I would print it and hang it on a wall for a while to see how long you like it.
I have prints I made forty years ago that I still like a lot (whether anyone else does is another question), and I have recent ones that I thought were good enough to print, but that seem to wear out their welcome in a week or two.
Have to say - there is a lot of sense here. It takes a long time before it becomes clear whether a picture works
or not. There are many aspects... a shot might look good onscreen, but does the composition work from 20ft away,
does it draw you in? does it balance? - there is no end to the considerations...
After a year do you still like it?
It's a complicated dialectic....
I hate it, but often I find in retrospect, not that others were right to complain, but that they weren't wrong