Luminous Landscape Forum

Equipment & Techniques => Digital Cameras & Shooting Techniques => Topic started by: cblesch on August 31, 2006, 01:58:20 pm

Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: cblesch on August 31, 2006, 01:58:20 pm
In his recent look at two new Panasonic cameras, including the Lumix LX2, Michael asks why the camera maker is packing more pixels onto the small chip. The cost is more noise, and even with new noise reduction circuitry, image quality ends up being a tossup. So why not keep the pixel count the same and use the new noise reduction circuitry to actually reduce the noise? He concludes (actually, laments) that more megapixels is something a typical consumer falls for and therefore camera makers can't resist.

Thankfully, he's not the only one who speaks such sense. Today's (Thurs. Aug. 31) New York Times business page article on new digital SLRs says much the same. And I quote ...

"Worse, cramming 10 million sensors into an area designed for 6 or 8 million increases the likelihood of heat-induced "noise" (speckles), although both companies insist that they've licked that problem. Even so, it's too bad Canon and Nikon are perpetuating the megapixel war; few members of the audience for these entry-level S.L.R.'s will gain anything from 10 megapixels."

So now there are at least two voices calling in the wilderness ...

Carl Blesch
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Andrew Larkin on August 31, 2006, 04:10:07 pm
We are still going through the "FAD" stage of DSLR development.  In the not-too-distant-future the law of diminishing returns will see the end of such foolishness and force the camera designers into new directions like adding more bells and whistles features that might actually be of interest to photographers - like the dust management features.

With the increase in in-camera computering power and storage capacity of memory cards that is inevitable (Moore's Law) there is a range of really funky things that cameras could be doing.

For example, suppose someone were to produce a camera with built-in wireless connectivity?  Then, once the camera could be connected to the local network or even the internet, suppose "they" added a webserver into the camera (both easy and cheap to do).  Now, let's suppose that the processor in the camera automatically hooked each new photo taken with its thumbnail into an in-built web photo album.  Add to this some basic file and image management via the web interface (e.g. delete, sort, selection/tagging, text comments, plus rotate, crop, brightness, contrast, white balance).  A lot of these features are already appearing in mobile phones, so there is nothing technically difficult - just tie it together under an inbuilt web server.

A camera with in-built wireless could generate a new accessory products such as photo storage devices with wireless connectivity.  Your photos could be stored directly to a hard disk on your belt or in your pocket, leaving the memory card in the camera as "standby" in case the camera loses connectivity to the hard disk.  When connectivity is restored, the camera can then resync and transfer the cached images on the memory card to the hard disk automatically.

Whether the camera deletes the images from the memory card after transfer to disk becomes an option for the photograper: leaving the images in place means that you have a backup of the images being made as they are taken.

Just some random thoughts...

Andrew
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: BernardLanguillier on August 31, 2006, 06:09:36 pm
Quote
For example, suppose someone were to produce a camera with built-in wireless connectivity?  [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75101\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Andrew,

For your information, quite a few cameras already have such wireless features. Nikon has been leading the pack with the consumer Coolpix P3, and all of its pro line bodies can be equiped with an optional wireless adapter that does just that (D2x, D2Hs and soon D200).

I believe that Canon offers something similar for its 1d series.

Regards,
Bernard
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on August 31, 2006, 08:53:21 pm
Quote
"Worse, cramming 10 million sensors into an area designed for 6 or 8 million increases the likelihood of heat-induced "noise" (speckles), although both companies insist that they've licked that problem. Even so, it's too bad Canon and Nikon are perpetuating the megapixel war; few members of the audience for these entry-level S.L.R.'s will gain anything from 10 megapixels."
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75071\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]


It might well be true that few members of the audience will gain anything, but the author forgot to add that no members of the audience will lose anything. A gain by a few is still a gain.

Canon have a policy of not going backwards on the noise front. I fully expect the new 10mp 400D will have slightly greater resolution than the 30D and if not slightly less noise, then at least equally low noise.

