Yes, it's obviously already cropped unless Chris shot it with a Rollei, Armand, but somebody usually comes up with a further crop.
Or, "I really wish she was holding the cigarette in her left hand," or, "I can't see her feet and therefore can't tell if she's sitting." What! You can't see the bench is held up by chains and the seat is lower on the left than the right and, really, are her feet really that important? You either like an image for the initial impact or you move on to the next one. I'm always game for a good suggestion that might include a crop, but never to "I wishes." Wish for the moon and perhaps you'll get a cigar for your efforts.
It's maddening sometimes the silly crap people come up with. I am bad about not cropping to specific crop ratios. So be it. I pay a little extra when getting work printed. I crop to whatever feels right to my eye.