Luminous Landscape Forum

Equipment & Techniques => Digital Cameras & Shooting Techniques => Topic started by: POP on March 12, 2007, 09:38:54 am

Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 12, 2007, 09:38:54 am
Hello All    

I have an EOS 20D, and on the whole am very happy with it, unless I am trying to take pictures facing the sun where the sun is reflected off of water, where I am getting red around sparkles!

Using the Canon viewing software the redness is visible in the thumbnails, when you view the image in the viewer utility before it has fully loaded the image and you get to see a very low res image the redness is there until the full res image loads and the redness is gone (and that is the only way I can see these images without redness!).

In all Adobe software (Bridge/CS2) the redness exists, and the redness prints aswell  

Examples:

Peter
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: Tim Gray on March 12, 2007, 10:48:15 am
do a search for "Purple fringing" - or chromatic abberation, there's a dialog in ACR or Lightroom under Lens Correction that let's you minimize the effect.  Not sure how effective Lightroom would be against a JPG (you could try) and obviously the ACR dialog is only available for RAW.
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 12, 2007, 12:16:00 pm
Quote
do a search for "Purple fringing" - or chromatic abberation, there's a dialog in ACR or Lightroom under Lens Correction that let's you minimize the effect.  Not sure how effective Lightroom would be against a JPG (you could try) and obviously the ACR dialog is only available for RAW.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106252\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I have tried the Chromatic Aberation adjustment in ACR, it helps but this clearly is not a case of CA, and is not fixable with ACR unfortunately.  The JPG images supplied have nothing to do with the purple fringing, I can provide a DNG image or a CR2 image or a PSD image that look just like the JPG images.

People have talked about wide/ultrawide angle lenses being responsible for CA but the images supplied are at 40mm (64mm) and it occures with my tele zoom lens aswell    

Admittedly I have not read all the posts I found (tired and ready to go to bed) but I read people stating that the purple fringing is not an issue with the 20D, and yet I strongly beg to differ, so I am wondering is it a fault with my particular camera, though I doubt it frankly.  Are there any 20D owners out there that recognise my purple fringing?

I read (for example) Jonathan Weinke's method of curing it and will try that I guess, though I was hoping for some magic way of making it not show up in the first place really hehe, none the less thanks for the reply Tim  

Peter
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: francois on March 12, 2007, 12:36:32 pm
Quote
I have tried the Chromatic Aberation adjustment in ACR, it helps but this clearly is not a case of CA, and is not fixable with ACR unfortunately.  The JPG images supplied have nothing to do with the purple fringing, I can provide a DNG image or a CR2 image or a PSD image that look just like the JPG images.

People have talked about wide/ultrawide angle lenses being responsible for CA but the images supplied are at 40mm (64mm) and it occures with my tele zoom lens aswell   

Admittedly I have not read all the posts I found (tired and ready to go to bed) but I read people stating that the purple fringing is not an issue with the 20D, and yet I strongly beg to differ, so I am wondering is it a fault with my particular camera, though I doubt it frankly.  Are there any 20D owners out there that recognise my purple fringing?

I read (for example) Jonathan Weinke's method of curing it and will try that I guess, though I was hoping for some magic way of making it not show up in the first place really hehe, none the less thanks for the reply Tim 

Peter
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106262\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Try a different RAW converter. Your purple fringing might be somewhat reduced. Other than that, you'll need to lessen PF in Photoshop. Also, have you tried to remove your front UV filter? I've rarely seen such severe PF, even when I shoot near water.
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: Tim Gray on March 12, 2007, 03:35:47 pm
So you've peaked my curiosity - can you post a link to a DNG?
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: dlashier on March 12, 2007, 04:08:03 pm
Demosaicing artifacts due to channel clipping. As already mentioned, some raw converters will handle this much better than others. C1 is worth a try if you haven't tried already.

