Panoramic v Single frame...Lac Blanc

[shaunw]

Ive stitched a 4 frame panoramic from this location as well as my previous post...id be interested to hear which you consider works best? The latest Pano is the top image, ive posted the previous image for comparison.
Thanks Shaun


Lac Blanc...Dawn by Shaunwalby Photography, on Flickr


Mountain Dawn by Shaunwalby Photography, on Flickr

[francois]

I prefer the panoramic version. It might be because it's more classic or because the V-shaped sides (rocks and reflections) of the images lead the eyes to the shack and finally to the snow-covered peaks.

[Rjohan]

I like the top image aswell, because of the V formation as Francois said. But also for the processing, it feels "smoother" and more "clear", hard to explain.

[Chairman Bill]

I prefer the composition of the single image, but the light & colour of the pano.

[Eric Myrvaagnes]

I prefer the composition of the single image, but the light & colour of the pano.

That's exactly my sentiment.

[shaunw]

Thanks for the feedback guys...I agree with the general opinions, the pano has a better finish/clarity but possible the single image is a better comp.
I think my final output for the pano might have a slight crop to the LHS to bring its comp more into line with the single image

Cheers very useful that.