Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: 5D vs 20D at 20"x30" print?  (Read 3908 times)

dwdallam

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2044
    • http://www.dwdallam.com
5D vs 20D at 20"x30" print?
« on: July 04, 2006, 11:01:45 pm »

My question is much more simple than a laboratory test between these two cameras. I just bought a 5D and have been using a 20D. If I print at 20x30 using PCS2 to process both files, will I "see" a noticible difference in a printed picture at 20"x30" and 12"x18"?

All processing we take to be equal: the same picture taken with the same lens processed using PSCS2 and printed on the same machine.

We're not talking about a screen image here, but what you see after the image is printed.

Thanks!
Logged

picnic

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 574
5D vs 20D at 20"x30" print?
« Reply #1 on: July 04, 2006, 11:24:22 pm »

Quote
My question is much more simple than a laboratory test between these two cameras. I just bought a 5D and have been using a 20D. If I print at 20x30 using PCS2 to process both files, will I "see" a noticible difference in a printed picture at 20"x30" and 12"x18"?

All processing we take to be equal: the same picture taken with the same lens processed using PSCS2 and printed on the same machine.

We're not talking about a screen image here, but what you see after the image is printed.

Thanks!
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=69790\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Well, I don't know about 20" x 30" but I feel sure you would see difference in detail.  Before I sold my 20D, I did a comparison with comparable FL and printed at 11 x 17 on my 2200 (same scene, converted in my usual RC and processed in PCSC2).  Friends, who didn't know anything about the comparison, chose the 5D print every time.  I shot a scene with quite a bit of detail, foliage, etc.---and that's where you really saw the difference.  I also took the same scene with the 24-70 on both but at different FL---and the same comparison was made--again, others chose the 5D print.  I would not say it jumps out and hits you, but it is there.  I have not had a chance to print or have printed anything 20 x 30 from the 5D--but I'm sure I will be very happy with the results when I do.

Diane
Logged

dwdallam

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2044
    • http://www.dwdallam.com
5D vs 20D at 20"x30" print?
« Reply #2 on: July 05, 2006, 09:54:53 pm »

Quote
Well, I don't know about 20" x 30" but I feel sure you would see difference in detail.  Before I sold my 20D, I did a comparison with comparable FL and printed at 11 x 17 on my 2200 (same scene, converted in my usual RC and processed in PCSC2).  Friends, who didn't know anything about the comparison, chose the 5D print every time.  I shot a scene with quite a bit of detail, foliage, etc.---and that's where you really saw the difference.  I also took the same scene with the 24-70 on both but at different FL---and the same comparison was made--again, others chose the 5D print.  I would not say it jumps out and hits you, but it is there.  I have not had a chance to print or have printed anything 20 x 30 from the 5D--but I'm sure I will be very happy with the results when I do.

Diane
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=69791\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Thanks Diane. Anyone else want to chime in?
Logged

Nigelfrommanchester

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 49
    • http://www.nigelatkinson.biz
5D vs 20D at 20"x30" print?
« Reply #3 on: July 06, 2006, 04:20:18 am »

I moved from a 350D to a 5D and I would also say that the differences can be quite subtle at 12x8 (A3+ is the biggest that I print).

When I [repare an A3+ print in CS2 I'm always amazed by the screen detail when applying the final sharpening before printing. However, little of that fine screen detail is actually visible on the prints.

Where I do see a big difference is when I crop. I can dramatically crop a 5D file and still produce a big print that's good enough (for me anyway).

Nigel
Logged
Nigel Atkinson
[url=http://www.nigelatki

dwdallam

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2044
    • http://www.dwdallam.com
5D vs 20D at 20"x30" print?
« Reply #4 on: July 06, 2006, 04:26:28 am »

Quote
I moved from a 350D to a 5D and I would also say that the differences can be quite subtle at 12x8 (A3+ is the biggest that I print).

When I [repare an A3+ print in CS2 I'm always amazed by the screen detail when applying the final sharpening before printing. However, little of that fine screen detail is actually visible on the prints.

Where I do see a big difference is when I crop. I can dramatically crop a 5D file and still produce a big print that's good enough (for me anyway).

Nigel
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=69899\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Agreed. Doing some slight cropping and getting a better or same ppi as the 20D has its advantages. However, if you are cropping to get teh same telephoto as teh 1.6 magnification factor on the 20D, you will end up with less pixels then the 20D can produce. In otehr words, if you use your len's longest setting on both the 5D and 20D and then crop the 5D to match the 20D, you will have lost pixels compared to the 20D file--given that you don't crop the 20D file. That's one reason I am keeping my 20D. Mounted on my 20D with a 1.4 extender and my 70-200 I have the equivalent of a 448mm F4 L lens.
Logged

gochugogi

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 80
    • http://emedia.leeward.hawaii.edu/frary/
5D vs 20D at 20"x30" print?
« Reply #5 on: July 06, 2006, 02:11:58 pm »

Compared to my 20D, moderate and large landscape prints have a medium format look to them. There's a lot more resolved detail, e.g., blades of grass, foilage, etc., that are pleasant but soft in the 20D print. With larger subjects and portraits the differences are less striking. Finally, because 5D images require less enlarge for any given size than 20D images, noise is far less apparent, even on my Cinema Display.
Logged
[span style='font-family:Impact']I'm try
Pages: [1]   Go Up