Luminous Landscape Forum
Equipment & Techniques => Digital Cameras & Shooting Techniques => Topic started by: MikeMike on April 15, 2007, 11:39:59 pm
-
How would i go about calculating how much ND i need and what aperture to select when i want to make an exposure past 30 seconds, all the way to 30 minutes or more? is it up to mathematics at that point or is there a formula? which i guess goes back to mathematics but anyhoo..
Anyone know?
Thanks,
Mike
-
How would i go about calculating how much ND i need and what aperture to select when i want to make an exposure past 30 seconds, all the way to 30 minutes or more? is it up to mathematics at that point or is there a formula? which i guess goes back to mathematics but anyhoo..
Anyone know?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112605\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
There's no reciprocity factor with digital; an 8-stop ND requires an exposure 256x as long, AOTBE.
However, you can get better results by taking a series of shorter exposures and adding/stacking them together, because signal adds 100% constructively, while noise only adds in a fractionally constructive manner. The only issue is the blackout time between frames; you need to keep them very short to avoid gaps in things like trails.
-
There are 60 seconds in a minute and 60 minutes in an hour.
-
There are 60 seconds in a minute and 60 minutes in an hour.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112612\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
so are you saying get the exposure time for one minute then double it every stop or so?
Thanks,
Mike
-
There's no reciprocity factor with digital; an 8-stop ND requires an exposure 256x as long, AOTBE.
However, you can get better results by taking a series of shorter exposures and adding/stacking them together, because signal adds 100% constructively, while noise only adds in a fractionally constructive manner. The only issue is the blackout time between frames; you need to keep them very short to avoid gaps in things like trails.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112608\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Thank you, but what I would like to do is capture the motion of something whithin 30 minutes, IE water, clouds, etc.
Anybody know?
Thanks Mike
-
How would i go about calculating how much ND i need and what aperture to select when i want to make an exposure past 30 seconds, all the way to 30 minutes or more? is it up to mathematics at that point or is there a formula? which i guess goes back to mathematics but anyhoo..
Anyone know?
Thanks,
Mike
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=112605\")
The basic idea is that you'd want to use the slowest film (lowest ISO) and the smallest aperture to get the longest time. If you're metering ISO 100, f/22 at 1sec, then a 5-stop ND filter would have an adjusted exposure of f/22 at 30 seconds.
ISO 100, f/22 @ 1sec (no filter)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 2sec (1ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 4sec (2ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 8sec (3ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 16sec, which is typically rounded to 15sec (4ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 32sec, which is typically rounded to 30sec (5ND)
If you need longer exposures, then you'll either need to lower your ISO, stop down more or use a stronger ND filter.
On your DSLR, most cameras only go as low as ISO 100, but the 1DS-MKII can go to ISO 50. If you're shooting film, then you have more options to choose from, especially in B&W.
Most likely, the lenses you're using with your 35mm will have a smallest aperture of f/22 and possibly f/32. However, if you're shooting large format, there are some lenses that can be stopped down to f/128.
Singh-Ray sells excellent ND filters ranging in strength from 1 to 5 stops, but they also make an adjustable ND filter that goes up to 8 stops. Check it out: [a href=\"http://www.singh-ray.com/varind.html]Vari-ND[/url].
Last, keep in mind that if you really want to explore long exposures, this is where I feel film still has an advantage over digital. You won't have to deal with noise and the effect of reciprocity failure can work to your advantage, thus allowing you to get really long exposures.
-
ISO 100, f/22 @ 1sec (no filter)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 2sec (1ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 4sec (2ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 8sec (3ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 16sec, which is typically rounded to 15sec (4ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 32sec, which is typically rounded to 30sec (5ND)
Finally a real answer... Thank you Bodenzord.
This really did help, and that varifilter looks really interesting and cool, expensive though.
Thanks Again ,
Mike
-
Mike,
Just remember that if you're using TTL metering, the exposure will adjust automatically. So, look at the cameras meter before and after you place the filter.
Good luck and have fun!!!
Mike
-
Let us know how your experiments turn out - post images or links.
Tip: Search forum for "Atta Kim"
-
Mike,
Just remember that if you're using TTL metering, the exposure will adjust automatically. So, look at the cameras meter before and after you place the filter.
Good luck and have fun!!!
Mike
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112784\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Let us know how your experiments turn out - post images or links.
