OK, seems like there aren't too many people concerned about density! ;-)
I guess that many people are shooting the likes of landscapes and portraits, so that 'when it looks right, it is right'. Objectively correct colour balance and density aren't really an issue like they would be when photographing table-top product in a studio (when the tub of yoghurt needs to look exactly that shade of green and no other!) or, as in my case, artwork for reproduction.
So, let me summarise what I wrote in my original post and ask if it makes sense.
There are two issues. Colour balance and density. Here I am only interested in density. e.g. how bright/dark should that yellow be?
As a means of arriving at density, does this make sense?
In C1 (I always use C1. I hate the histogram in Camera Raw. No grid, no numbers and no sliders attached. In addition to which, it isn't near as sharp on my screen as the C1 histogram. Very muddy in fact. But, I realise it's horses for courses.) assuming that we have exposed to the right (ETTR):
1. Move the right slider to the left until it reaches the toe of the histogram, but without overlapping it in any way. Moving it to the right will usually be necessary because opening up the camera an extra 1/3 during shooting would have pushed it into overexposure. The slider permits much smaller increments.
2. Move the left slider to the right until it reaches the left toe of the histogram. This will usually be around the 33/37 mark. (Again C1 wins out for me here since the toe is very visible and the warning feature is very sensitive.)
Your image will now look a lot punchier. It will have a bit more contrast and a bit more saturation. All we have done is to move both sliders to their logical extremes. i.e. in as far as they can go without blowing highlight or shadow, but no further.
In essence, what we have done is to set the white and black points manually with the sliders, rather than use the eye dropper. Much more accurate for critical work, in my opinion.
The problem is the middle (mid-tone) slider. We have no indicated point on the histogram to where we can move this one which would us that final 'tranny' look.
Or do we? Here's a suggestion....which works best for studio based work.
Shoot a frame (in the same light, obviously) of a Gretag Macbeth Colour Checker. I am suggesting this product because the correct values of each patch (not the ones that Gretag issue which are considered incorrect) are available here..........
http://www.creativepro.com/story/feature/21351.htmlWith this image to hand..........
3. Adjust the left and right sliders on the Gretag image (as described above)
4. Now move the middle slider to the right until the RGB values of the mid-grey at the bottom of the checker are as near as possible to 104/104/104.
5. Read the numerical value of the middle slider - usually around 85-95 - and apply this value to your first image. This should add the final touch. You now should have an image that has the punchy, saturated look of a transparency.
Make sense?
D.