Vent

[Harald L]

In an abandoned coking-plant. What do you think? (color, bw, at all)





Here are the links for further scrutinizing

http://www.flickr.com/photos/harlemhh/8883473866/lightbox/

http://www.flickr.com/photos/harlemhh/8883475372/lightbox/

[Jeremy Roussak]

In an abandoned coking-plant. What do you think? (color, bw, at all)

I like it. It has an air of mystery. I find, unusually for me, that colour is necessary.

Jeremy

[graeme]

Colour.

Lovely image - almost like a split toned b & w anyway.

Graeme

[RSL]

My first reaction was: color. But after studying both images for a while I switched to monochrome. In the mono version the structures on the right are better defined, and I think the improved definition makes for a more balanced composition.

[Tonysx]

My first reaction was: color. But after studying both images for a while I switched to monochrome. In the mono version the structures on the right are better defined, and I think the improved definition makes for a more balanced composition.

I find the colour version much more pleasing. And with a little bit of increase to clarity and vibrance in LR the definition of both left and right structures matches that of the monochrome.

[francois]

Color for me…

[Rob C]

Colour.

Rob C

[PeterAit]

Fascinating image! Both are good, I vote for the color. It is very gentle color.