Tip: Search forum for "Atta Kim"
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112851\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Will do!
Thanks guys,
Mike
-
Just make a little hole with a pin in a piece of black cartoon and put it on your lens.
You might make some test to find the right position and the right exposure...
Good luck
-
If you need longer exposures, then you'll either need to lower your ISO, stop down more or use a stronger ND filter.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112778\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
As an earlier poster already pointed out, digital gives you an additional option of stacking multiple exposures to capture motion over an extended period of time. This requires much less aggressive application of neutral density filters and has the advantage of averaging sensor noise out of the final image (effectively increasing your dynamic range).
The best technique for achieving this is to set the camera up for a 15-second exposure, lock up the mirror and find a way to keep the shutter firing for the duration of the exposure that you require to capture movement. you will also need to ensure that the aperture is fixed (manual or AP). If you are doing a 30 minute exposure you may want individual shots to be 1-minute to keep the number of frames to be stacked manageable.
In photoshop stack the images (you can use merge to HDR to make things quicker) and then flatten the layers. There is also specialist software (astronomy) that does facilitate this process though I haven't gone down that particular route.
I've done this a few times up to 5 minutes, though nothing as ambitious as 30 minutes.
This is a stack of (perhaps) 15 images:
(http://www.pbase.com/mexmoon/image/40334775.jpg)
-
look s really nice
-
...
On your DSLR, most cameras only go as low as ISO 100
...
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112778\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
You can go even (s)lower, by picking your lowest ISO and then going to the appropriate menu on your camera to underexpose by another two stops.
Andy
-
Singh-Ray sells excellent ND filters ranging in strength from 1 to 5 stops, but they also make an adjustable ND filter that goes up to 8 stops. Check it out: Vari-ND (http://www.singh-ray.com/varind.html).
Mike, you used the Vari-ND? I found it vignetted (on an original 1Ds) at focal lengths around 33mm and wider, and that that there were some weird artifacts at the highest filtration factors. I'm on the road now so I don't have the original test images, but I'm curious if you've observed the same thing.
I've switched to using fixed NDs for stuff like this.
-
Mike, you used the Vari-ND? I found it vignetted (on an original 1Ds) at focal lengths around 33mm and wider, and that that there were some weird artifacts at the highest filtration factors. I'm on the road now so I don't have the original test images, but I'm curious if you've observed the same thing.
I've switched to using fixed NDs for stuff like this.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=124193\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
I'm starting to test a Vari-ND right now, the wide angle version without front threads. The widest I've gone so far is 24mm on a 1.3 crop Canon 1D2 or about 31mm equivalent. I'll test wider lenses next.
The only time I got artifacting (cross bar effect) was when I went beyond the maximum marked setting, and Singh-Ray warns about this.
Paul
-
There's no reciprocity factor with digital; an 8-stop ND requires an exposure 256x as long, AOTBE.
However, you can get better results by taking a series of shorter exposures and adding/stacking them together, because signal adds 100% constructively, while noise only adds in a fractionally constructive manner. The only issue is the blackout time between frames; you need to keep them very short to avoid gaps in things like trails.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112608\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
I use a 10x filter and sometimes stack a 10x + a polarizer (12 stops). While it is true that there is
no reciprocity failure there is a significant loss of contrast, and it pays off to overexpose at
least by 1 stop.
Another problem I had in the past doing extreme-long exposures is changes in ambient light.
If you meter and set the camera to the time during the exposure is made a cloud can pass
by in the meantime.
dmg
-
As an earlier poster already pointed out, digital gives you an additional option of stacking multiple exposures to capture motion over an extended period of time. This requires much less aggressive application of neutral density filters and has the advantage of averaging sensor noise out of the final image (effectively increasing your dynamic range).
...
Stacking works well at night, but not during the day if you have clouds. The clouds keep moving,
and between frames you get slight "jumps".
Noise is an issue, so I turn noise reduction on (Canon). That increaes the gaps between exposures.
Even if the exposures are short and you don't need noise reduction the time betwen frames (seconds) create some artifacts in the clouds.
This is an example:
http://turingmachine.org/silvernegative/in...g-exposure.html (http://turingmachine.org/silvernegative/index.php?/archives/659-Long-exposure.html)
10 exposures (middle of day) each 1.6 seconds were combined. Look at the clouds.
