted to make sure that the fact that the M8 is an 8-bit camera will not make the task impossible simply because it does not capture enough information.  So I'd like to ask all you M8 owners out there again - do you notice any limitations of the M8 vs. Canon, Nikon or other 12 or 14-bit cameras?  Is this an issue?

Thanks again for your patience.
Logged

thompsonkirk

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 208
    • http://www.red-green-blue.com
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #9 on: November 16, 2007, 10:58:21 am »

Already answered?

Kirk
Logged

StuartR

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
    • http://www.stuartrichardson.com
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #10 on: November 16, 2007, 11:15:27 am »

Quote
So I'd like to ask all you M8 owners out there again - do you notice any limitations of the M8 vs. Canon, Nikon or other 12 or 14-bit cameras?  Is this an issue?

Thanks again for your patience.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=153329\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]


Not in my experience. For what it is worth, the M8 is a 16bit capture device, but Leica made the Raw files 8 bit because they felt there was no difference between a 20mb 16bit m8 raw file and a 10mb 8bit raw file.
« Last Edit: November 16, 2007, 11:17:07 am by stuartr »
Logged

alba63

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 72
Help - large prints from M8?
« Reply #11 on: November 16, 2007, 07:04:54 pm »

@ stuartr:
I believe that what you said about the printer's capabilities and experience is true, with the advent of digital, photoshop and all the plug- ins as well as the possibility to (relatively) control the workflow at every phase leads almost automatically to the idea that everybody can do it.

But I there is certainly a difference between a technically good (sharp, well toned) and an excellent print. The latter certainly takes years of effort and dedication, not to forget talent.

I hope I can learn myself to print better myself through effort and time.

regards,
Bernie
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up