Are you planning on banning Jeff Schewe from posting on LuLa on this basis?
I might be wrong but I have never seen a posted image from Jeff in the time I have been a member.
Using Jeff as a good example, a helluva lot of good information is shared (including image critiques) by members who, in my admittedly limited experience, are not big posters of images.
Furthermore, to those who think that individuals who are not regularly posting images are not deserving of the privelages afforded by this forum, come and walk in my shoes for a month or two and then see whether you are able to think clearly to handle a camera appropriately.
I am an ICU physician. In the next 21 days I will be on call for my ICU for 10 nights. These are not shifts. I work my "normal" hours and then have to cover the ICU for emergencies after that. The last six calls I have worked I spent most of night in the ICU on five occasions.
If any of you hotshots, particularly if you are over 40 years of age, think you can do this and still shoot 500-1000 images a week, week in week out, with any expectation of quality please share!
Please check out my history. I love posting images but am very selective in what I post. I also contribute to most of the forum categories as and when I feel I can make a contribution.
This includes critiquing images. Those who read my critiques will note that I tend not to be disparaging. If I can't say anything constructive I won't post a comment. I regard image critique as much more than offering my opinion. It is also a way for me to learn. I closely scrutinize others who make comments to see what their take on the image is. Their insights allow me to learn plenty about photography and what makes a good image.
I actually obtain much pleasure in viewing many of the images posted on this forum. It sustains me during those times when I am unable to get out and shoot for myself.
Possibly the OP was a bit tongue-in-cheek with his suggestion.
I hope so - because this suggestion cannot be actually seriously entertained.
My humble opinion