Luminous Landscape Forum
Equipment & Techniques => Digital Cameras & Shooting Techniques => Topic started by: Fred Ragland on September 05, 2007, 11:20:55 am
-
Like many of you, I am accumulating a large collection of hard drives and wiring snaggles. I've read about Drobo (http://www.drobo.com/) (Data Robotics) as a way to simplify exernal storage requirements and saw a mention of it on Jeff Schewe's PhotoshopNews Lightroom Live Tour report.
Is anyone on the list using Drobo? If so, what do you consider its pros and cons to be?
Thanks in advance,
Fred Ragland
-
Like many of you, I am accumulating a large collection of hard drives and wiring snaggles. I've read about Drobo (http://www.drobo.com/) (Data Robotics) [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=137481\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Fred,
Nice catch. I would be interested in how it compares with the soon-to-be-released Windows Home Server. I suspect the pricing will be comaparable but with greater capabilities in WHS.
Ron
-
I've been using the drobo for a few months now. It has a very easy Mac-like setup (even the packaging is Mac-inspired) for someone who wouldn't be completely comfortable with setting up a RAID. It seems very well made and the software seems good.
The fan can be a tiny bit noisy for the sonically sensitive user but no more noisy than my G5 tower's fans which I got used to a long time ago.
Also, it's not the fastest thing around. There's no problem copying the 4 GB daily job to it but transfering a whole archive would probably take pretty long.
All in all, I like it.
-
I chatted with them at photoshop world for a while. Seems like a terrific product - the concept is wonderful, about as painless to use as any external drive I've seen, especially considering the ability to just add drives or increase drive sizes pretty much on the fly.
The only negative is the slow USB 2.0 interface.
After visiting with quite a few photographers they said they are currently reviewing options and may design a unit with FW 800.
If they do I'll buy one. May buy one anyway, since I'd probably just use it to backup files, not work with the files.
-
This device uses a proprietary storage method.
If the data became corrupt, who would be able to recover the data? There won't be any third party data recovery tools (as you can get with RAIDs).
I really like the idea of this device. But one has to think of the worst case scenario and how one would recover from it.
I wish the company and its developers well, but I would only feel happy using this as a secondary archive rather than as the only copy of data. However, in that case, a cheaper solution such as the Sonnet Fusion eSATA 500P enclosure would be just as effective but have a faster data transfer time due to the eSATA interface.
-
I've been looking into this device recently as it's a brilliant idea.
But, some people have had issues with it and as noted above it's proprietary. So only Drobo can sort it out, if possible. So you may need to back it up which kind of defeats the point. Though I believe it does have battery power in case of powercuts, which is reassuring.
The major stumbling block seems to be the fact that it's simply a big [albeit clever] ext drive. Firewire 800, Ethernet, NAS are what it needs to realise its full potential.
And it's a tad too expensive.
I'll wait for v2.0 myself.
-
This device uses a proprietary storage method.
If the data became corrupt, who would be able to recover the data? There won't be any third party data recovery tools (as you can get with RAIDs).
I really like the idea of this device. But one has to think of the worst case scenario and how one would recover from it.
I wish the company and its developers well, but I would only feel happy using this as a secondary archive rather than as the only copy of data. However, in that case, a cheaper solution such as the Sonnet Fusion eSATA 500P enclosure would be just as effective but have a faster data transfer time due to the eSATA interface.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=138464\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
One of it's strengths is it backs itself up. Bascially it is a dyamic raid device, and will use whatever drives and sizes you install to create the most efficient raid possible, be it striped or raid 5, or a combination. As you add drives, or change to larger drives, it rebuilds the data and again makes the best use of the space.
So a "painless, dynamic" 4 drive raid. Theoretically at least. It hasn't been around too long.
I do agree, I think it's a great device for secondary backup, but probably not suited for a working drive.
-
I think it's a neat device. Expandable... can hold a fair bit of data (though the USB 2.0 limitation imposes a maximum volume size of 2 TB which means if you use 1 TB drives you'll have a 2 TB volume and a ~700 GB volume), is pretty small and thus portable.
