Thanks for these John.I hope you don't mind but I have an alternate suggestion for the third image - just to get an idea of isolating colour and texture. You can yourself play with aspect ratio's and corresponding balance of colour within the image.Julie
I also like the reflection in #3. I find that it resembles (with different colors) northern lights photos. The rain drops add somehting dynamic to the otherwise very calm image.The "frosty" surface on the water of photo #2 is intriguing. I like its horizontal nature vs the vertical trees.
John, I'm a raindrop guy too. I'll vote for #3 along with the majority. All three shots are good, though at first I assumed you'd shot them in reverse order, but dropped your camera between the second and third.