However, I doubt that manufacturers of P&S cameras have adopted this Canon DSLR policy and more pixels might often equate to more noise, as it appears to in the case of the LX2.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: BernardLanguillier on August 31, 2006, 10:29:31 pm
What is unclear in the review of Michael is whether an A3 print from a LX2 will look better than an A3 print from a LX1.

He claims that there is more noise, meaning that the image quality per pixe is lower, but he also mentions that the LX2 will enable people to print a bit larger.

To my eyes, if the increase in pixel overcomes the loss of image quality per pixel, then the LX2 has some value. If it does, then it has no value.

Regards,
Bernard
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: jani on September 01, 2006, 04:44:57 pm
Quote
[Wireless transmitter]
I believe that Canon offers something similar for its 1d series.
Not only the 1 series, but also the 5D and the 20D/30D.

But the price is ludicrous.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Andrew Larkin on September 02, 2006, 01:30:59 am
Quote
Andrew,

For your information, quite a few cameras already have such wireless features. Nikon has been leading the pack with the consumer Coolpix P3, and all of its pro line bodies can be equiped with an optional wireless adapter that does just that (D2x, D2Hs and soon D200).

I believe that Canon offers something similar for its 1d series.

Regards,
Bernard
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75133\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I wasn't aware of the "built in" WiFi - thanks.  I knew about the optional connectivity for some models.

In any case, it proves my point.  The makers will be forced to think laterally to differentiate their products.  Hey, here's an idea: what about adding mobile phone capability to a camera rather than doing it the other way around?  

Andrew
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: BernardLanguillier on September 02, 2006, 03:11:17 am
Quote
I wasn't aware of the "built in" WiFi - thanks.  I knew about the optional connectivity for some models.

In any case, it proves my point.  The makers will be forced to think laterally to differentiate their products.  Hey, here's an idea: what about adding mobile phone capability to a camera rather than doing it the other way around?  

Andrew
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75282\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

A small fridge integrated to the D3x would, according to some rumours, help Nikon win over some beer drinking canon shooters.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Eric Myrvaagnes on September 02, 2006, 09:26:27 am
Quote
A small fridge integrated to the D3x would, according to some rumours, help Nikon win over some beer drinking canon shooters.

Cheers,
Bernard
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75284\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
And in response, after they've added everything else (lawnmower, direct-to-ipod printing, bathtub, cocktail shaker, ...), maybe Canon will finally add a ...
.
.
.
(drumroll)
.
.
.
mirror-lockup button?      

-Eric
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Chris_T on September 02, 2006, 09:27:15 am
Quote
We are still going through the "FAD" stage of DSLR development.  In the not-too-distant-future the law of diminishing returns will see the end of such foolishness and force the camera designers into new directions like adding more bells and whistles features that might actually be of interest to photographers - like the dust management features.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75101\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Whether the manufacturers "will see the end of such foolishness" is not a given. When product development is driven by the marketeers and/or the designers instead of by the users, foolishness may never end.

Take the PC CPU chips as an example, they keep getting faster while most users (except gamers) don't need them. The PC market tanks as a result, but that does not stop the manufacturers from their foolishness. Similarly, 90% of Word users probably use only 10% of the features (my wild ass guess). Yet each rev adds more features and gets more bloated.

The difference is that there are more camera manufacturers and more model choices. Hopefully one will listen to the users and come out with something different.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 02, 2006, 10:21:24 am
Quote
What is unclear in the review of Michael is whether an A3 print from a LX2 will look better than an A3 print from a LX1.

He claims that there is more noise, meaning that the image quality per pixe is lower, but he also mentions that the LX2 will enable people to print a bit larger.

To my eyes, if the increase in pixel overcomes the loss of image quality per pixel, then the LX2 has some value. If it does, then it has no value.