- DL
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 12, 2007, 04:34:26 pm
Quote
So you've peaked my curiosity - can you post a link to a DNG?
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=106293\")
Oki Doki, I'm not sure about how to do this but I will give it a try  

the same as the example one:
[a href=\"http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com/images/115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).dng]115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).dng[/url]

and similar one but from EF 70-200mm F4L @ 70mm:
115527_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_(with_2_boats)_-_Paekak_hilltop_(70mm).dng (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com/images/115527_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_(with_2_boats)_-_Paekak_hilltop_(70mm).dng)

If the links work I will leave them there for awhile but will delete them eventually since they take up alot of space...

Seems they do work when I previewed them so have a look and let me know what you think, my curiosity was tweaked awhile back    

Peter
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 12, 2007, 04:49:36 pm
Quote
Demosaicing artifacts due to channel clipping. As already mentioned, some raw converters will handle this much better than others. C1 is worth a try if you haven't tried already.

- DL
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=106301\")

Pardon my lack of knowledge in the achronyms DL, and good to have your feed back, but what is 'C1' (I understand it is a RAW converter, but is it a plug in for PShop or stand alone, or...)? and where do I get it?  and does it cost an arm 'n a leg?

Peter
P.S. POP stands for [a href=\"http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com]pictures of paradise[/url] (shamless plug for my site)
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: DarkPenguin on March 12, 2007, 04:55:46 pm
Capture One.  Go to Phase One to try a demo.  Probably www.phaseone.com
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: BernardLanguillier on March 12, 2007, 06:54:12 pm
I have found Raw Developper to be good at getting rid of similar issues.

RD is unfortunately only available for Mac at this stage.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: dlashier on March 12, 2007, 09:58:26 pm
Peter, if you want to send me the raw file I'll give it a try in C1 and post the result. There's an upload file link on my "about" page.

- DL
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 13, 2007, 05:46:19 am
Hi all again, it has been a busy day  

I went to PhaseOne and downloaded a 15 day trial of CaptureOneLE and eventually got a chance to give it a try...

Surfice it to say that Adobe Camera Raw and CaptureOne are quite different to each other, since I have used ACR all my digital life, I have come to feel right at home with it, and found C1 clumsy and imprecise to use, but I guess with time it would get better (perhaps).  However the crux of the matter!

With C1:
 

Digital processing is just incredibly complex, though saying that, I guess it is not that different, but it's just that all the adjustments are in my hands now and I am coming upon a steep learning curve. I was ready to fork out US$99 for C1 but now I'm not so sure again  

Perhaps Dlashier I could take you up on your kind offer and upload a DNG file to you and see what you make of it? It would be great to remove all my uncertain methods and have someone who really knows what they are doing can reveal    If you left a mail at my site with a password for the file upload section perhaps?

Cheery
Peter
Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: Ben Rubinstein on March 13, 2007, 07:58:26 am
Looks like blooming to me. That is (I think) where the pixels next to blown out pixels get some sort of light leak from the blown out areas which appears red/purple. I've not found a good way to get rid of the problem but it often occurs with edges where one side is blown out and the other is not, you will see it often in sunsets for example.
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 13, 2007, 08:30:50 am
Quote
Looks like blooming to me. That is (I think) where the pixels next to blown out pixels get some sort of light leak from the blown out areas which appears red/purple. I've not found a good way to get rid of the problem but it often occurs with edges where one side is blown out and the other is not, you will see it often in sunsets for example.
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=106393\")

Maybe the individual pixels of the sensor needs little tiny lens hoods...  Or possibly larger sites on a larger sensor, but then you would be buying a 5D   It is ashame that Adobe seem to have fallen short on incorporating the phenomenon into their algorythums quite as well as apparently some other software makers have.

Bed time here in New Zealand (way past it actually) so good night  

Peter
[a href=\"http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com]Pictures of Paradise[/url]
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: dlashier on March 13, 2007, 02:27:14 pm
Peter, I forgot that upload requires a password. I'll have to look it up later but I'm pretty certain that it's "upload".

- DL
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: Tim Gray on March 13, 2007, 07:02:38 pm
Probably the result of the nasty clipping.  It can be fixed at the cost of some major desaturation (my first play with the targetted saturation tool in Lightroom), but the chromatic aberation tools in LR didn't do much.

