Luminous Landscape Forum

Equipment & Techniques => Digital Cameras & Shooting Techniques => Topic started by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 12:46:03 am

Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 12:46:03 am
I have a 5D and have been trying recently to play family photojournalist and take some people pictures at some recent events which are indoors at night.

I am using the Canon 24-70mm L lens wide open at f/2.8 and I have the camera's ISO amp'ed up to 1600.  However, in the typical illumination of the various rooms in the house I am getting shutter speeds of 1/8 to 1/25.  Even at 24mm this is barely enough to eliminate camera shake.  At 70mm (which is what I prefer), this shutter speed is way to slow.  

Needless to say, 1/25 isn't fast enough to stop the action of the kids playing with the new baby, etc., etc.   Do I have to use ISO 3200?? Do I need a faster lens?  Not sure if the 50mm 1.4 will do it as it is only 1 stop faster.  I won't even go into the fact I already have too little DOF as it is....  

I hate to underexpose due to all the noise, but I am otherwise getting 98% blurry shots!!! Am I being unrealistic to think that any camera can capture this stuff?
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Ray on August 03, 2006, 12:59:29 am
The answer is clear and unequivocal. In those circumstances you have to use a flash attachment. If you use a lens with IS, then 1/25th is fast enough to stop the camera shake, but not the action.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Phuong on August 03, 2006, 02:13:12 am
wow this is where a 350D beats a 5D  
Ray was right. with IS and/or shorter focal length you may stablize the subjects, but not alway freeze them. these are two totally different topics. 1/25 (or even if you managed to get 1/60 by bumping iso to 3200 or open the lens wider) simply isn't fast enough to stop the actions. this is especially true if there were kids running around.

so since the room can't be any brighter, your best bet is to use a flash.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 03, 2006, 09:13:29 am
Quote
I hate to underexpose due to all the noise, but I am otherwise getting 98% blurry shots!!! Am I being unrealistic to think that any camera can capture this stuff?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72447\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

There's a reason there's a Tv-pri mode on your camera.  It is *THE* low-light AE mode, IMO, even though it is not very popular.  In most informal forum surveys, most people say they use Av and M - one more than the other.  I don't see Av as being very useful in low light, unless you're on a tripod and your subject is still.

I use Tv-pri hand-held in low light with my 20D at ISO 1600 (3200 is fake and doesn't help if you're shooting RAW; I don't know about the 5D), and just let the images under-expose as they might.  Depending on what you're going to do with the images, pushes to 6400 are quite useable.  I've pushed images up into ISOs in the millions, hand-converting from RAW, and binning the results, and the random noise reduces at the smaller sizes, but the one thing left is mostly horizontal and slight vertical "banding".  Banding does not decrease relative to the signal as you bin (or downsample) because it only exists in one dimension, rather than reduce like random noise does.  There is no reason why an intelligent algorithm couldn't remove most of the banding, but RAW converters seem content with their current limitations.

I've removed banding myself, but I have to use a mixture of software; lots of saving, loading, layering, resizing etc.  It would be nice to have  RAW converter that allowed for pattern noise to be removed before conversion, but after promotion to 16-bit linear.  It is my opinion that most of the subjective noise in the shadows of RAW files from recent Canon cameras is the banding, even if it is not blatantly banded.  The banding creates troughs and crests as wide or tall as the image, upon which the random noise is pushed up or down, and when both go down or both go up, you get a broken grid pattern, which the brain locks into and fails to ignore to the degree it can ignore purely random noise, which is actually quite nice looking in moderation, IMO.  No amount of pattern noise looks nice.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 09:21:11 am
Quote
The answer is clear and unequivocal. In those circumstances you have to use a flash attachment. If you use a lens with IS, then 1/25th is fast enough to stop the camera shake, but not the action.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72449\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
I was trying to avoid the use of flash, but it looks like I have no choice.  I actually bought a 580EX, but haven't yet cracked the code on how to make it work without creating that artificial look.  I think the answer is somewhere between bouncing the light off the cieling and decreasing the overall brightness of the flash.

The other problem I had using flash was that it didn't increase the shutter speed.  I think the camera was still trying to properly expose the background.  I'm not sure.  What I got was a blurry picture of a kid overlayed on top of a nicer sharp flash exposed picture of a kid.

Sorry if this thread has turned into 'how to teach the niewbie flash 101'...
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 09:27:43 am
Quote
I use Tv-pri hand-held in low light with my 20D at ISO 1600 (3200 is fake and doesn't help if you're shooting RAW; I don't know about the 5D), and just let the images under-expose as they might.

Can I ask what software you use to do RAW conversion and do remove the random noise?  

If I can't get flash to help here, then its off to the "John Sheehy school of denoising underexposed images"...