Regards,
Bernard
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75166\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Bernard, as an LX-1 user I read Michael's review of the LX-2 with some interest (though I won't up-grade - not worth it or necessary). I've produced very acceptable A3s from my LX-1. Using it at ISO 80, the images require from none to very moderate noise reduction. If you use most of the frame 8 MP is very adequate to A3 size. All you get from 10 MP of course is a bit more leeway for cropping or all else equal a slightly larger image at a given resolution. Again all else equal, it's really hard to see (without a loupe) substantial quality difference in a large print anywhere from 240 PPI onward, so the usefulness of the extra MP in the LX-2 really depends on how big you want the prints and how much cropping leeway you like to have. If the LX-2 is really a bit noisier than the LX-1, it puts a bit of extra burden on the quality of noise reduction software and the user's proficiency at using that software. I think there is a lot of wiggle room playing around with this stuff such that in the hands of savvy users the comparative appearance of image quality may be a moot point.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Kenneth Sky on September 02, 2006, 06:40:10 pm
Mark
Are you saying that a potential buyer might be better off looking for "old stock" LX 1 at a discount price in one of the large retailer sites or stores?
Ken
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 02, 2006, 07:25:55 pm
Quote
Mark
Are you saying that a potential buyer might be better off looking for "old stock" LX 1 at a discount price in one of the large retailer sites or stores?
Ken
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75334\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

No, not necessarily - it depends on one's objectives. People who need a larger MP count because they want to make very large (and high quality) prints or want alot of cropping leeway on somewhat smaller ones would welcome the up-grade from 8 to 10 MP. If indeed that is at the cost of a bit more noise, good noise reduction tools are available and can be used effectively in the right hands. At the same time, my reading of Michael's review and some other stuff we've seen on the net from Japan would seem to suggest that if a prospective purchaser finds 8 MP good enough, a heavily discounted LX-1 could be the right fit.

It also depends perhaps on whether this camera is a primary or secondary resource. In my case, for example, it is for back-up and convenience, so there is a limit to what I need for those purposes.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: 32BT on September 03, 2006, 10:21:39 am
Quote
It also depends perhaps on whether this camera is a primary or secondary resource. In my case, for example, it is for back-up and convenience, so there is a limit to what I need for those purposes.

Mark, why did you end up selecting this camera?
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 03, 2006, 10:44:55 am
Quote
Mark, why did you end up selecting this camera?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75368\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Hi Oscar - that was an easy process of elimination based on what I wanted and what was available at the time I bought it. The criteria were: (a) shirtpocket, (b) no less than 8 MP, © RAW files, (d) known high quality lens. When I went to DPReview and did a search on their whole data base (their site facilitates this), ONE camera came up: the LX-1. Then I read their and Michael's review of the LX-1 and despite the comments on noise I bought it. As icing on the cake, I really enjoy the wide aspect ratio - combined with the wide angle lens setting, you get close to panoramic sweep with it.

The noise is a drawback, but quite easily managed. The two things about it I don't like and can't be nearly so well managed are (1) the LCD is close to useless in bright sunlight, and (2) for situations like child photography where timing is critical, there is an unacceptably long lag between the time you press the button and the time the capture occurs. This sort of thing tends to slip between the cracks in reviews and one only learns by using. I mention this for the benefit of those thinking of buying an LX-2 - they should check these factors and see whether they matter.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: 32BT on September 03, 2006, 12:10:54 pm
Quote
Hi Oscar - that was an easy process of elimination based on what I wanted and what was available at the time I bought it. The criteria were: (a) shirtpocket, ( no less than 8 MP, © RAW files, (d) known high quality lens.

In retrospect how would you judge quality of the lens vs noise? Would you consider going to lower res and lower noise if that were available? And in comparison with other offerings by other brands?
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 03, 2006, 12:27:37 pm
Quote
In retrospect how would you judge quality of the lens vs noise? Would you consider going to lower res and lower noise if that were available? And in comparison with other offerings by other brands?
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75379\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Oscar, you can't do much about a second-rate lens, but you can mitigate a certain amount of noise, so if I had to make a choice between a Leica (or equivalent) lens and a little more noise, versus a lower quality lens and a little more noise, I'd go for the better lens. As for lower res, yes, I think if there were a major trade-off between noise and MP down to about 6, I could see myself thinking twice about that choice, but no less than 6MP for my purposes. I don't have any brand allegiance - I buy whatever best fits what I want - except for the major camera, one does get committed to a system unless the budget is very large. If I hadn't bought the LX-1 already and I were now in the market for a shirt-pocket camera I would be prepared to consider any reputable brand that met the criteria. Needless to say I don't know them all in real-time - not a pre-occupation. I just get up-to-speed on what's available at decision time.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: MarkKay on September 03, 2006, 01:05:13 pm
As i attend my kids school functions more and more people who are using digital cameras for snapshots are moving into DSLRs.  Compared to school events three or four years ago, the number of folks carrying such cameras has risen exponentially. When i talk to them, it becomes clear that  most of the folks equate quality with the number of megapixels. I try to explain not all megapixels were created equal but it comes down to mine is bigger than yours and size matters.  I see and hear this often.  I think some of the megapixel wars are used as effective marking tools to the affluent non photography experts.  At some point I believe this will go away but for now, seems like a very effective advertising tool. mark