[attachment=2089:attachment]
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: dlashier on March 14, 2007, 05:08:29 am
Quote
Probably the result of the nasty clipping.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106531\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Yup Tim, I agree.

and btw Peter, the pw is "upload" as I thought. Nothing secret here, just trying to keep out the teenies who stumble on the site.

- DL
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: John Sheehy on March 14, 2007, 09:12:23 am
Quote
I have an EOS 20D, and on the whole am very happy with it, unless I am trying to take pictures facing the sun where the sun is reflected off of water, where I am getting red around sparkles![a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106239\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

That's infrared light, in too strong a dose for the hot-cut filter to cut it out.  What is happening is that the curves in the water are making parabolic mirrors that increase the intensity of light in certain spots, and your lens is not focusing the IR as well as the visible, so you get strong IR right outside the blown-out areas.
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: John Sheehy on March 14, 2007, 09:17:40 am
Quote
Admittedly I have not read all the posts I found (tired and ready to go to bed) but I read people stating that the purple fringing is not an issue with the 20D, and yet I strongly beg to differ,[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106262\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

There are three distinct phenomena that people call "purple fringing".  In your case, it is infrared light that is out of focus, and doesn't blow out with the visible light.  Different lenses focus IR differently.

Some people call CA "purple fringing" which is a really bad idea, IMO.

The other thing is that CCD sensors can "bloom"; pixels can saturate and overflow charge into their neighbors.  This overflow is generally from green into red and blue pixels, and the daylight WB calls for boosting red and blue anyway, so the leakage converts as a purple or magenta color.
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 14, 2007, 08:15:25 pm
Don, I tried the upload link but I got a page that said there was a problem    try right clicking this link and downloading it to your HDD:
115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).dng (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com/images/115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).dng)
(I dont normally have understrokes in my file names but for the purposes of transfer I have included them)

John, it is great to read your break down of the problem and it rings true for the example included.  I guess when you have pin point lights in a night time scene it would be the CCD sensor bloom?  I do whole heartedly agree that calling CA 'purple fringing' is highly misleading and tends to make it hard for people that are trying to discuss one thing not to have it confused with another thing (however similar they may be infact).

Cheery
Peter
Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 14, 2007, 08:34:42 pm
Quote
Probably the result of the nasty clipping.  It can be fixed at the cost of some major desaturation (my first play with the targetted saturation tool in Lightroom), but the chromatic aberation tools in LR didn't do much.

[attachment=2089:attachment]
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=106531\")

I just noticed your attached file Tim, thanks for the effort!  I agree about the desaturation, and in the crop, or even with the whole image it is tempting to do that (not that the particular image is likely to be used for anything, but it does exhibit the purple fringing especially well), even if the desaturation were masked down to the locale of the PF itself, and something that I will bear in mind for the future, but I am also interested in understanding the effect better in the hope that it may reveal some solution available within my existing workflow.

As for the CA adjustment, I found that since it is not CA, trying to remove it with CA adjustment just created more of a multi coloured effect, which was not satisfactory at all hehe.

Cheers
Peter
[a href=\"http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com]Pictures of Paradise[/url]
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: John.Murray on March 14, 2007, 10:58:26 pm
I agree with others, the original exposure is blown - here is acr4(from cs3 beta)screenshot:
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 14, 2007, 11:13:18 pm
Quote
I agree with others, the original exposure is blown - here is acr4(from cs3 beta)screenshot:
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=106707\")

There is no doubt in anyones mind I think that the image is blown, it is absolutely blown Joh, but from my experience many pictures endure being blown without suffering purple fringing.

Very interesting seeing the screenshot of CS3 though!  It shows a lot of new sliders there, I am curious whether the new ones are a new way of doing the same things with the old sliders?  Also I am wondering why the WB is stated as being 'Tungsten'?

