Luminous Landscape Forum
The Art of Photography => Street Showcase => Topic started by: drmike on January 01, 2020, 10:28:59 am
-
It has to be street but showcase implies quality :)
(https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/49309862238_b666d134d9_o.jpg) (https://flic.kr/p/2i8kW7A)
It was a very hurried shot taken in a cowardly manner. He was in fact conscious. Probably a lovely guy but he was doing this in the wrong part of town.
Mike
-
Plenty ambiguity. It is street!
-
Good one I think.
-
Good grab, Mike. What was "cowardly" about it?
-
Very good "Street."
-
I don't think it's street at all: I think it's very good photographic art. Pure and simple.
Too good to be street.
Rob
-
Too good to be street.
Rob
;D 8)
-
;D 8)
Not a knock at the shins of street; a reference to the technical precision and composition that takes it elsewhere, in my mind at least. Too perfect, in other words, for one genre but a great example of another.
:-)
-
Thanks Rob. I was trying for a good composition using the 'found' subject which is what I usually do.
Cowardly because I wasn't big and bold and I was quite concerned he might regain consciousness. I wasn't too worried but in a foreign place and a clearly unpredictable subject it's fair to say I didn't own the street.
Ambiguity? I don't go for that idea much and I don't think there is any. The guys is just spaced out on a bollard.
Thanks for the kind comments though, they are appreciated.
-
Thanks Rob. I was trying for a good composition using the 'found' subject which is what I usually do.
Cowardly because I wasn't big and bold and I was quite concerned he might regain consciousness. I wasn't too worried but in a foreign place and a clearly unpredictable subject it's fair to say I didn't own the street.
Ambiguity? I don't go for that idea much and I don't think there is any. The guys is just spaced out on a bollard.
Thanks for the kind comments though, they are appreciated.
It is good to read you bring it back into its proportion.
Personally, I don’t see the ambiguity, I even don’t see the value of photographing a passed out dude. I understand your cowardly feeling.
I think shots like this works better if no attempt was made to find a kind of arty composition.
Color could help to bring it alive.
Just my five cents tough. 😬
-
I know what you mean Ivo.
However, I prefer to take photographs with composition which I think this has. To me it's an image that happens to have a passed out dude in it who contributes to the composition by breaking it up a bit. He also coils round his chosen post very nicely. I couldn't pass it up.
It is a full colour image. I don't think I destaurated at all. It's outside some huge IT company in San Francisco, SalesForce I think and I was really surprised that firstly he wasn't moved on and secondly that I wasn't told off for photographing on what must have been private property although used as a public path.
The money these corporates have is obscene and the way they spend it equally so.
-
ambiguous
/amˈbɪɡjʊəs/
Learn to pronounce
adjective
open to more than one interpretation; not having one obvious meaning.
"ambiguous phrases"
not clear or decided.
"the election result was ambiguous"
Similar:
equivocal
ambivalent
open to debate
open to argument
arguable
It isn't obvious to me why he was in that pose. Picking himself up/ asleep/ being sick/ or just resting? Whatever it makes you think about the image and that what makes it work?
-
ambiguous
/amˈbɪɡjʊəs/
Learn to pronounce
adjective
open to more than one interpretation; not having one obvious meaning.
"ambiguous phrases"
not clear or decided.
"the election result was ambiguous"
Similar:
equivocal
ambivalent
open to debate
open to argument
arguable
It isn't obvious to me why he was in that pose. Picking himself up/ asleep/ being sick/ or just resting? Whatever it makes you think about the image and that what makes it work?
Everything is ambiguous, depending on the viewers awareness / willingness / understanding. ...
-
Everything is ambiguous, depending on the viewers awareness / willingness / understanding. ...
The viewer is almost always the problem.
That's why unless you do it for pay, you have to please yourself and the hell with the other people. Especially with the second-guessers, who insist they know better than you do what was in your mind.
Rob
-
It is fun though, to see one of these 'ambiguous' images and build your own story. As ever it's more about you than the image, what you bring as context for the interpretation.
Putting it crudely - if you ask an artist 'what does it mean' they'll almost always bounce back with - 'what do you think it means'.
-
The viewer is almost always the problem.
That's why unless you do it for pay, you have to please yourself and the hell with the other people. Especially with the second-guessers, who insist they know better than you do what was in your mind.
Rob
Hear, hear. Of course that doesn't happen on LuLa. ???
-
Hear, hear. Of course that doesn't happen on LuLa. ???
Of course not: banned by decree!
:-) :-) :-)
Rob