Main negative in my mind is the USB 2.0 thing. That makes it slow (I think it's maybe 15 MB/sec read/write. USB 2.0 is "rated" at ~45 MB/sec but that's a bald-faced lie... USB 2.0 sucks as a data protocol compared to Firewire (400 || 800) or eSATA).
Personally, I use an Infrant ReadyNAS. It has 4 drives in RAID 5, and it can easily share them via AFP/SMB/NFS/DAV/HTTP(s), etc. So I slap it on the network and can get to all my files from any machine. If you have some cruddy Windows machines alongside those nice shiny Macs then this is a HUGE plus, because with Drobo you need to format it as HFS+ or NTFS which means sharing data is a lot tougher.
Anyway... if you're willing to spend the 45 minutes to set up up and have a network the ReadyNAS IMO is the best bet (it's also faster -- I get maybe 30 MB/sec to it). The ReadyNAS is ~650 "empty" plus the drive costs, so it's $150 more than the Drobo. If you can live with the Drobo's limitations (volume size limit and speed), its extra simplicity may make it a better fit.
Oh -- and just to be 100% clear on this -- RAID (or DROBO's proprietary protection stuff) is NOT NOT NOT NOT NOT a backup. LET ME BE AS CLEAR AS POSSIBLE ON THIS. NEVER assume that you can just have data on a "protected" device and have that be your "one true source" of your valuable images. Because this does NOT protect against the cause of 45% of all data loss, which is user error. It also doesn't protect against natural disasters (earthquake, fire, sprinklers go off), so you should ALWAYS have at least one additional copy, and you should ALWAYS keep it off-site.
Personally, when I import from LightRoom I have one copy of my images go to my local drive, and I have one set of images go straight to the ReadyNAS. I really should have a 3rd copy offsite and once every couple months I update an external HD that I swap with one at a friend's house.
-
Has anyone tried Amazon's Simple Storage Service (http://aws.amazon.com/s3)?
-
Oh -- and just to be 100% clear on this -- RAID (or DROBO's proprietary protection stuff) is NOT NOT NOT NOT NOT a backup. LET ME BE AS CLEAR AS POSSIBLE ON THIS. NEVER assume that you can just have data on a "protected" device and have that be your "one true source" of your valuable images. Because this does NOT protect against the cause of 45% of all data loss, which is user error. It also doesn't protect against natural disasters (earthquake, fire, sprinklers go off), so you should ALWAYS have at least one additional copy, and you should ALWAYS keep it off-site.
My worst data loss occurred when I powered on two external hard drives in reverse order. They ended up on the wrong drive letters. Not paying attention I let my sync software destroy all my new files. Then I did my system upgrade that whacked the drive with the third copy of the data.
I recovered thousands of images off of DVD. But I wasn't religious about burning DVDs so I missed a few. (Including one of my all time favs. I still have it. At 1024 wide.)
The loose nut at the end of the keyboard is a bigger problem than most of us would like to admit. But it sure nailed me.
-
This device uses a proprietary storage method.
If the data became corrupt, who would be able to recover the data? There won't be any third party data recovery tools (as you can get with RAIDs).
I really like the idea of this device. But one has to think of the worst case scenario and how one would recover from it.
I wish the company and its developers well, but I would only feel happy using this as a secondary archive rather than as the only copy of data. However, in that case, a cheaper solution such as the Sonnet Fusion eSATA 500P enclosure would be just as effective but have a faster data transfer time due to the eSATA interface.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=138464\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
I agree. Like the Lacie Big Disk, if one drive goes down you potentially lose everything on both drives; it's happened to a friend, and is about to happen to my studio mate if, if the mechanical clunks and groans from a dying hard drive are any indication (they are).
The Drobo claims that it can rebuild a failed drive automagically, but until I see it work every time without fail I remain...skeptical. I'm more inclined to stick with "standard" solutions like external drives and RAID boxes.
-
I agree. Like the Lacie Big Disk, if one drive goes down you potentially lose everything on both drives; it's happened to a friend, and is about to happen to my studio mate if, if the mechanical clunks and groans from a dying hard drive are any indication (they are).
