I just found this post today and it pretty much confirms the tentative conclusions I posted above.
http://canonipf.wikispaces.com/share/view/12791457?replyId=18997495I'm posting it here for anyone that might need this info in the future. I can't understand why Canon doesn't...
1) explain this more clearly, and
2) tell us what paper they use to calibrate the printers they use to make the profiles they supply for downloading. That goes for all paper manufacturers who supply profiles.
In summary... the purpose of printer calibration is to bring the printer to a known state so that it will print in a reproducible fashion. It is common knowledge that ICC profiles are unique to a particular printer/ink/paper combination, but for a profile to do its job these three components need to always be the same, all the time, everywhere. Nothing is perfect so they often aren't. We have to rely on the paper manufacturers to produce a paper with consistent characteristics, but we do have control over the printer/ink element, which changes with age and wear. Printer calibration is provided precisely to address this issue. It also allows owners of multiple printers to calibrate them all the same, so they will print all the same.
If you are making custom printer profiles, calibrate your printer first with a paper that you always use for calibration. This paper does not have to be the paper you print with. It can be the same paper although Canon lists recommended papers for calibration and the rep told me glossy was best. Then, as time passes (some are recommending twice a year) or you change heads, calibrate again with the same paper before you soft proof with those profiles.
I just received my 20 sheet box of 8-1/2"x 11" Canon Photo Pro Platinum glossy paper ($13 from eBay and one of the papers recommended by Canon for calibration) and calibrated my iPF6400 with the "Glossy Photo 170g" setting.
Now I'm off to print some targets for profiling the paper I'm using for my prints...
Disclaimer: However authoritarian my remarks may or may not sound, please keep in mind that I am not an expert, but in fact am a NEWBIE when it comes to printing at this level. If you have something to add or correct, please do!