Quote
Oscar, you can't do much about a second-rate lens, but you can mitigate a certain amount of noise, so if I had to make a choice between a Leica (or equivalent) lens and a little more noise, versus a lower quality lens and a little more noise, I'd go for the better lens. As for lower res, yes, I think if there were a major trade-off between noise and MP down to about 6, I could see myself thinking twice about that choice, but no less than 6MP for my purposes. I don't have any brand allegiance - I buy whatever best fits what I want - except for the major camera, one does get committed to a system unless the budget is very large. If I hadn't bought the LX-1 already and I were now in the market for a shirt-pocket camera I would be prepared to consider any reputable brand that met the criteria. Needless to say I don't know them all in real-time - not a pre-occupation. I just get up-to-speed on what's available at decision time.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75384\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 03, 2006, 07:55:06 pm
Quote
Oscar, you can't do much about a second-rate lens, but you can mitigate a certain amount of noise, so if I had to make a choice between a Leica (or equivalent) lens and a little more noise, versus a lower quality lens and a little more noise, I'd go for the better lens. As for lower res, yes, I think if there were a major trade-off between noise and MP down to about 6, I could see myself thinking twice about that choice, but no less than 6MP for my purposes. [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75384\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Mark,
Whilst preparing for my next trip, wondering what to take and what to leave, because weight is a major consideration, I wondered if it would be worth including my Sony DSC T1. I bought this little 5mp, shirt pocket camera in the days I was using a D60 DSLR and the quality compared quite favourably, at ISO 100, to the D60 at ISO 1000 after a bit of Neat Image noise reduction (same shutter speed & DoF). The D60 was still marginally better though, as I recall.

The Sony T1 usually gives acceptable results in good lighting at base ISO and a fast shutter speed, as in this 100% crop at f7.1, 1/250th sec and -0.7EV. At this magnification, the whole print would be 27"x36".

[attachment=937:attachment]

However, in poor lighting the Sony T1 usually disappoints. I hate dealing with noisy and resolution degraded images so I've recently been looking at what developments have taken place with these ultra compacts since I bought the Sony T1. The latest reincarnation of the T1 is the 7mp T30 with Image Stabilisation. This seems a worthwhile improvement over the T1 in terms of noise and resolution. The IS is a big bonus. These tiny cameras that you can't get a proper grip on are very susceptible to shake, and of course the 1/FL rule applies to 35mm equivalent focal lengths, not the actual focal length.

I compared a few cameras at Imaging Resource at various ISO settings and the LX1 appears to be very noisy indeed. At ISO 400 it's noisier than my Sony T1 that came out almost a couple of years earlier. The 6mp Canon SD700 (which also has IS) produces much cleaner images than the LX1 and the Fujifilm F30 (unfortunately no IS) produces significantly cleaner images at ISO 800 than the LX1 at ISO 200.

So the big question, Mark, is this. How much noise reduction without resolution degradation is possible with the LX1 RAW images? Do you get the impression that an LX1 ISO 400 RAW image, after clean-up in ACR and/or Neat Image, might be on a par with an SD700 image straight out of the camera? Isn't the extra time delay between one shot and the next a huge disadvantage of shooting RAW with such a camera?