The Drobo claims that it can rebuild a failed drive automagically, but until I see it work every time without fail I remain...skeptical. I'm more inclined to stick with "standard" solutions like external drives and RAID boxes.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=139816\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Drobo's ability to rebuild automatically in the case of a failed drive isn't something I'm overly worried about. That's not that difficult to do -- it's similar technology to RAID. So I'd pretty confident in this. And Drobo's flexibility with this (namely that you can mix and match drives and grow the volume by growing the file sizes) is a significant benefit. I'd be WAY more likely to use a Drobo for external local storage than something like the La Cie disks. If the La Cie loses a drive you'll lose all your data -- with the Drobo this is specifically what they're guarding AGAINST.
Again, though, the one thing I am vehement about is that you cannot have this be your ONLY mechanism for ensuring safety of data. RAID is not a backup. It is protection against hardware failure. There are other mechanism for data loss than the failure of a hard drive. Many more
-
Drobo's ability to rebuild automatically in the case of a failed drive isn't something I'm overly worried about. That's not that difficult to do -- it's similar technology to RAID.
Yeah, but it isn't RAID, it still uses a proprietary hardware controller to make it's magic happen, and requires software to manage that isn't needed with other solutions, which introduces another yet potential failure point.
Again, though, the one thing I am vehement about is that you cannot have this be your ONLY mechanism for ensuring safety of data. RAID is not a backup. It is protection against hardware failure.
Exactly, which is why RAID is great as a work drive where speed is important, and lets you recover from a single drive failure. But the Drobo isn't built for that, it's built for backup. As clever as it is, I'd rather trust my work on hard drives that can be plugged into any computer without a proprietary controller and software layer in the loop.
It's already a problem with external 1394 and USB drives that sometimes need to be cracked open and have the bare drives plugged straight into a system to get at the data. That's bad enough, but at least you're normally dealing with standard file systems and interfaces so that data recovery is possible directly from the operating system, and/or utilities that support the process. I've been dealing with this for years and it's a constant, ongoing problem that I don't see this thing solving, as slick as it may seem to be.
IOW, no matter how much better it is than similar systems, the proprietary controller and management software are still the weak points in the chain as an archiving solution. If the box that holds the drives goes down, there's nothing you can do without repairing or replacing exactly the same box. And if the host computer goes down, you have to install their proprietary software onto something else to get your data back...which may or may not work, especially if the company goes out of business, and their last firmware/software rev doesn't fly on a newer computer...
The Drobo is certainly a nice backup product from a workflow perspective, but is it the best archive solution? Not in my opinion.
-
It's MAJOR drawback for any use except backup, is the excrusiatingly slow transfer speed of USB2. I had contacted them earlier this year, in hopes they had a new product with a high speed interface on the drawing board. they flat out said no, and they have no interest in doing so. They rationalized the USB connection as being the lowest common denominator, and think most people will buy because of that.
Personally, I'm looking for a high speed, networkable (100/1000), JBOD server. I need about 4TB at the moment, to convert a library of DVDs, and it will need room for expansion. Right now there are solutions, but they are in the $1000-$1500 + drives range.
It looks like a cool product with potential, but there are better and/or cheaper solutions for anyone looking for just a backup unit.
-
Something with all the benefits of the drobo and none of the drawbacks is this: http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/content/view/30155/75/ (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/content/view/30155/75/)
It doesn't have enough space for what I need (only 4 bays) but if were expandable or had 8 bays, I would get it.
-
Something with all the benefits of the drobo and none of the drawbacks is this: http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/content/view/30155/75/ (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/content/view/30155/75/)
It doesn't have enough space for what I need (only 4 bays) but if were expandable or had 8 bays, I would get it.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=140072\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
The Infrant ReadyNAS kicks that thing to the curb ;-)
I have one, and it's awesome.
But it only has 4 bays, which means that today, you can only get about 2.8 TB of storage on it (with 4 x 1 TB drives in RAID 5).
-
Actually, it's quite a bit slower, but in fairness it is a year old: http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/content/view/24945/75/1/7/ (http://www.smallnetbuilder.com/content/view/24945/75/1/7/)
-
...It doesn't have enough space for what I need...[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=140072\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
What do you need, how could you do it and what is the cost?
Thanks.
