Psycologically I believe a sort of compensation can be helpful, but not in the way of killing a criminal.
I am also strictly against death penalty for various reasons.
Compensation could be something like an excuse in less severe cases, for example.
Or an acknowledgement of the suffering of a victim by the court and the society.
There are many possibilities. It is very difficult.
Punishment should not have the function to lie the loss one suffers.
Nothing is brought back or repaired.
I have great respect for the feelings of the Americans after the disastrous 9/11.
Bin Laden was an evil terrorist who had brought much suffering to many innocent people and he had to be prosecuted, of course ...
There are many evil people in this world.
But as I see it, the danger is huge, that people doing bad things, be it criminals, terrorists,
(drug addicts, strangers, gay people, communists, punks, homeless, successless, witches, jews, protestants, catholics ...
)
or whoever serve a role for the internal stability of society, and the danger of abuse by "justified prosecution" is great.
Nothing stabilizes more and distracts more from internal problems than a common enemy !!!!
It would have been a sign of a mature constitutional society to have brought Bin Laden to trial
instead of killing him (we'll leaveout the self defense aspect in the course of the attempted arrest here).
This chance is now lost.
And when I see the pornographic way, how some newspapers exploit the death of Bin Laden I feel plain disgust.