Peter
[a href=\"http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com]Pictures of Paradise[/url]
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: John.Murray on March 14, 2007, 11:28:11 pm
pop:

i open the first link directly into Photoshop 3 with no changes (I doubled checked  )

ACR4 settings are basically identical to Import/Develop features of Lightroom 1.0, just a different UI

I love the image btw
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 15, 2007, 12:42:14 am
Quote
pop:

i open the first link directly into Photoshop 3 with no changes (I doubled checked  )

ACR4 settings are basically identical to Import/Develop features of Lightroom 1.0, just a different UI

I love the image btw
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=106714\")

I just checked, the version I have here is identical except the WB is 'As Shot' and Temp is 5450, Tint +5, strange but not so important i guess...

The picture is from a place called Paekakariki in New Zealand.  Every time I am there I am blown away by the majesty of the view, and this was another attempt to catch it.  I intend making a panorama of 4 pictures, the far left one being this:

Peter
[a href=\"http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com]Pictures of Paradise[/url]
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: John Sheehy on March 15, 2007, 08:52:03 am
Quote
Don, I tried the upload link but I got a page that said there was a problem    try right clicking this link and downloading it to your HDD:
115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).dng (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com/images/115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).dng)
(I dont normally have understrokes in my file names but for the purposes of transfer I have included them)

John, it is great to read your break down of the problem and it rings true for the example included.  I guess when you have pin point lights in a night time scene it would be the CCD sensor bloom?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106681\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

The 20D's CMOS sensor does not bloom.  Purple/magenta edges around pinpoint lights are most likely OOF IR with a 20D.

Take a shot of the heating element in a toaster or toaster oven, manually focused.  Note the sharpness of the coil.  Then, put on an IR pass filter and take it again, focus unchanged.  You will have an OOF purple/magenta coil.
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: dlashier on March 15, 2007, 03:22:19 pm
Quote
Don, I tried the upload link but I got a page that said there was a problem   Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106681\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Peter, my system probably didn't like the gawd-awful long filename. I've dl'd from your link and will try it in C1 tonight.

Edit: looked at the error log and it was the unmatched quote (apostrophe) you put in the description. Oversight on my part as I should encode this input.

- DL
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 16, 2007, 09:53:09 am
Quote
Peter, my system probably didn't like the gawd-awful long filename. I've dl'd from your link and will try it in C1 tonight.

Edit: looked at the error log and it was the unmatched quote (apostrophe) you put in the description. Oversight on my part as I should encode this input.

- DL
[{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a] (http://index.php?act=findpost&pid=106833\")

     The 'gawd-awful long filename' is an attempt to keep myself at least semi aware of what is in all my files, you think it's gawd-awful, you wanna (not) try naming them all, it really is a chore, but I press on valiantly (thick headedly) trying to ignore that I am up to my armpits in these files, and they increase in number daily...

I got no email telling me that you had posted a comment here Don, but I just came to say thanks to everyone for helping me and that you have all made me feel quite honoured to have recieved your help!  I see I have had a big influx of traffic at my website aswell, which is nice, and I hope it was enjoyable to visit

Anyway I'm looking forward to your conclusions Don.  Btw your picture of Yake-Me is just wonderful, the way he holds himself is there to see, and very special!  I dont know who he is but I think he is a great man. You moved me and that is what it is all about I believe.

Peter
[a href=\"http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com]Pictures of Paradise[/url]
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: dlashier on March 19, 2007, 03:51:09 am
Quote
Anyway I'm looking forward to your conclusions Don.  Btw your picture of Yake-Me is just wonderful, the way he holds himself is there to see, and very special!  I dont know who he is but I think he is a great man. You moved me and that is what it is all about I believe.

Peter
Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=106979\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Thanks Peter, Yake-Me is one of my personal favorites also. Believe it or not this was taken handheld from about 75 feet from the dancer on stage, ISO 200 (because 1D is not good at high ISO). Fortunately it was a slow dance. Also note that he "squinted" throughout the dance - wasn't just bad timing.

re your image, I finally found time tonight to check it out but for some reason C1 will not open the DNG even though it opens other DNGs like Leica M8's just fine. Can you upload or post the original raw file? (just leave any ' out of the description).