Both the SD700 and T30 have a very short lag between pressing the shutter half way for focussing and all the way to take the shot.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 03, 2006, 08:44:48 pm
Quote
So the big question, Mark, is this. How much noise reduction without resolution degradation is possible with the LX1 RAW images? Do you get the impression that an LX1 ISO 400 RAW image, after clean-up in ACR and/or Neat Image, might be on a par with an SD700 image straight out of the camera? [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75418\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Ray, I can only respond in respect to the experience I've had the with LX-1, as the only other digital camera I've ever used is my Canon 1Ds, which of course is in a different league and for different purposes. So I can't tell you anything comparative. I would not use the LX-1 at ISO 400. It can be a bit noisy at ISO 80 - sometimes needing a bit of Noise-Ninja, sometimes not, depending on the image. At ISO 200, it usually needs moderate noise reduction. I and photo-savvy friends of mine continue to be pleasantly surprised by the high quality A3 prints I'm making from this camera used at low ISO.

As you well know, ANY noise reduction comes at the cost of SOME resolution, but most of it can be recovered with a good sharpening tool such as PK Sharpener Pro. But this needs attentive workflow: remove the noise very carefully (i.e. finding the boundary between noise and image detail) and then do the Capture Sharpening.

The LX-1 is also Image Stabilized and that works well, so the LX-2 should be at least as good in this respect. The Leica lens is really superb.

The lag between pressing the button and getting the capture is the time it takes for the autofocus to work. So in a situation where you press halfway and let it focus, from that point onward (i.e. half to complete) the lag issue doesn't arise.

More than this is really hard for me to say. If you have several models in mind that you wish to compare for both lag and noise, as well as ergonomics, there really is no better way of choosing than to go to a good retailer who has them on display and test them. Bring your laptop so you can transfer images shot in or around the shop and examine them on the laptop LCD before buying.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 03, 2006, 09:49:55 pm
Quote
I would not use the LX-1 at ISO 400. It can be a bit noisy at ISO 80 - sometimes needing a bit of Noise-Ninja, sometimes not, depending on the image. At ISO 200, it usually needs moderate noise reduction.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75425\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Mark,
Thanks for your opinion. Testing various cameras in the store before buying would probably give one a good idea as to noise but could be fraught with danger as regards resolution. These ultra compact P&S cameras generally don't have tripod mounting or full manual mode with aperture priority. One could easily end up comparing different apertures at different shutter speeds with different degrees of camera shake. Imaging Resource do a pretty good job comparing cameras at various ISO settings shooting the same targets, so I guess I would rely primarily upon their results in making an upgrade choice.

Generally, it seems to me, if the purpose of carrying a small compact everywhere is in order not to miss that interesting shot which so often  gives rise to the lament, "Why didn't I bring my camera?', then such a compact should be as versatile as possible. I notice on the Imaging Resource site, most of their LX1 shots are very much exposed to the right, to the point of overexposure, in order to reduce noise even at low ISOs. Because of the susceptibility to blown highlights with these small cameras, autobracketing is a useful feature. The Sony T1 can take 3 shots at highest image quality in a second or so.

Is shooting RAW with the LX1 not a PITA? You wouldn't be able to do autobracketing in RAW, would you? After the first RAW shot, the camera is inoperable for several seconds, is it not?

I'm actually torn between 3 models, the Canon SD700, the Sony T30 and the Fuji F30. They've each got their strong and weak points. The SD700 has a 4x zoom, IS , very low chroma noise and excellent sharpness. The T30 has the advantage of a non-protruding lens as well as IS, slightly higher resolution but more chroma noise. The F30 has the best high-ISO performance of the three and the greatest dynamic range, but no IS.

Difficult decision   .
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 03, 2006, 11:04:41 pm
Ray, points of information: the LX-1 does have a tripod socket on the bottom and it does auto-bracketing, taking three pictures. This camera does have quite a substantial feature set considering its size and price point. I don't how the other models you are considering compare in these respects.

I think there's less "danger" testing cameras in and about the store than buying them site-unseen based on web reviews and itemization of specs. I think it's important to get a direct hands-on feel for how they handle and respond taking real world photographs. The reason this is important is that guys like you and me are accustomed to DSLRs and these are far from! For cameras of this kind you'll not be working in laboratory conditions anyhow. I believe it's best to see what they do based on how you'd be normally using them. Taking a number of varied shots with each reduces the risk of fluke outcomes.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 04, 2006, 08:57:43 am
Quote
Is shooting RAW with the LX1 not a PITA? You wouldn't be able to do autobracketing in RAW, would you? After the first RAW shot, the camera is inoperable for several seconds, is it not?