That is why I generally favor a single exposure:
http://turingmachine.org/silvernegative/in...-the-ocean.html (http://turingmachine.org/silvernegative/index.php?/archives/661-Into-the-ocean.html)
This one is 160 seconds (also during the day) with 2 filters stacked together (for a total of 14 stops ND).
dmg
-
There are 60 seconds in a minute and 60 minutes in an hour.
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=112612\")
This is a 1hr exposure with a 20d in an almost dark room (only lit by the computer displays)
[a href=\"http://turingmachine.org/~dmg/temp/061006_0484.JPG]http://turingmachine.org/~dmg/temp/061006_0484.JPG[/url]
and same picture with very aggressive dust removal:
http://turingmachine.org/~dmg/temp/061006_0484-dust.jpg (http://turingmachine.org/~dmg/temp/061006_0484-dust.jpg)
So I agree, the best solution is stacking images. The stacking can be done with several algorithms depending on what your intentions are.
dmg
-
ISO 100, f/22 @ 1sec (no filter)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 2sec (1ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 4sec (2ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 8sec (3ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 16sec, which is typically rounded to 15sec (4ND)
ISO 100, f/22 @ 32sec, which is typically rounded to 30sec (5ND)
Finally a real answer... Thank you Bodenzord.
Mike
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112780\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
If you are new to ND filters, be careful with the density specification. The list above is for ND filters labeled by f/stops. It is common for ND filters to be labeled by "optical density", which is the base-10 logarithm of the transmission. So for example a filter with ND = 3.0 would attenuate by 10^3 = 1000 = 2^10 = 10 f/stops. This filter would enable you to increase the exposure time by a factor of 1000, while a 3 f/stop filter would only give you a factor of 8.
-
If you are new to ND filters, be careful with the density specification. The list above is for ND filters labeled by f/stops. It is common for ND filters to be labeled by "optical density", which is the base-10 logarithm of the transmission. So for example a filter with ND = 3.0 would attenuate by 10^3 = 1000 = 2^10 = 10 f/stops. This filter would enable you to increase the exposure time by a factor of 1000, while a 3 f/stop filter would only give you a factor of 8.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=124890\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
I think it depends on the manufacturer. I have in front of me a B+W, which is labeled as you explain (1000x, and ND 3.0).
But I also have a Hoya ND 400, which is 400x, or ND 2.6 using the B+W notation. I am also looking at a 3 stops hoya one that is labeled ND 8 (hoya notation).
dmg
-
I'm starting to test a Vari-ND right now, the wide angle version without front threads. The widest I've gone so far is 24mm on a 1.3 crop Canon 1D2 or about 31mm equivalent. I'll test wider lenses next.
The only time I got artifacting (cross bar effect) was when I went beyond the maximum marked setting, and Singh-Ray warns about this.
Paul
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=124251\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Paul et al.
Thinking about the Vari-ND for my 5D on 17-40, 24-105, and 70-200.
Any further comments you might have on the "thin" Vari-ND filter, it's "vignette-safe" focal lengths, and it's performance on Canon camera's would be very much appreciated.
I assume for the price that the build quality is top notch?
Many thanks from Tasmania,
Thomas
-
How would i go about calculating how much ND i need and what aperture to select when i want to make an exposure past 30 seconds, all the way to 30 minutes or more? is it up to mathematics at that point or is there a formula? which i guess goes back to mathematics but anyhoo..
Anyone know?
Thanks,
Mike
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=112605\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
This is how I do it...
Set my camera to its highest ISO and biggest apeture, then the cameras light meter show how long shutter time I should use.
Lets take an exemple :
1Ds Mark II on ISO 3200 f/2.8 with 5second shutter time.
f/2.8 ISO 1600 = 10sec
f/2.8 ISO 800 = 20sec
f/2.8 ISO 400 = 40sec
f/2.8 ISO 200 = 80sec
f/2.8 ISO 100 = 160sec
f/4 ISO 100 = 320sec
f/5.6 ISO 100 = 640sec
f/8 ISO 100 = 1280sec
f/11 ISO 100 = 2560sec
f/16 ISO 100 = 5120sec
f/22 ISO 100 = 10240sec
f/32 ISO 100 = 20480sec
Then I just devide resault into 60 to get minuts.
Might be many other better ways to do this, but this works well for me...
Here is a shot I made here in Denmark on a Phase One P30 digital back, 45sec exposure.