Hi Dave,
This photo is all about the colors - black gold, and magenta make for a wonderful combination.
My opinion is to chop the off the bottom 1/2 of water, (about 1/8 of the bottom photo) to make it less
bottom heavy. I think it is being kept there unnecessarily.
You're only getting about 4 extra star reflections, not enough IMO to sacrifice overall composition.
Great photo otherwise.