Love it when a person attempts an objecti :ve judgment of a subjective matter. How about I tell you Sarah Moons images are out of focus and underexposed? Get it?
But I"d agree with you.
Music, I'm told, is different and much about siinging in tune and not being flat and overly nasal. It's a different ethic.
Were that not so, I would have had a shot at being a pop musician too, despite being unable to play - or even tune - my guitar.
However, he might have been an interesting lyrics writer.
I saw Rod Stewart "singing" to a couple from the UK that had booked a wedding in Vegas (who would do that?) via the collapsed Thomas Cook enterprise. Oh dear... not a good sound, live, and (I hope) without a good sound system to back him up. If charitable, I could try to blame the videographer and sound person.
So many feet of clay out there.
:-)