Hi TJ, and welcome aboard. I like 'em both, but if they were mine I'd go for a bit more detail in the lows. I might even do a bit of dodging on the carrier deck. One thing you'll discover here is that when you do a jpeg conversion and then post the result on the web you lose detail, especially in the lows. The thing can look perfect on your monitor, but it'll always lose some of its perfection in translation.