Fred
-
With a RAID 5 or 10 array I need at least 8TB, and need something expandible - lots of bays. When I move my collection from DVD to HDDVD and Blu-Ray, my needs will increase even further.
Right now the cost is either $35k turn-key, or DIY about $5000 - too much in either case right now, it's not that important. I'll live with a few thousand DVDs on the shelves.
-
It's MAJOR drawback for any use except backup, is the excrusiatingly slow transfer speed of USB2.
Not entirely true, it depends on the device. A properly implemented USB2 interface - on both sides of the cord - is on par with FW400. For data transfer, realtime transfer speeds can stutter because of OS interrupts but that's only important if you're working with something audio or video. For backup, it's fine.
Firewire 800 is certainly better for striped RAID work drive setups, but eSATA and Fiber Channel is even better, at least if you're running faster than 7K hard drives.
But all that's out of my price range, so I just back up to duplicate external drives. One stays at the studio and the other goes home with me. When the drives gets full I simply print a folder list, put them away, and buy two more.
Anything recent or other things I want quick access to stays on my work drive, but the bulk of my archive resides on the shelf. A bit inconvenient if I want something from it, but very large storage arrays where my life's digital work is always available, are far too expensive for me right now.
The duplicated external drive solution is inexpensive, safe and effective, and plenty fast enough for backup and archiving. The only time I'm vulnerable is if my work drives suddenly fails before I've backed it up, but then RAID setups have their own share of drawbacks, like if you accidentally delete a file it also gets deleted on it's mirror.
FWIW, I always bring an external drive with me on a location shoot if there's any chance that I'll exceed the capacity of my flash cards. Of course I backup to my laptop every time a card is full, but I don't erase the CF card until it's data is in two other places.
-
You just agreed with me, I don't know what you are saying isn't true...
eSATA or high speed ethernet is a magnitude above USB and firewire, it's not even comparible.
Given this is a photo board, it's safe to assume people are talking about large photo files. My particular application happens to also include large video files - both working and archive.
Here on my video processing station I happen to use 500GB eSATA drives. They are not expensive whatsoever. $9 for an enclosure, and $65 for an adaptor card. My home machine didn't even need the card, it's built on to the motherboard.
If you don't think USB is useless for working files just do this - put one of your CF cards in and make that your CS swap file drive, then utilize it. Enjoy the nap DO the same on a high speed transfer drive and it's night and day.
-
I still fail to grasp in what respect the drobo is any better than a bunch of big redundant external firewire (or eSATA) drives for backup. (I take it all are agreed that it's essentially a backup solution, not a live data solution.)
Nill
~~
www.toulme.net (http://www.toulme.net)
-
Because you can mix and match any size, brand and speed HDs in it - it makes them all hot swappable and redundant with 100% availability. It's not unique in this, but it's cheaper than the competition.
-
The same is true of separate individual firewire drives — they're just not all in the same enclosure. And there's nothing proprietary about the way they store your data. Drobo sounds like "RAID, sort of, for dummies" to me, but I'm sure I'm missing something.
Nill
~~
www.toulme.net (http://www.toulme.net)
-
What you're missing is the spanning of the info over one partition, which I don't believe individual drives can do.
Sure I can plug in all 8 of my external drives, but that's not the same as a big RAID array with 8 drives.
-
And why is that an advantage for backup?
Nill
~~
www.toulme.net (http://www.toulme.net)
-
And why is that an advantage for backup?
Because your backup is safer by being in a redundant array (assuming other than RAID 0). You can lose a drive (or more possibly) and still recover.
-
Well it's no safer than two completely redundant external drives.
I'm not arguing against RAID, understand. My live data is on a 1.1TB RAID5. But I back up to simple, redundant, external firewire drives, some of which live offsite.
So far all I can glean about Drobo is that it's kind of like RAID, but not really. It's main advantage is that you can mix and match drive sizes. (You can do that with RAID too, of course, but you're limited by the size of the smallest drive.)
Is that it? Is it really so much easier to live with than a real RAID that it makes up for its proprietary format and slow interface? Or is it really just that it's marketed to photographers and seems easier to them? Do they understand that it is NOT inherently a backup unless and to the extent it's used properly as such?