- Don
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 19, 2007, 05:42:32 am
Don, did you mean ' as in apostrophe? I am sure there are none in the name   Sometimes when I upload files they get corrupted but I checked that before linking them and they seemed fine, darn finicky things these computers    

115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).CR2 (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com/images/115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).CR2)
115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).xmp (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com/images/115526_Sunlight_reflected_from_the_sea_-_Paekak_hilltop_(40mm).xmp)
Here we go; there's the CR2 file and its sidecar XMP file.

This would make it third time lucky wouldn't it?

All the best
Peter
Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: pminicucci on March 19, 2007, 12:34:25 pm
Peter: Since you listed the CR2, I thought I'd try DxO to "cure" the purple fringing/IF OOF issue. Here's the result:

(http://homepage.mac.com/minicucci/.Pictures/115526_Sunlight_reflected_cropdxO.jpg)

This is a 100% crop, at native resolution, using ACR's 20D defaults (no other adjustments). Did a pretty decent job, I think.
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 25, 2007, 01:28:30 am
Pat, the image looks great!  I think I am satisfied where the PF is coming from now.

I have downloaded a trial copy of DxO and it seems pretty wizzy i must say.  A program that creates so many files and projects etc disturbs me though, like Bridge and Version Cue does.  I'm sure that all the projects and files would be useful for someone, but I always thought it nice to have one file per picture (2 at the most).  Just a gripe about over complex things that store important information in places I dont know about and dont understand...

Perhaps in the future I will think about buying another Raw converter, but for the time being I cannot justify the expense for the few images that need the extra attention.

Thanks to all poster's for your input and effort, you have all been most informative  

Cheery O
Peter
Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: POP on March 25, 2007, 03:46:36 am
When I look at images now, i see how 'blunt' an instrument ACR is!  It is relatively easy to learn and to use, but seems lacking somehow.  Perhaps later versions will be better, but that is the 'catch phrase' of computers isn't it, as the intent of the computer gets more and more sopisticated and complex, all the 'tools' needed to work with the intent become more sophisticated and complex, and more expensive     It drives me crazy  

Having another play and a read of the DxO's help file impresses me more and more, it is very full featured, and moderately userfriendly.  Well I know that if I want to do better justice to my cameras pictures that seems to be the way to go.

Just adding some more detail to my thoughts while this topic is still top of the que, that's it now though  

Peter
Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
Title: Red edges to Sparkles from EOS 20D
Post by: John Sheehy on March 25, 2007, 09:33:25 am
Quote
When I look at images now, i see how 'blunt' an instrument ACR is!  It is relatively easy to learn and to use, but seems lacking somehow.  Perhaps later versions will be better, but that is the 'catch phrase' of computers isn't it, as the intent of the computer gets more and more sopisticated and complex, all the 'tools' needed to work with the intent become more sophisticated and complex, and more expensive     It drives me crazy   
Pictures of Paradise (http://www.pictures-of-paradise.com)
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=108556\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

What RAW converters need is a plug-in system, to alter the files before the converter does its unique thing.  Each converter has its strengths and weaknesses.  ACR might be the best for removing horizontal banding in images; it removes/interpolates hot and dead pixels, etc, but there are a few things it still doesn't do well, like reject chroma information at extremely-high contrast edges in the demosaicing algorithm.

I looked at your DNGs in the RAW state, and it is a little difficult with the color moire and over-exposure, but it seems that even where the sparkles are not clipping the RAW data, the edge pixels tend to be mostly blue and red, and very little green, reinforcing my OOF IR idea.  This could have been verified with an under-exposure, which would probably be about 3 stops darker to keep the sparkles (or at least some of them) from clipping.  Fortunately, even if converters don't address the IR issue per se, some may address CCD blooming, which has similar end results, like DxO (Or they may be aware of both problems).  A filter that simply avoids hi-res color around high-contrast edges in general probably helps, too.