Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Gitzo Tripod: Leveling, Mountaineer or Systematic?  (Read 7570 times)

Gregory

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 191
    • http://www.gregory.hk
Gitzo Tripod: Leveling, Mountaineer or Systematic?
« on: October 16, 2007, 10:53:47 pm »

hi all.

given the possibility of walking/hiking hills, using a 1D Mark III with both a wide lens and the 400 DO lens on tripod, would you recommend:
  • the Gitzo Series 2 Leveling (GT2941LVL) or
  • the Gitzo Series 3 Mountaineer (GT3540L) or
  • the Gitzo Series 3 Systematic (GT3540LS) -- a little short at just 146cm max height; I would prefer the camera to be at eye level where possible; but 146cm does not include the optional column.
I'm having difficulty understanding the important differences between these models and would appreciate any insight the experienced photographers might have. They're all Carbon 6x models, all roughly the same height and all roughly the same weight. The Systematic series is supposedly the sturdiest series but by how much?

I plan to one day purchase and use the 400 DO. Gitzo's data sheet states: "The tripod’s torsion angle should always be inferior to the view angle of the longest focal length lens you intend to use." and they recommend at least a Series 3 for 300-500mm lenses. Has anyone had difficulty using a Series 2 with a 400mm (x1.3=520mm) lense? There's also the question of adding Extenders to the 400mm which would further reduce the view angle and perhaps require more torsional rigidity?

if you happen to be using one of the Gitzo Systematic tripods, are you using a centre column? which one?

at this point, I'm leaning towards getting the Think Tank Rotation 360° backpack to carry my gear when walking the hills (if it's big enough to hold the Mark III and the 400 DO). I'd carry the tripod on the back of the backpack.

regards,
Gregory
Logged
Gregory's Blog: [url=http://www.gregory.

Gregory

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 191
    • http://www.gregory.hk
Gitzo Tripod: Leveling, Mountaineer or Systematic?
« Reply #1 on: October 16, 2007, 10:58:58 pm »

an afterthought.

the tripod's torsional rigidity would only be important if the camera had to be locked down and motionless; eg, for scenery photographs. for photographs where the camera was free to pan and tilt such as when photographing birds with the 400DO, torsional rigidity wouldn't have any impact on the photo. the torsional rigidity would therefore in general only be applicable to my scenery photography. ie, I should be able to get away with a Series 2 ?

comments anyone?

regards,
Gregory
Logged
Gregory's Blog: [url=http://www.gregory.

Sheldon N

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 828
Gitzo Tripod: Leveling, Mountaineer or Systematic?
« Reply #2 on: October 16, 2007, 11:48:47 pm »

I wouldn't use the 2 series for a 400mm lens. You might get away with it in calm conditions with good technique, but if it was a little windy out you'd be wishing for a 3 series tripod.

The Systematic designation just means that it comes with a flat plate instead of a center colum. If you add a center column, it's no longer a "Systematic" series. I believe the 2 series and 3 series Mountaineer tripods come with the flat plate too, so you can take off the center column and just use the plate. Ultimately it's just a question of whether you want to pay more to get a center colum. I'm personnally of the opinion that a center column robs stability (extra joint, plus it works like a monopod), so I'd buy a tripod tall enough to use w/o a center column.

The GT3540LS at 146cm is probably tall enough for your purposes. My Gitzo (older 1325) is 148cm tall and with a ballhead and a 5D (no grip) mounted the viewfinder is exatly at eye level. I'm just a shade over 6' tall for reference. Since you are using a 1D series camera, the added grip height makes up the 2cm difference.

If you aren't too worried about how compact your tripod is when folded, another issue to consider is the number of leg locks. A lot of people prefer 3 leg locks to 4 leg locks, since it's faster to set up/take down.

If you want a 3 section tripod, look at the GT3530LSV. It's 148cm tall and comes with a video bowl that you just remove and replace with the included flat plate (hence the higher price). The main benefit is that the lowest leg sections are thicker diameter than the 3540 and it has fewer leg joints, so there is slightly improved stability.
Logged
Sheldon Nalos
[url=http://www.flickr.com
Pages: [1]   Go Up