Luminous Landscape Forum
The Art of Photography => User Critiques => Topic started by: mdg on June 24, 2013, 05:04:30 am
-
Again...would appreciate your thoughts
-
I like everything about this. It's highly stylized, but I think all the styling serves the central idea very well, and it's a very very strong picture. Well done!
-
I have to say way over done, in my view.
-
IMHO the moving grass ruins the atmosphere because it doesn't correspondent with the majesty of the mountain (which I really like!)
Harald
-
Mountain, cloud are magnificent. What bothers me is the moving grass and too strong vignetting. The grass blurriness is either too much or not enough.
-
IMHO the moving grass ruins the atmosphere…
My thought exactly, you couldn't have said it better.
-
Thank for sharing your thoughts. Much appreciated (bow)
-
Mountain, cloud are magnificent. What bothers me is the moving grass and too strong vignetting. The grass blurriness is either too much or not enough.
Yup. That about sums it up.
Mike.
-
Personally I think the white cloud and the movement of the grass complement each other nicely. There are plenty of similar images without the movement to be seen so this is a pleasant change. However I think it is a type of image that could be seen as overdone if you persisted in doing all of your images in the same fashion, just like some like to HDR every image the take.
-
Overall I like the photograph. I rather like the moving grass. I think it adds an interesting and original touch in an otherwise static scene. But I agree with Slobodan that the vignetting is a little too much of a good thing. It would be instructive to see what the same shot looks like with less of it.