BTW -- I have been trying to find out if ISO 3200 in the 5D is done via hardware (real) or software (fake)...reading on the internet I heard both claims...Canon says nothing on the subject.  However, the fact that you have to enable ISO 3200 via a custom function is probably a good indicator that it's fake.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Jonathan Wienke on August 03, 2006, 10:11:26 am
The situation you're describing is pretty tough. I've done a lot of shooting in low light situations, mostly concerts with some kind of stage lighting. You have reasonably fast glass, and are shooting at max ISO, so the only other options are to use flash or increasing the room lighting somehow, like replacing a 60-watt incandescent bulb with a 150-watt-equivalent (~25 watt actual) fluorescent bulb, or something like that. If your ceilings are white or at least neutral-colored, I highly recommend bouncing the flash to avoid harsh shadows, redeye, and other common shortcomings of flash photos. I recommend shooting manual mode with the lens aperture wide open, shutter speed just fast enough to avoid motion blur, and flash exposure compensation set to achive a well-exposed shot. This setting will vary depending on the overall color of the subject; mostly dark-colored subjects may require a -1 stop FEC, while mostly light-colored subjects may require up to +2 stop FEC.

You may find some of the information here (http://visual-vacations.com/Photography/DigitalPhotography.htm) and here (http://visual-vacations.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=73) helpful.

PS: Try using the shortest focal length lens you can get away with, and get closer to the subject. You'll get wider DOF, faster flash recycle times due to the shorter subject distance, and less blur from camera shake. You can handhold a 17mm lens down to 1/20, but not a 100mm. Just remember that focus-recompose sucks (http://visual-vacations.com/Photography/focus-recompose_sucks.htm), especially when shooting with wide-angle lenses and small subject distances.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Richard Dawson on August 03, 2006, 11:02:22 am
Jonathan's information concerning flash, as with other topics, is very complete and may include this.  If it doesn't, another option you might consider is shooting in Av mode and setting the appropriate custom function for flash sync speed to 1/250 second.

This is accomplished on the 20D by setting custom function 3 to 1.  It's probably the same for the 5D.

As already mentioned, bounce flash can be a real help.

Hope this helps.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 12:12:29 pm
Quote
I recommend shooting manual mode with the lens aperture wide open, shutter speed just fast enough to avoid motion blur, and flash exposure compensation set to achive a well-exposed shot.

Thanks for the help.  I really like this idea.  

If I understand what you and everyone here are saying...its basically, open up the lens max, set to highest ISO, fix the shutter speed to 1/125 (or something), use a flash, and tweak the FEC to get the best exposure you can without the deer in the headlights look.

I'll try this out tonight though I am worried the subject will be properly exposed and the background will be way dark....  I refuse to clean this up with photoshop as I haven't the time....

Thats basically the best you can do...beyond this you have to spend time cleaning up noise in RAW conversion   .

Thanks for your links to the other sites. I plan to do some heavy reading this weekend.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Sheldon N on August 03, 2006, 12:16:56 pm
If the space in which you are shooting is enclosed with a nice lower ceiling (preferably white in color) then bounce flash is another option.

Put the camera in Manual mode, stop the lens down a couple stops (f/5.6 or so) and set a faster shutter speed of around 1/125. Also, set the ISO down to 100 or 200. This will completely eliminate any ambient light from the photograph, and the flash will completely light the scene. Then, point the flash head straight up, or angled slightly toward the subject - it's sort of like playing a bank shot (off the ceiling) when shooting pool. Your 580EX also has a nifty white card that can be pulled out of the flash head when doing bounce flash. Some of the light reflects off the card directly onto the subject, helping create a catchlight in the eye and to knock down the shadows that form under the eyes due to the overhead lighting effect.

A little flash exposure compensation can help as well, I usually use about + 1/2 stop.

You'd be amazed at how much bounced flash can light up a whole room. It really helps to eliminate that "black background" look from direct flash.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 12:18:56 pm
Quote
another option you might consider is shooting in Av mode and setting the appropriate custom function for flash sync speed to 1/250 second.

Can you explain a little more what effect this will have.  If I understand correctly, will this get the camera to use the flash for more than just fill?

I'll try it.  If this really works, I am wondering if I can lower the ISO or stop down the lense to get more DOF....OK now I am just being greedy....
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Jonathan Wienke on August 03, 2006, 01:45:37 pm
Quote
Can you explain a little more what effect this will have.  If I understand correctly, will this get the camera to use the flash for more than just fill?

Basically that function will lock the shutter speed at 1/250 when using flash. IMO it's easier to use manual mode and set the shutter speed to 1/250, with the added bonus of other shutter speed options available if you so choose. In manual mode, adjust the shutter speed to control the amount of ambient light that appears in an exposure, and FEC to control the degree of flash lighting in the shot.

Say you're shooting your family doing something in front of the Christmas tree, which is decorated with the standard colored lights. Turn off the flash, and shoot a few test shots to adjust your shutter speed to properly expose the tree lights (capturing the colors without blowing everything out to an overexposed white). Then turn on the flash and adjust FEC to properly expose your family and the rest of the room.

On the subject of noise elimination, my tool of choice is Neat Image (http://www.neatimage.com/), but Noise Ninja (http://www.picturecode.com/) is also very good. Don't use the noise reduction in the RAW converter; instead, convert the RAW, perform noise reduction, then some initial sharpening. Photokit Sharpener (http://www.pixelgenius.com/sharpener/index.html) is well-regarded as a good all-around package, and Focus Magic (http://www.focusmagic.com/) is an excellent tool for reversing the effects of a digital camera's AA filter. I use it immediately after Neat Image, and then my own Midtone Sharpening Actions (http://visual-vacations.com/Photography/SharpeningActions.htm) for additional sharpening.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 03, 2006, 02:29:58 pm
Quote
Ray was right. with IS and/or shorter focal length you may stablize the subjects, [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72452\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Shorter focal lengths don't freeze subjects; they just reduce the movement to a smaller area on the focal plane, so the motion is physically smaller on the recording medium.  If you crop the WA to the same FOV as a telephoto, it will have just as much subject blur with the same shutter speed.  It will actually be worse, and less de-convolutable, because the pixels are bigger.

Same is true with camera shake without IS; a crop from a WA will show just as much shake as the telephoto and be worse because of the larger pixels.  With IS, things become a little more complex for the camera shake aspect.

Using a WA lens to freeze motion relative to subject, rather than the frame, is counterproductive.  You use a WA lens because you want a wider FOV.

Same false economy when you use a shorter FL macro and get closer to the subject - you still need as fast a shutter speed.  You choose FL of a macro based on the working distance and perspective you need (AOTBE).
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 03, 2006, 02:48:05 pm
Quote
BTW -- I have been trying to find out if ISO 3200 in the 5D is done via hardware (real) or software (fake)...reading on the internet I heard both claims...Canon says nothing on the subject.  However, the fact that you have to enable ISO 3200 via a custom function is probably a good indicator that it's fake.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72472\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

The Minolta 7D seems to use amplification for 3200, and it has to be enabled specially, too.  Then again, Minolta may just be a little bit more clever than Canon in covering their footsteps.  The Canon 10D, 300D, 20D, 30D, and 350D all have very obvious RAW data, showing that there is no gain-only ISO 3200.  Perhaps Minolta read my posts or someone else's who also noticed this and decided to hide it a little better with their cameras.  I was comparing 7D shots with the same f-stop and shutter speed yesterday at ISos 1600 and 3200, and they both had the same patterns in the histogram, and the ISO 1600 pushed to 3200 had more line-banding and chromatic noise than the 3200 shot.  Of course, the 3200 could have been dithered.  The LSB from the 3200 shot made into a B&W one-bit image had no obvious patterns, and looked like real noise.  There wasn't more noise in the 3200, though, so I don't think dithering could have been done unless it was done selectively - lower values added only to brighter pixels, etc.  These files will keep me busy for a while trying to figure out what type of trickery, if any, is used.  It might just be gain, though.  Stranger things have happened.

Where can I download a 5D 3200 RAW file?  Mathematical pushes can be hidden, but if they aren't, and are obvious, then there is no question what is going on.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: boku on August 03, 2006, 03:00:40 pm
While all of you have given very good advice - the one obvious thing that was missed was to get a faster lens. Consider something like the 50mm f/1.4. Yes, at wide open, you will have depth of field compromises (as well as need focusing skills), but it gives you an extra stop of light without having to resort to ISO 3200.

This isn't an absolute solution, but it adds one more option.

Frankly, I'd buy some brighter light bulbs.

As already mentioned, if you have low, white ceilings, the bounce flash is another option, just make sure you use a Stofen or white card to fill in the shadow pockets a bit.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 03, 2006, 03:15:31 pm
Quote
Can I ask what software you use to do RAW conversion and do remove the random noise?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72472\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

That's a bit complex; it depends on the image.  The technique is always evolving, and is usually on a per-image basis.  It basically involves deriving the banding offsets from horizontally and vertically blurred flat areas of the image while the image is in a linear tonality, and then subtracting the map of offsets from the image, before applying blackpointing and gamma.  I've done this multiple ways, using IRIS, and the DNG converter in "uncompressed" mode to get the Canon black pixel borders that IRIS discards, and photoshop.  The black pixels can be used if there are no suitably flat areas in the image.  The problem is that there are very few pixels devoted to black (a *HUGE* mistake, IMO).  On the 20D, there are only 74 pixels at the left edge of each row of pixels, and 24 at the top of each column.  That leaves too much room for statistical error.  I wouldn't mind giving up 128 pixels on all 4 edges for better banding removal information.  

One thing is very clear no matter how I do it; line-banding is much weaker than random noise at the pixel level, but the more you bin the pixels or downsample the image, the more the random dot noise disappears, but the banding noise is persistent.  IOW, you need to eliminate the banding before binning or downsampling; it is fractal-like in nature, and keeps appearing no matter how much you zoom out.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 04:18:56 pm
Quote
While all of you have given very good advice - the one obvious thing that was missed was to get a faster lens.

I love the idea of a faster lens, but I already have serious DOF issues.  For example, trying to capture my daughter and my neice in focus while they are playing together.  I like the FOV at 70mm and I want to fill the frame with them, so I am 4-5 feet away.  At that distance, my handy dandy DOF table tells me I have barely 3 inches.  The likelihood I can get them both in the plane of focus is not good.  I can't anticipate their movement well enough and frankly I am running out of ability to think about all these technical issues while I am trying to capture the mood of the situation.  I have really got a healthy respect for photographer who did this with film...it blows my mind how they ever got this right....

On the ambient light issue, I am happy to bump up the wattage at my house, but I can't get my family, friend, and neighbors to do the same.  

Been drooling over the 85mm f/1.2 but can't fathom the 2 grand...
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 04:31:05 pm
Quote
If the space in which you are shooting is enclosed with a nice lower ceiling (preferably white in color) then bounce flash is another option.

Put the camera in Manual mode, stop the lens down a couple stops (f/5.6 or so) and set a faster shutter speed of around 1/125. Also, set the ISO down to 100 or 200.

I am beginning to understand thisI think.  I love the idea of shooting at f/5.6 as it will double my DOF to 6 inches...which I can live with.  I also am indoors and usually have nice white ceilings.

Here's what I have:

1 - Use M mode...set the aperture to 5.6 if possible else 2.8
2 - Set shutter speed to something between 1/125 and 1/250
3 - Set to ISO 100 if background can be lit by flash, else higher
4 - Set the FEC to taste

Geeze this is an education.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: jani on August 03, 2006, 05:14:20 pm
Quote
I love the idea of a faster lens, but I already have serious DOF issues.  For example, trying to capture my daughter and my neice in focus while they are playing together.  I like the FOV at 70mm and I want to fill the frame with them, so I am 4-5 feet away.  At that distance, my handy dandy DOF table tells me I have barely 3 inches.
Yes, but that's only if your viewing distance of your print is such that you just barely cannot distinguish the dots from the original pixels. That's a pretty big print viewed at a pretty short distance with your 5D. How likely is it that your family snapshots will, for instance, be printed 8x10 inches and viewed at 1 foot distance or less?

Quote
The likelihood I can get them both in the plane of focus is not good.  I can't anticipate their movement well enough and frankly I am running out of ability to think about all these technical issues while I am trying to capture the mood of the situation.  I have really got a healthy respect for photographer who did this with film...it blows my mind how they ever got this right....

On the ambient light issue, I am happy to bump up the wattage at my house, but I can't get my family, friend, and neighbors to do the same. 

Been drooling over the 85mm f/1.2 but can't fathom the 2 grand...
That will only get you worse DoF issues.  

But seriously: don't fret about DoF that much!

Make the limited DoF your friend instead; think of it as an opportunity instead of a limitation.

And keep in mind that the DoF "problem" is less on smaller prints.

Compare, for instance, the following:

http://jani.vikingmud.org/gallery/d/2780-4/_MG_8004.jpg (http://jani.vikingmud.org/gallery/d/2780-4/_MG_8004.jpg)
http://jani.vikingmud.org/gallery/d/2781-3/_MG_8004.jpg (http://jani.vikingmud.org/gallery/d/2781-3/_MG_8004.jpg)
http://jani.vikingmud.org/gallery/d/2811-2/_MG_8004.jpg (http://jani.vikingmud.org/gallery/d/2811-2/_MG_8004.jpg)

(Image with EXIF data (http://jani.vikingmud.org/gallery/v/Pool/NM/14_1+2006/_MG_8004.jpg.html), in case that is of interest)
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 03, 2006, 07:11:41 pm
Quote
On the 20D, there are only 74 pixels at the right edge of each row of pixels, [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72500\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Sorry, that should have read "left edge".
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 03, 2006, 07:51:56 pm
Quote
Frankly, I'd buy some brighter light bulbs.

Color of light is important, too.  When you shoot a Canon (and most other digitals) in incandescent light, the blue channel is generally about 2 stops weaker than the red and green in the RAW exposure.  That makes the blue channel tremendously noisier; noisier in the shadows at ISO 100 than the green channel is at ISO 1600!
If you're shooting at 1600, then the blue channel actually has an exposure index of 6400; it is literally pushed two stops if you completely white balance the image.

Incandescent light and green foliage-filtered (and reflected) light are very difficult for current cameras with their limited dynamic range and native color balance.  The best light for white highlight or general subjects (or highlight color in white light) for most digitals is about R:G:B 1.9:1:1.4 (magenta).
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 03, 2006, 10:52:55 pm
Quote
And keep in mind that the DoF "problem" is less on smaller prints.

Point made.  The small version of the pic looks almost entirely in focus.

However, I am very happy to report that I put all the advice given today to good use tonight with great results.  With my 580EX pointed at the ceiling, I was able to shoot in manual mode at f/5.0 and 1/200 shutter speed at ISO 100...WOW!!!  Perfect DoF and all action stopped.

I used FEC to take the flash down 2/3 of a stop...and the results were very good.  

A couple points I should make is:

1) when you do this you need to really be aware of your background.  If you take a shot at an oblique angle to a wall for example you get uneven lighting from side to side.  
2) Shooting with custom white balance (I shoot RAW too, but like to see a decent preview on the LCD) was critical...the camera absolutely blew it on white balance on every setting but custom.

Beyond these two points, I could forget all the technical stuff and focus on getting the right shot.  Thanks to everyone for your help on this.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Ray on August 03, 2006, 11:30:58 pm
Lack of DoF when using flash can be a big problem. One can't have it all. It's sometimes better to accept a few shadows on the wall by firing the flash directly at the subject, if you want to get as much as possible in focus.

The following shots were at 100th sec, f11 and ISO 400. I probably should have used ISO 800, but you don't get a second chance in some situations.

I don't find the shadows at all disturbing in these shots of dancing apsaras, taken in a restaurant in Cambidia. (Or should that be 'apsarases'?)


[attachment=867:attachment]                                 [attachment=868:attachment]
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Craig Arnold on August 04, 2006, 03:23:59 am
Quote
Point made.  The small version of the pic looks almost entirely in focus.

However, I am very happy to report that I put all the advice given today to good use tonight with great results.  With my 580EX pointed at the ceiling, I was able to shoot in manual mode at f/5.0 and 1/200 shutter speed at ISO 100...WOW!!!  Perfect DoF and all action stopped.

I used FEC to take the flash down 2/3 of a stop...and the results were very good. 

A couple points I should make is:

1) when you do this you need to really be aware of your background.  If you take a shot at an oblique angle to a wall for example you get uneven lighting from side to side. 
2) Shooting with custom white balance (I shoot RAW too, but like to see a decent preview on the LCD) was critical...the camera absolutely blew it on white balance on every setting but custom.

Beyond these two points, I could forget all the technical stuff and focus on getting the right shot.  Thanks to everyone for your help on this.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72531\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Just a couple of quick points from a P&S flash user.

Experiment with where you aim the flash head indoors. I have found that with a Stofen diffuser on and if the flash can light the room that you get a very nice effect by pointing the flash back over your head at 45degrees instead of straight up at the ceiling.

If there is ambient light from a window then you can angle the head to bounce off another wall to try to fill some of the directional light that can give.

Once again it depends on flash power, but in a small room don't be afraid of dropping right down to f8 to get DOF. In my house (in London) even our bigger rooms are not that big, and I can use f8, 1/125, ISO100/200 and bounce back over my shoulder with a diffuser.

All this with the Sigma 500DG Super, and the 580 is more powerful than the Sigma.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: James DeMoss on August 04, 2006, 04:49:05 am
 I guess the original poster knew that low light would require "help" but not so much additinall lighting so as that might distract from the subject. I clearly can identify with this and use low light sitiuations frquently. My advice is that the OP consider adding and using avalable lite AND become familiar with strobes, lighting placement /direction. This is a subject at the core of photgraphy and from what I understand he wishes to have natural lite look - but you can have a natural look by adding lite, be it flash on camera/ multi-sync or lamps.

Bottom line, more light is needed, lower the ISO to a reasonable 200 and master "reading" and working with a given sitiation. I believe he has everything needed and is doing a great service by mentioning the fact digital cameras are leading some to believe "post-processing" is the cure to an image problem.

Good Luck

-James
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 04, 2006, 08:26:09 am
Quote
With my 580EX pointed at the ceiling, I was able to shoot in manual mode at f/5.0 and 1/200 shutter speed at ISO 100...WOW!!!  Perfect DoF and all action stopped.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72531\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Using bounce flash at ISO 100/f5 sounds a bit ambitious.  I would expect poor exposure, and lots of noise in the shadows.  Forcing a low ISO when you can't get a full exposure is a *HUGE* mistake.  A stop of under-exposure causes far more noise than a stop higher ISO.  400 is the norm for such shooting.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: boku on August 04, 2006, 08:56:50 am
Quote
Using bounce flash at ISO 100/f5 sounds a bit ambitious.  I would expect poor exposure, and lots of noise in the shadows.  Forcing a low ISO when you can't get a full exposure is a *HUGE* mistake.  A stop of under-exposure causes far more noise than a stop higher ISO.  400 is the norm for such shooting.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72555\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I often wondered about the trade-off. I had no idea. Even with film this seemed ambiguous.

I'll take your word for it, but I'd like to have more insight as to how this was determined or where you came about this information.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 04, 2006, 10:26:31 am
Quote
I don't find the shadows at all disturbing in these shots of dancing apsaras, taken in a restaurant in Cambidia. (Or should that be 'apsarases'?)

Nice pics!  I have to agree with you, but I would also add that you have 3 things going for you in these shots IMHO:

1) Flash to subject distance...it seems that you are far enough away from the dancers to get even light over them all at the same time
2) Subject to background distance...it seems that they are close enough to the background for the flash to work, but far enough away to not have a major shadow
3) The bright colors and detail in the shot take my eye in a thousand directions the least of which is the shadow.  Take the costume off the lady and take the same shot in a dining room with plain walls and Mr. Shadow might spoil the shot....
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 04, 2006, 10:30:13 am
Quote
I have found that with a Stofen diffuser on and if the flash can light the room that you get a very nice effect by pointing the flash back over your head at 45degrees instead of straight up at the ceiling.

I will have to try this...I am all for any technique that reduces the amount of that 'flash' look.  Thanks for the tips.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 04, 2006, 11:09:50 am
Quote
I guess the original poster knew that low light would require "help" but not so much additinall lighting so as that might distract from the subject.

Exactly!!  No flashy look and no post-processing.

I am aware that 'brightening' the image later to correct underexposure in the camera will kill the shot with noise.  At the same time, I don't want to have the 'flash' look.  So its a balance.

Looking again at my shots from last night, I will probably go up to ISO 400 from ISO 100 to brighten shadows in the background.  I may also be able to drop shutter speed from 1/200 to 1/150 and stll stop the action.  This will probably also allow me to use a flash diffuser with the flash pointed behind my head AND push down the FEC from -2/3 to -1 or -1 1/3 maybe.  

Thanks to all the help I feel like I am on the right track to get this correct in camera. Now its all about fine tuning...
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Jonathan Wienke on August 04, 2006, 03:14:16 pm
The biggest thing to realize is that especially in this type of photography, EVERYTHING is a compromise. Increasing ISO allows a faster shutter speed or smaller aperture (more DOF), but increases noise. Faster lenses allow lower ISO and faster shutter speeds, at the cost of DOF and big $$$. Flash can solve the shutter speed and aperture problems simultaneously, but you need some understanding and skill with lighting to avoid the typical P&S "flash look" with unattractive glare, black backgrounds, harsh shadows, and lots of redeye.

One technique I've used effectively when shooting indoor events with horrible lighting (1/2 second at ISO 3200, f/2) is multiple remote strobes. In small-to-medium sized rooms, a few 420EX flashes slaved to a 550EX or 580EX can fill in the background or increase overall flash range and power. Put them on stands, and bounce tham off the ceiling or a silver umbrella (white ones eat too much power for hotshoe flashes), and you get a nice diffuse light that works well even for portraits. I've shot portraits on location away from AC power this way, as the flashes and stands are light and portable enough to carry almost anywhere. For bigger rooms, you'll need some studio-type strobes like Alien Bees and a Pocket Wizard to trigger them wirelessly. I've even mixed both types of flash, with a 550EX in the camera shoe set at about -1 for fill, and the Pocket Wizard connected to the PC jack on the camera triggering the strobes providing the main lighting. A set of 4 Alien Bees with all the accessories (stands, umbrellas, wired remote control for adjusting all the lights' power from a single location, Pocket Wizard transmitter and receiver, sandbags to keep the stands from tipping over, etc.) will run a little over $2000, but will give you the ability to shoot in a huge variety of circumstances, limited mostly by your creativity.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 04, 2006, 03:22:11 pm
Quote
I often wondered about the trade-off. I had no idea. Even with film this seemed ambiguous.

I'll take your word for it, but I'd like to have more insight as to how this was determined or where you came about this information.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72558\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

The amoint of noise in the shadows with Canon DSLRs (and this should be true with other cameras, too) increases at a slower rate than the ISO as you raise the ISO.  For my 20D, the noise (standard deviation RAW levels) goes like this in the deepest shadows (near black):

100 - 2.1
200 - 2.2
400 - 2.45
800 - 3.2
1600 - 4.7

This can be measured in a RAW  blackframe (cap on).  Amplifying 2x, 4x, 8x, or 16x what is amplified for ISO 100 should result in that many times as much noise, but from these numbers, you can see that it doesn't happen.  Rather than having 4x the shadow noise of ISO 100, ISO 400 only has 2.45/2.1 or 1.167x as much shadow noise.  This is called readout noise, as it happens even without any signal and is part of the readout process.  No matter what ISO you use, the readout noise is very significant.  It is what keeps ISO 100 from having significant exposure latitude.  At ISO 1600, the readout noise is highest (relative to the RAW level or RAW saturation), but *lowest* relative to the absolute sensor capture.  

So, for any given absolute sensor exposure, the *ONLY* disadvantage of higher ISOs is the potential for clipping.  No noise issues, whatsoever, except lower noise at the higher ISOs.  Any properly-conducted experiment with a Canon DSLR will bear this out.  The idea that high ISOs bring on noise is based on experience changing the ISO while the EC remains constant, and the absolute sensor exposure varies inversely with the ISO.

There is another aspect of noise, which is the highlight noise, which is photon counting noise.  This is almost the same at all ISOs for the same absolute exposure (but the relatively weaker shot noise is added to it, so the higher ISO has a very slight advantage here); the main difference between ISOs for absolute exposures that are in the midtone and highlight ranges of the ISOs is the amount of posterization in the digitization process, which is higher for the lower ISOs.

This is one reason why people crave auto-ISO with manually selected f-stop and shutter speed; you can only create more noise by having a choice of ISO, and failing to maximize it for your manual absolute exposure.  I would love a mode that let me pick f-stop and shutter speed, let me dial in exposure compensation based on key and contrast, and automate the ISO.  IMO, photography is not about ISO; ISO is an unfortunate side-effect of non-ideal technology.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Ray on August 04, 2006, 08:06:52 pm
Quote
Take the costume off the lady and take the same shot in a dining room with plain walls ..................[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72563\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Now that's an idea! I don't think she would have agreed, though!  

All your points are valid, but I presume you are sometimes going to use flash outside of the family home. If you've got a nice white ceiling or wall to bounce the light off, that's fine.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Ray on August 04, 2006, 08:34:29 pm
Quote
The amoint of noise in the shadows with Canon DSLRs (and this should be true with other cameras, too) increases at a slower rate than the ISO as you raise the ISO. [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72602\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]


John,
This is true. I first saw you demonstrate this on the old Galbraith forum and I've since confirmed it myself with the 5D. It's always better to fully expose at a higher ISO than underexpose at a lower ISO. This is particularly true of the current crop of Canon DSLRs, but the improvement was far less dramatic with the early Canon models and probably still isn't dramatic with current Nikon DSLRs.

It's really another way of saying that noise at high ISOs has improved . ISO 1600 is now usable. I assumed the reason was due to some fancy, proprietary noise reduction system, and I still suspect that's the case. Even though the reduction in noise has now been identified as a reduction in 'read-out' noise, it doesn't necessarily follow that a proprietary noise reduction system has not been employed. Simply amplifying the analog signal itself does not ensure significantly lower read noise, or we would have had low noise, usable ISO from the beginning, in Canon's first model the D30, for example.

On the other hand, perhaps the innovation here is that previously the analog signal never was amplified prior to A/D conversion. It was all done in the digital domain.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: dwdallam on August 05, 2006, 07:27:46 pm
Quote
Sorry, that should have read "left edge".
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72518\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I didn't read this entire thread because it does not seem that important to me--since you are shooting family snapshots. All of the advice given, of course, is valid. But here is my thinking on the subject:

1. Who cares if you get a little harsh light in family snapshots?

2. If you are really worried about getting snapshot looks from a camera mounted flashgun while taking , uh snapshots, then invest in a small stand for your 580EX and a small softbox that fits on it. Then just carry it from room to room. You'll need a radio control for the EX. As an alternative, you can use a small strobe, like the Alien Bees and a cheap radio transmitter (about 20.00 on Ebay). Just plug the strobe into the wall outlet or use their battery pack.

3. If you want to use the 580EX on the camera, invest in a 50.00 off camera arm and a cord, and then again use a small softbox that attaches to the 580EX.

4. Perhaps most important, you can set the EX to High Speed flash (dialed right on the EX), which will allow you to use any shutter speed you want. You lose a little distance because the flash does not stay on for as long, and this increases with each faster shutter speed. This should not be a problem shooting indoors. I use high speed synch outdoors on my 5D and have no problems with it. This will allow you to set you r shutter and fstop manually to anything youn want.

5. Remember that you will ALWAYS get key light flash type exposure if your shuttter speed is greater than what the correct exposure needs to be for  the ambient light. There is no way around this because if you use a shutter speed faster than which allows the ambient light to record, your background will be dark and your subjects will be lit by the flashgun looking like a traditioanl flash--not fill light, which Canon flashes try to do by slowing the shutter down after they run up against your lens' fastest speed.

6. If you really don't want to use a flash, your best option is to increase light in your rooms--as others have already mentioned. Remember too that the 5D's sych speed is 1/200th and that the 20D is 1/250th, which is quite abit faster. Again, you can get by this using the EX's High Speed Synch option. You can buy a cheap halogen type room light at about 300 watts that bounces off the ceiling for around 50.00 at target. That will light a fairly large living room enough to shoot with a decent fstop and shutter with a high ISO.


Good luck.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: John Sheehy on August 05, 2006, 07:58:13 pm
Quote
You can buy a cheap halogen type room light at about 300 watts that bounces off the ceiling for around 50.00 at target. That will light a fairly large living room enough to shoot with a decent fstop and shutter with a high ISO.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72660\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I do not recommend any yellow- or amber-colored light for digital photography, if light richer in blue can be had.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: Ray on August 05, 2006, 08:33:09 pm
Quote
1. Who cares if you get a little harsh light in family snapshots?

[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72660\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

dwdallam,
That is not a good attitude. If a job is worth doing, it's worth doing well. Even though one might never sell the family photos, doing the best job one can will contibute to one's own learning of photographic technique.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: PicDaddy on August 05, 2006, 09:19:20 pm
Quote
If a job is worth doing, it's worth doing well. Even though one might never sell the family photos, doing the best job one can will contibute to one's own learning of photographic technique.
You said it so much better than I would have.  Our families are the most important thing to most of us.  I want my collection of family photographs to be something that captures the *essence* of who we are.  With regards to children, I'd actually like to take a photograph of their soul if I could.  It's not about how cute they are, or who came to their 3rd birthday party, its about how we think and live and love and feel.  

I am finding it both a technical and an artistic challenge to get to this level.  For 2 years I have been pushing myself to improve my technique.  After five thousand shots I think I have less than 5 that approach what I really want...a photograph that allows you to look inside someone.  I believe I have many more years of learning yet ahead of me.

I hear you all on the stand-mounted lights.   Its a complexity, but one I think I can live with - will research your suggestions.  I will also look into the high-speed sync option on my 580EX...thanks dwdallam.   Anything to eliminate the artificial from the scene and emphasize the subject.

John, your data on the ISO's blows me away...very good information.  I love this concept of auto-ISO.  Shutter speed relates to action/blur, aperture to DOF, and ISO relates to limitations in the  mechanism...it could be taken out of the photographic equation and nobody would ever miss it.  I'll shut up now...
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: dwdallam on August 09, 2006, 06:23:24 am
Quote
dwdallam,
That is not a good attitude. If a job is worth doing, it's worth doing well. Even though one might never sell the family photos, doing the best job one can will contibute to one's own learning of photographic technique.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=72668\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

His options for learning lighting are relatively small using area lighting and an on camera flash gun though. If he wanted to learn lighting, he's gonna need some off camera lights. But then using a flash gun like the EX on camera is a completely different animal, being that the on camera flash is usually meant to be fill flash with the sun as key or other main light as a key light.

That's why I suggested using the off camera arm for the EX and putting a small flashgun softbox over it, along with some area lighting in the rooms, aka more omnidirectional light.

He said "snapshot" -- lol.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: dwdallam on August 09, 2006, 06:45:07 am
The only way I can see doing what you want to do "right" is to use area lighting and an on camera flashgun. The reason I say this is that if you want to capture family images you need them to be natural, not posed--and there goes your beautiful lighting set up. The only way around moving subjects and bad lighting is to "area light" a room as evenly as possible and use your on camera flash as fill light--which is what Canon had in mind anyway. If you could truly light evenly all of your room with diffused area lighting--like having multiple softboxes in every room--you could do away with the on camera flashgun. That isn't realistic however.

My suggestion for you in your situation is to better light your rooms, maybe with a secondary light switch you can use only when you are shooting, and to use an off camera arm with the 580EX on high speed sync. Play with your shutter and stops to get the exposure settings that produce images that you find acceptable. I say this because my intense reading on the subject, and my several studio practice sessions, have taught me that really nice lighting takes lots of practice and lots of time setting up the light and making small incremental adjustments--even for the pros. This type of lighting pretty much precludes shooting small kids--they move around too much. That's why people doing family portraits with small kids--and some adults who can't sit still--use large softboxes that are really just "area lighting"--lighting the entire studio pretty much evenly. It's you typical clear, crisp mall shot--very little modeling light or other nice lighting techniques, no style, but lots of light and clear snapshot type images.

There just isn't much you can do about light when your subjects are moving around, be they in your home or out in public, except to get enough of it, or get really lucky, or both, or in the case of street people photography pick a spot where the light is where you want it, even if only for 15 minutes (rotation of the earth), and try to get a shot where the light is on the subject as you want it when the subject passes by. You can try that with your kids using your windows for key light in daytime, but put something over the window to diffuse the light--white sheet, etc. Then have your kids get near the window and try to use the light as a key. Use the 580 as fill.

Thus--more area lights, small softbox for your flashgun, play with shutter/stops/flashgun settings. Your other options is to set up a studio, but those aren't nearly as nice as on the spot snaps of a family. If you get good in a studio, you CAN bring out the personality, or as you say, the "soul," of your kids, but that is another topic. Point being that nothing can take the place of good snaps for family pictures, and your lighting options are limited.
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: stever on August 09, 2006, 03:38:14 pm
taking pictures of kids is really difficult and even more so indoors where there are windows and distracting background all over -- and of course they're moving and unpredictable

flash re-cycle speed is also a problem with kids - they move fast.  i've been happy with my Quantum Turbo Compact on the bottom of the camera (originally purchased for wildlife fill flash) so you're not tied to the camera with a cord in the way all the time

another way to approach area lighting - particularly if you have white ceilings - is to use a slave flash (perhaps with diffuser as well) on a stand or light tripod in the corner of the room positioned to light the room with bounce of the ceiling  - you can use a Canon battery pack on this strobe to get quick cycle.  you may have to move it from room to room, but once you determine the position and angle for each room, that shouldn't be much trouble
Title: Stopping action in low light
Post by: stever on August 15, 2006, 02:38:35 pm
this thread motivated me to try some things

i've just done some on-camera experiments with diffusers, and the Gary Fong Lightsphere gives the best results i've gotten with on-camera flash.  pointed up, it acts sort of like a large diffuse bare bulb with enough light to give reasonable exposures (up to 1/500 at f5.6 ISO 800 at reasonable distance - obviously a faster lens would be useful here) even without a white ceiling (a white ceiling is better of course).  even with a white ceiling, it is distinctly better than straight bounce flash and is pretty insensitive to angle - just remember to turn the flash head when you shoot verticals

not as good as off camera plus fill, but lets you move quickly and get good shot with little fiddling