Luminous Landscape Forum
Equipment & Techniques => Digital Cameras & Shooting Techniques => Topic started by: Khurram on March 02, 2006, 02:22:20 pm
-
I need to replace some worn out filters - polarizers and skylight. For my 16-35 F2.8L and 24-70F2.8L lenses I was using the Hoya Pro 1 filters as well as a Moose Circular polarizers, mainly to avoid vignetting using these slimmer mount filters on wide angle lenses.
Given that the Canon 1D Mark IIN has a 1.3 crop sensor, do I still need to worry about getting slim mount filters to use on wide angle lenses I currently have the 16-35 F.8L and the 24-105 F5L lenses that I am looking to get filters for???
I was thinking of getting Singh-Ray filters, but their wide angle filters do not have front filter threads, so I can't attach my Lee hood for when I need to use Neutral grads. Will I be able to use the regualar mount Singh-Ray filters be ok on these lenses without vignetting???
I am also interested in knowing if anyone has any experience using Singh-Ray's High Lux, the newLB warming Polarizer filters (supposed to have 2/3 less light loss then their old warming polarizer), or the new LB Color Combo filter (combo of warming polarizer and colour intensifier filters).
-
I use a 17-40 f/4 on a 1D Mk II body and a standard Singh-Ray polarizer works fine. I'm not sure if this applies to the 16-35 f/2.8.
I have no experience with the "new" filters but you can read a review here (http://www.f-8andbethere.com/notes/LB_Series.htm).
-
I use a 17-40 f/4 on a 1D Mk II body and a standard Singh-Ray polarizer works fine. I'm not sure if this applies to the 16-35 f/2.8.
I have no experience with the "new" filters but you can read a review here (http://www.f-8andbethere.com/notes/LB_Series.htm).
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59402\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Thanks Francois for letting me know how your combo works, as well as the link to the article!!
-
You're welcome!
I would add that my standard Singh-Ray polarizer vignettes slightly on the 24-105 f/4 mounted on a EOS-5D. Everything is OK from 26mm and up. This should give you an idea of the limit...
So you should be safe with a normal filter on a 1D2 body.
-
You're welcome!
I would add that my standard Singh-Ray polarizer vignettes slightly on the 24-105 f/4 mounted on a EOS-5D. Everything is OK from 26mm and up. This should give you an idea of the limit...
So you should be safe with a normal filter on a 1D2 body.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59441\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Thanks again Francois,
that was actually the next consideration I had. If the 5D price drops to under $3k canadian, i may look into getting that as a second body (which would be my a body of choice when I need to use wide angle lenses).
How much vignetting do you get with your 17-40 with the 5D?
-
Thanks again Francois,
that was actually the next consideration I had. If the 5D price drops to under $3k canadian, i may look into getting that as a second body (which would be my a body of choice when I need to use wide angle lenses).
How much vignetting do you get with your 17-40 with the 5D?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59451\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
The normal polarizer vignettes and is not really usable. On the other hand I also have a slim polarizer and this one is OK on the 17-40 f/4 and EOS-5D. But you need to keep in mind that using a polarizer with a wide-angle lens produces uneven saturation (or effect). As long as you know it, it's not a problem.
The lack of threads on the slim polarizer is a pain in the lower back, that's one of the reasona I have both the "normal" and the "slim" filters.
I must add that here it's winter and I didn't get to test too much with the 5D + 17-40 + polarizer filter combo.
-
I am also interested in knowing if anyone has any experience using Singh-Ray's High Lux, the newLB warming Polarizer filters (supposed to have 2/3 less light loss then their old warming polarizer), or the new LB Color Combo filter (combo of warming polarizer and colour intensifier filters).
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=59400\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Khurram,
I've used the new S-R LB warming polarizer (regular, not slim) with my EOS 1D Mk2 with Canon 24-70 f/2.8 and 17-40 f/4 lenses. No apparent filter-caused vignetting at all focal lengths even at wide open apertures. However, can't remember if I used the lens hood with the 17-40 and the polo filter; works fine with the 24-70 and lens hood.
With the 17-40 there is vignetting at the wide end if you add a split ND holder/filters to the regular S-R LB polarizer. The field-expedient workaround is to hand-hold the split ND filter against the front of the lens.
Have not tested, but the claim for a 2/3 stop advantage over regular polo filters seems to hold true.
Best,
Paul