I'm not arguing, I'm trying to understand the product. So far I think I do not.
Nill
~~
www.toulme.net (http://www.toulme.net)
-
Got you. From what I can understand, you pretty much explained it. Of course if you're planning a RAID system from scratch, you'd get all same drives anyway. And if Drobo is utilizing all asymetrical drive space, then there's going to be a trade-off, and it's probably performance.
-
Nil, I don't know if you are just conviently ignoring 1/2 of the features everytime you post, or just baiting the discussion under the guise of claimed ignorance.
If you truely believe a RAID device is the same as 2 or more external independant drives, then you need to read up a lot more on RAID.
It's REALLY simple:
The device (and others like it) does the following:
- Uses any mix of drives for storage material
- Provides for complete redundantcy
- Provides uninterupted data access
- Makes each drive hot swappable
- Provides a single addressable volume
- Is instantly upgradeable in size by swapping for larger drives, with no inturuption
There is nothing unusual in that it uses a proprietary format for the data storage. Every raid controller is the same way. You can't take an array off one controller and use it with another.
Individual external drives can not, and are not designed to, do these things.
The advantages of this device over others is the price point and slick interface. The use of multiple mismatched drives with redundant storage is also fairly unique.
Yes it takes a performance hit *when compared to dis-similar raid setups optimized for speed*. I am not aware of another setup with a redundant JBOD array using mismatched drives that has been reviewed for an apples to apples speed comparison.
The one huge drawback of this device over others similar is of course the external transfer interface, being USB2. They do not market this as a backup only device, so get over your little self-made argument. *We* as users (most) are simply stating that ANY drive relagated to a slower protocol rather than the faster modern alternatives, is better suited to backup duty than live data.
-
You can also start with small drives and slowly upgrade them. So if you have a couple of 200g drives you can start. As you add drives you can add larger ones. Eventually you swap out the small ones for bigger ones. The device does all the work. You don't have to keep copying data around every time you do that.
All of that is from memory. I haven't read up on the device in a while but I believe that was one of the key features.
-
Yes, the key features are the flexibility and the ability to mix and match drives. You can start with 2 drives, and it gives you the same space as if you had them mirrored. Then you add a third drive, and it gives you the space you'd have with a 3-drive RAID 5. Add a 4th, and it gives you the space as if you had a 4-drive RAID 5.
And all this is done automatically. With ordinary RAID you'd often have to back up everything, move it off, delete the RAID sets, and reconstruct. So this kind of flexibility IS a really nice thing. Is this product the be-all end-all? No. It's pretty slow, it's USB 2 (i.e. no NAS), etc. Still, for a big chunk of backup storage I'd use this thing over some janky La Cie drives any day (I know lots of people who have had issues). I personally use an Infrant ReadyNAS because I like the NAS ability, but it's not as flexible as the Drobo.
But the Drobo is WAY nicer to manage than a box full of drives in firewire enclosures where you have to wonder what's on which drive... maybe you write the contents in felt tip pen on the outside. Or put a big sticky label on there. I've seen it
-
You might want to check out what's coming in 2008. USB 3.0 (http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9780794-7.html)
-
Yep, and by 2009 we might have some devices for it
-
You might want to check out what's coming in 2008. USB 3.0 (http://www.news.com/8301-10784_3-9780794-7.html)
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=140963\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
I'm sure that's the solution
There are a number of current interfaces, including Firewire 400, Firewire 800, and eSATA that would do a great job today -- with markedly larger computer support than USB 3.0.
-
Just to add another data point...I've got a Infrant ReadyNAS NV. Infrant has had some great support and the product works fine, but you'll never be able to use it for anything but a backup because its way to slow even with a direct connection to the computer with 1Gb nic . It takes nearly a whole weekend to sync my 0.7Tb aperture library with verify and most of a day to do the 0.3Tb Lightroom library.
Backups for digital suck compared to film negatives. You can't really expect to get by with just one backup, plus you need a UPS for your back up and working volume, and you always have to worry about technology leaving you in the dust. Buy a new computer and your RAID card might not work anymore.
That's why I have the ReadyNAS as a second backup because its ethernet instead of a hardware RAID. Nice to have two formats.