[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75428\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Ray, I didn't respond to this point. Shooting RAW with the LX-1 is NOT a PITA. BUT you are correct that one cannot auto-bracket with RAW. Just for you, I tried timiing the file processing from the instant of exposure until the camera was ready for the next shot. As close as I could do it, somewhere between three and four seconds for a RAW file. Here is where judgment sets in. I'll pay the price of a few seconds to have a RAW file, because post-capture processing is so important to maximize image quality.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 04, 2006, 11:00:56 am
Quote
I'll pay the price of a few seconds to have a RAW file, because post-capture processing is so important to maximize image quality.
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75457\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Thanks for doing the test, Mark. I find it more frustrating trying to choose a compact P&S than a DSLR. They all seem to have a wider gap between the pros and cons that makes any decision quite difficult. Having a RAW capability on the LX1 seems to be really needed because of high noise. The FinePix F30 probably doesn't need the RAW capability as much, but it appears to need a contrast adjustment, which it doesn't have. Image stabilisation, autobracketing and zoom in video mode would also be useful, all of which the Sony T30 has.

I think basically I want a Sony T30 with the low noise capability, and shutter and aperture priority modes of the FinePix F30.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 04, 2006, 11:21:33 am
Quote
Thanks for doing the test, Mark. I find it more frustrating trying to choose a compact P&S than a DSLR. [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75466\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I agree with you about the choice problem - now that you're down to three you're doing well, Ray  !

This is the point at which individual needs and preferences are determinative. Hard to advise. The reason I told Oscar the choice was easy for me is because I absolutely wanted the flexibility and quality control afforded by a RAW file. That eliminated almost everything on the market. Then I read and re-read Michael's review, where he clearly states you can get portfolio quality prints from this camera using RAW format, lower ISO and some noise reduction. My experience with it confirms that. If this isn't the kind of output you're targeting for the P&S, then obviously RAW becomes less important. If you want low noise at high ISO you wouldn't buy a Lumix. So as usual, the choice problem boils down to a careful matching of your priorities with the cameras' features. Do let us know what you decide!
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 05, 2006, 12:19:23 am
Mark,
I'm leaning strongly towards the Sony DSC-T30. I've just discovered that the 640x480 video mode allows use of the zoom whilst shooting (which is an unusual but useful feature), as well as image stabilisation. Whilst the image quality for stills at ISO 400 is hardly better than that of my T1, at base ISO of 80, image quality is substantially better as can be seen in the following 300% crops. The difference is more substantail than the difference between my D60 and 20D.

[attachment=940:attachment]

Whilst noise at ISO 800 cannot compare with the FinePix F30, the IS feature seems to have the usual 2 stop advantage, so noise at ISO 200 should be compared to the FinePix at ISO 800, except in situations where subject movement is a problem.

The Sony T30 also has a tripod socket, which the T1 lacks. It seems a very worthwhile upgrade and the high price can be partly offset by the fact I already have 1.256GB of Memory Stick Pro Duo. Perhaps I should also invest in an ultra light monopod   .
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 05, 2006, 09:09:13 am
Hi Ray - sounds like you're zero-ing in on a decision that suits your needs - but the monopod? Could make the shirt-pocket tip a bit
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 05, 2006, 09:19:19 am
Quote
Hi Ray - sounds like you're zero-ing in on a decision that suits your needs - but the monopod? Could make the shirt-pocket tip a bit
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75541\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]


