I could be wrong, but I gather from the tone of your questions that you are less than satisfied with your Apple experience. Were you a happy Vista user? I actually left Windows for the world of Jobs from XP. Actually, I just upgraded to Lion because I purchased a MacMini to replace my 1st edition Intel MacPro that was 5 years old and getting a little long in the tooth. Using the Apple supplied Migration app the transition was seamless. It transferred everything- apps, data, permissions, logins, printers - everything. I use Lightroom with an Epson 3880. No problems, what so ever with LR or printing. Was I skeptical after the Snow Leopard issues with Apple, Epson and Adobe? You bet! Did everything turn out OK for me, Yes. I'm going out on a limb here to suggest that the reports you read that "Lion appears to be a poor OSX release" is coming from charter members of the Piss & Moan Club (a Jeff Schewe description). Obviously, YMMV. If your happy with Leopard or Snow Leopard stay there for a few dot releases of Lion. Give the developers a chance to rewrite your specific software for Lion if necessary. If you're seriously thinking of going back to Windows, then.........let us know how you make out.
My core question is about the readiness of Lion for photographers. It took a really long time for Snow Leopard to be usable because many application providers needed month to release stable versions of their software.
I have been a happy OSX (Snow) Leopard user for a few years. I have never used Vista, but have been using Win7 at work for more than a year and have had zero issues with it.
I don't care about Win or OSX, really. I am looking for a stable platform that I will be able to keep using for years to come with confidence that my needs as a performance user are well cattered for.
My main concern with Apple going foward:
- their reduced focus on the Pro line, Mac Pro in particular has seen slow updates and is falling behind the mark in several domains compared to equivalent workstations from leading Windows providers (lack of USB 3.0 support, lack of Thunderbolt support, lack of memory lanes, total bandwidth of bus,...),
- Lion itself seems half finished if I have to believe reports from Loyd Chambers and others on forums. This shows to me that they best engineers are now working on iOS.
Overall, the problems I have had with Apple in terms of product quality are:
- Sudden death of my iMac a few days after the end of the 3 years Apple care period
- Chronic shut down of my Mac pro related to overheating of the graphic card resulting from poor design of air intake filter,
- Very poor battery life with Mac Book Pro,
- over heat of my 2010 mac mini HDMI chip causing display to shut down intermitently on the flat screen TV,
- Unusable Raid card for Mac pro - got a full refund after having wasted 2-3 full days of tuning,
So I would say that as a heavy user of Apple products, I have had a mixed experience with their products so far.
Cheers,
Bernard