Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Alternative photobook services to Blurb - a 2025 update  (Read 4753 times)

Mosccol

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 94
Alternative photobook services to Blurb - a 2025 update
« on: July 22, 2025, 08:39:20 am »

Hello everybody

I am a few photobooks 'behind' and would like to identify a quality service I can invest learning etc. into. Most of the info. in this forum (and in many other places) is 2010-2020 so I was wondering if there had been updates, especially for Europe-based services.

Here is what I know at this stage:

- There are no decent Lightroom Classic plugins (or at least ones that are updated regularly), so the workflow will be to get a paper icc profile from a chosen supplier, soft-proof in LR and then export the picture set before playing with the book builder.

- There seems to be an agreement that Blurb's stand-alone BookWright works better than the original LR Blurb plug-in, but I can't find profiles for the papers used by Blurb

- Opinions on Blurb vary a lot, with quality consistency being top of the list. They also apparently use HP indigo presses which have a gamut not that different from classic offset printing, i.e. not as good as home printing

- I am not a book binder so the idea of double-sided printing on quality paper and then building a physical book doesn't appeal. I just want a good, wide gamut, book printing service

Any suggestions? - Thank you
Logged
Canon 7 & L Glass + iPhone 6 ... Where n

Kyle Jackson

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 532
    • Lone Leaf Photography
Re: Alternative photobook services to Blurb - a 2025 update
« Reply #1 on: July 22, 2025, 10:08:07 am »


Following this topic too...

Based on my singular experience (also 15 yrs ago oops) I'm cautious of any printers that require using their own proprietary book design software, so they can't accept a file from other common layout software. The company I used locked up my book design in their own software so I couldn't edit or print it elsewhere, and got kinda hostile when I challenged that. (I eventually jailbroke it out tho.) So lesson learned, research carefully before committing again.

Fwiw the colour management was also challenging, required hand-holding and making sure they weren't substituting different papers/settings after we proofed. Altho I ended up with something I was ok with for a coffee table book, I guess I had higher hopes. (And yeah, it was the prolific HP Indigo 5000 system.) I should say their press operator seemed decent tho, it was just getting thru the web/service/business front end layers that made it kinda meh experience. So maybe finding a small local operator you can connect with personally on proofing etc is better than going to one of the mass-market online services, I dunno. I think there will always be a quality gap (compared to prints) so it's more about finding a helpful flexible service, than one where you can only get paper A if you choose package B with cover C, etc.

Anyhow I'm in same boat, any leads I had were eons ago. Since then I've just been making prints at home and putting them in portfolio sleeve books. But having something bound still has appeal, especially when I want to give people copies (or sell them). So finding a decent book printing service is on my to-do list.

Logged

langier

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1565
    • Celebrating Rural America, the Balkans and beyond
Re: Alternative photobook services to Blurb - a 2025 update
« Reply #2 on: July 22, 2025, 12:06:24 pm »

On occasion I use MagCloud (the "lower cost" version of Blurb) but haven't had the need to use Blurb for a few years. I tried the Bookwright software but the type tools were too limiting for kerning and leading...

So, I simply used the plugins for InDesign and that way I could also repurpose my books and do my own PDF and ebooks without locks and watermarks.

One of the lock-ins you deal with most of the Print-On-Demand (POD) vendors is that they a handful or more of formats and one may have to reformat their work to fit the next size. For instance MagCloud has 8x8 and 12x12 books while Blurb is 5x5, 7x7 and 12x12. Other than the 12x12, you've got a little work to do. It's a similar situation on other sizes.

For the most part, I haven't been anal regarding color reproduction. Going for "pleasing color" gets it pretty close for a lot of my work. Few people who buy my books will ever compare an image to my prints and fewer would even notice that the color will be different between the two.

Learning from my long-time professional graphic & fine artist friends who used to use 5-6-7 color printing, touch plates, etc., tuning the color to the n-th degree, the costs got out of hand and that extra 5-10% of color tweaking amounted to 90% of the cost of their printed reproductions. They learned after paying their dues to go to pleasing color since nearly all of their customers and clients were satisfied and onboard with the results of "pleasing...".

That said, another option is KDF, a division of Amazon. Many formats for books, now hardcover for some and quite pleasing color and pretty good consistency batch to batch. I believe they, too, use the Indigo presses which is not quite to offset quality like on the Heidlebfrg DI presses for short-run printing or the Komura presses, but still quite adequate. The price is quite reasonable per unit, also.

You have to figure out some of the set-up on your own and there's little hand-holding available. BUT there are ISBN numbers and the ability to list and sell it on Amazon.

Amazon used to fulfill in under a week when I started to use them several years ago but now they make about 10-14 days and mostly seemed to be fulfilled on the east coast. When I started, they were printed in Southern California and I'd have them in less than a week, but I guess they moved their printing plant to a cheaper venue.

I haven't tried their hard-bound books yet, but as far as the overall experience, if you know InDesign and can create a proper PDF (KDF has a plugin/preset for this), then it may be worth giving it a try. If you need more control over paper, color, etc. then by all means pay the price and have Blurb, MagCloud and the others do the printing for you.
Logged
Larry Angier
ASMP, ACT, & many more! @sacred_icons
https://angier-fox.photoshelter.com

Mosccol

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 94
Re: Alternative photobook services to Blurb - a 2025 update
« Reply #3 on: July 23, 2025, 08:56:36 am »

Thank you.

I've now also trailed through a few photo mags that do their own evaluations. Lots of trash to discard, but I how for a shortlist soon!

Keep the suggestions coming... Will report back
Logged
Canon 7 & L Glass + iPhone 6 ... Where n
Pages: [1]   Go Up