I can get a Velbon Ultra Stick monopod that weighs just 210 grams, about 30% heavier than the T30. I could have the T30 in my shirt pocket and the Ultra Stick in my trouser pocket.  
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 05, 2006, 09:24:39 am
Quote
I can get a Velbon Ultra Stick monopod that weighs just 210 grams, about 30% heavier than the T30. I could have the T30 in my shirt pocket and the Ultra Stick in my trouser pocket. 
[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75543\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I was tempted to reply something rude but I won't - seriously, though, does that monopod have any kind of small tilt/rotation mechanism, and will extend to eye level? If not, could be hard to use successfully, as convenient as it may be for better stabilizing the camera. The problem you're addressing is a real one - I find keeping my arms extended to see the LCD properly really disadvantages steadiness, especially when pressing the shutter button.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 05, 2006, 09:44:02 am
Quote
...does that monopod have any kind of small tilt/rotation mechanism, and will extend to eye level? [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75545\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

I'll have to check this out. It's in stock at my local camera store. It's definitley not eye level, so crouching down would be necessary, but that's okay. Nothing wrong with my legs.

I did have some trouble finding ultra light monopods on the net. Is there possibly a carbon fibre model that's even lighter than 210gms, ot taller than this Velbon aluminium model, or more compact when collapsed?
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 05, 2006, 09:52:59 am
Ray, did you try these guys - here's 5 pages of monopods:

http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/controller...earch&Q=&ci=397 (http://www.bhphotovideo.com/bnh/controller/home?O=NavBar&A=search&Q=&ci=397)

You'd have to click on the "more info" links for the more prospective models and see whether they are what you want.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 05, 2006, 10:38:49 am
Mark,
There are clearly going to be more options outside of Australia, but unfortunately I don't have the time to wait on a shipment since I'm leaving in a week or so. Having looked at the site you linked, there's really not much in the way of specifications on the cheap and light monopods listed.

I'm surprised that the makers of these ultra compact digicams do not also offer an ultra light monopod as an accessory.

A 150gm, 6" when collapsed, 8 section, 4ft monopod would be fine.  
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: situgrrl on September 06, 2006, 09:22:06 am
k, going to ask a dumb question now...why do you want a monopod?

Have you seen the gorillapod for instance?  I've not used one but the idea seems good and they are sweet-shop cheap.  FWIW my most used tripod is a manfrotto 709B - even with a dslr and 24-135 attached, it's good and stable.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Fotophil on September 06, 2006, 10:14:57 am
My LX1 does have a tripod mounting thread in the base
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 06, 2006, 10:31:45 am
Quote
Have you seen the gorillapod for instance?  I've not used one but the idea seems good and they are sweet-shop cheap. [a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=75675\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Thanks for mentioning that. It's the first time I've heard of it. Seems like a great idea. I've ordered one   .
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Ray on September 06, 2006, 07:47:15 pm
It's a pity my Sony T1 doesn't have a tripod socket because the gorillapod would be more useful with that camera. I had a look at the upgraded DSC T30 in the store yesterday. The only thing that stopped me buying it there and then was the thought I could get it at a lower price overseas. I was very impressed with the very noticeable effects of image stabilisation on that very impressive 3" wide LCD screen.

It seems that one significant feature of this camera that is not widely known is the facility of being able to use the zoom whilst shooting in video mode. I've seen that mentioned in only one review. The salesman in the store wasn't aware of it.

Even though video capability at its highest quality is a progressive scan 640x480 at 30fps, the compression is so great on these small cameras, the picture quality generally doesn't match that from a dedicated mini DV camera. However, my impression is that conventional IS in video cameras tends to reduce image resolution through some process of pixel shifting. I would expect the IS in the T30 would only enhance image quality. This combination of IS and zoom could make the video facility worth using.
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: jbarkway on September 14, 2006, 05:32:35 am
Today I took delivery of an LX2. Once I have it figured out, and if anyone's still interested, I'll post my experiences.

To be honest, the camera offers such a lot that, for me at least, this outweighs the noise problems. We shall see if I'm right...

In any case, it will only be used as a back-up and for snapshots so ultimate quality isn't the issue. For that I have my large-format film camera. :-)
Title: Panasonic LX2
Post by: Mark D Segal on September 14, 2006, 09:25:06 am
Quote
Today I took delivery of an LX2. Once I have it figured out, and if anyone's still interested, I'll post my experiences.

[a href=\"index.php?act=findpost&pid=76299\"][{POST_SNAPBACK}][/a]

Yes, please do share your observations.