IMO the question is 'If not Galbraith / ProPhotoCommunity, then where?' It takes a critical mass of informed posters that I don't find on some sites (I won't name names). Where will professional photographers & especially fine-art photographers go for info & advice: Here? ProPhotoCommunity? Somewhere else?
I hope that either (a) Michael will beef up this forum, or ( the former Galbraith forum will re-admit its banned 'bad boys' & succeed.
Of course folks like Andrew should be reinstated & the moderating should be more intelligent. With those conditions, I suppose the former Galbraith forum would be worth $25/year. As one of Rob's notes mentioned, the forum didn't bring in advertising revenue, & it takes valuable time & energy to administer a large forum. I noticed that another forum, pro4um, also charges a fee.
I found RG the easiest place to seek information. There were only a couple of places where I could ask questions and get answers at a level that was helpful me. It was helpful, for example, to have Chuck Westfall replying to questions about how Canon equipment is supposed to work - or Andrew or Ethan Hansen, in former times.
I've used the PixelGenius forums for technical PS questions, but you have to be a client there, & some of the Geniuses haven't been posting much of late.
This (LL) forum offers experienced & helpful discussion, but it isn't organized into as many discrete categories as the RG forum was, & it has fewer forum members. I don't have time to read through a lot of stuff under a few headings to find what I'm looking for.
I'd really like to see a larger forum for fine-art photographers, with more stuff about how technical & aesthetic matters interact. For example, discussants sharing experience of how the new Crane, Hahnemuhle, & Innova papers work, with the original Ultrachrome & the K3 inksets in both BW & color. This seems to be a good site for that, & I wonder if Michael would want to host discussions on a larger scale. This would be a good outcome of the Galbraith melt-down!