While considering the entire scene, I'd say that the water effect is slightly overdone in #1. You might try toning down the foliage, especially in the lower left. I think it would emphasise the water more.
The second image is very nice; it has a evenness to it. You should remove the small twig in the lower foreground.
Always nice to see more of this wonderful area. Superior has always been a favorite of mine although I spend my time on the north side of the lake.
Thanks for posting.