As a senior citizen, and long-time amateur photographer, I'm about to take my first steps into video. I've stayed with film cameras, as they give better definition than digital at the same price point, and currently use two Mamiya medium format cameras – a 645Af and a 7. Even with cropping when necessary, I can produce sharp 13 by 19 prints (HP 9180). So, I'm used to quality.
I don't want to spend more than £1,000 – ideally a little less, and have narrowed the choice down to the Panasonic GH1 or the Canon S21.
Videos on youtube – viewed in the highest definition available – seem to me to show much higher definition from the Panasonic, presumably because of the larger sensor. The images jump to life, whereas the Canon always seems to be struggling. The GH1 also attracts me because there's more control over depth of field, and I could use other lenses – for instance, prime lenses when a larger aperture was needed.
The Canon, being a “proper” camcorder, has a powered zoom, and faster autofocus - those appear to be the main operational differences.
I know that the Canon has a headphone outlet, which the Panasonic doesn't; but a work-around seems possible using the A/V output of the GH1.
My questions are:
1. How difficult is it to produce a smooth zoom by hand (GH1), without twisting the camera? I'd try to use a tripod whenever possible.
2. How significant is the difference in autofocusing speed? (my eyesight isn't good enough to focus manually).
3. I read – I believe on this forum – that the only way to get really good sound with the GH1 is to make a simultaneous recording and sync in software. I have a Fostex MR8 multitrack digital recorder, which outputs MIDI timecode (I think that's what it's called!). How possible is it to produce really accurate synchronization using such equipment e.g. of piano music played very fast?
Initially I want to video a friend's granddaughter, who dances beautifully, but I can see other applications for video once I have the equipment e.g. recording piano performances (I'm a piano teacher) for pupils and friends.
What do you folks think? And are there any other factors I ought to consider?
Thanks in advance.