... In your series I like the first equally.
What's different in the first, is that the church is lit. The lights go off as soon as the sun appears. It happens sometimes that just as I finish setting up the tripod, cable release, etc. and ready to press the shutter, the lights go off in that same instant. Bummer!
The reverse situation happened in Slovenia last November. After shooting a church at sunset, and when the last rays of sun disappeared from distant mountain tops, clouds moved in, it is getting darker and darker, so I said "that's it for today" and started collapsing the tripod and packing. And then I noticed they turned on the lights on the church. So I shot just one frame hand-held, 200mm, 1/30s, f/2.8, ISO 2000: