Luminous Landscape Forum
The Art of Photography => User Critiques => Topic started by: stamper on March 17, 2016, 10:32:08 am
-
I don't normally do sets but this time a set is appropriate? A harbour which has only wrecks of days gone by.
-
That is a stunning set, Stamper!
Good seeing, fully appropriate processing.
-Eric
-
Nice set indeed. I particularly like the last two, although I find the vignettes a bit on the heavy side.
Jeremy
-
A terrific set, but I am with Jeremy.
-
All four shots are very nice but my preference goes to the last two. I don't think that vignetting adds much to those images, though.
-
A terrific set, but I am with Jeremy.
+1
-
Probably correct about the vignetting. Thanks for the feedback.
-
A wonderful set both visually and thought-provoking .... very well done indeed.
-
Re: Vignetteing,
I would keep at least a light vignette on "abandoned" (the third one) or the edges will probably look washed out.
-
I think these are the first photographs you've posted that I just can't warm up to. I know how proficient a photographer you are in every respect, so I'm not just saying this to stir the pot, but with the high contrast and faux vignetting, these remind me of high school darkroom days before we learned the finer points of photography and "edgy" was all we knew. That being said, given the subject matter, perhaps your treatment is successful in making me feel this way!
-
Terry, thanks for your honest assessment. I always appreciate your posts and comments.
-
The third draws me into it. It's may favorite of the set. The 1:1 aspect ratio--with a circle in the square works well. It's also the most abstract of the bunch.