Recent Works Thread - Critiques?

[dwdallam]

I think it would be a good idea for people with constructive ideas to add those to photos in the Recent Works thread. I think it would be great if Micheal could set up a "Works" thread that allowed you to post one image for every one good critiques you give.

The guidelines would be something like at least a short sentence that would help the image and thus help the photographer.

What do you all think?

[Josh-H]

I think it would be a good idea for people with constructive ideas to add those to photos in the Recent Works thread. I think it would be great if Micheal could set up a "Works" thread that allowed you to post one image for every one good critiques you give.

The guidelines would be something like at least a short sentence that would help the image and thus help the photographer.

What do you all think?

Its not a bad idea - but there is already a 'user critiques' forum for that sort of thing - maybee sufficient?

[dwdallam]

Its not a bad idea - but there is already a 'user critiques' forum for that sort of thing - maybee sufficient?

I didn't know that existed. Is it active?

[Josh-H]

I didn't know that existed. Is it active?

User Critiques

[dwdallam]

User Critiques

Thanks. There is also Photo Sig which employees a strict critiquing guideline before you can upload. Seems to be successful.

[HickersonJasonC]

Thanks. There is also Photo Sig which employees a strict critiquing guideline before you can upload. Seems to be successful.

Photosig and sites like it are run by popularity whores for the most part. You know the type, "I'll thumb up yours if you thumb up mine." ; ) Don't expect many useful critiques there.

I think the User Critiques section here is plenty.

[dwdallam]

Photosig and sites like it are run by popularity whores for the most part. You know the type, "I'll thumb up yours if you thumb up mine." ; ) Don't expect many useful critiques there.

I think the User Critiques section here is plenty.

Yeah that sounds about right--lol.