...the term "macro" itself, is, by definition photography where the reproduction ratio >= 1:1, and it is the magnification ratio that affects the DOF.
Not all macro lenses are 1:1, most notably the Zeiss.
And since a flat view and a shallow depth-of-field are part of the dynamics of all macro lens, to criticize a macro photograph for exhibiting these elements seems (pardon the pun) shallow itself.
If I was not aware of the complications of the limited DOF, I would not have mentioned focus-stacking.I hope soon to be acquiring the equipment to make MF macro-photography more practicable, including eShutters for programmed focus-stacking with a medium format digital view camera.Using an auto-focus stacker will hopefully make it possible to photograph some live animals,,, but there are other applications for macro-photography.
Well, if you were already aware of the depth-of-field limitations of macro, then to criticize an otherwise great macro shot for this element to it seems pointless IMO. That would be tantamount to me criticizing a landscape shot because I couldn't see all intricate details of the wildlife perched in the faraway trees ... I should simply understand why
Which brings us to the fact that there are more important elements to macrophotography than "having everything in focus"; for example---lighting, form, and color. IMO, what a focus-stacked studio shot might have in clear focus, it would totally lack in bokeh, background color, and the suspended dreamlike quality that a great, natural, single-shot macrophotograph carries.
And, again, the piecemeal-photographing of a dead insect, in-studio, would pretty much be the polar-opposite experience (spiritually) of enjoying a wonderfully-captured moment of a beautiful living insect displayed under perfect lighting in nature. You may have a "sharp image," that might contain a certain amount of interest, detail-wise, but it would never have the same impact emotionally with your audience.
I am looking forward to having the equipment to put my theories to the test and take some pictures, and to further recover from major surgery so that I have the energy... but, as you suggest, it is now easier for me to criticize and theorize than it is to produce better macro images.
Well, I sure hope you feel better and recover fully, Dick, and I would love to see your ideas featured here. What you propose involves a lot of work and expense, and if it results in what you'd hoped-for, then I would enjoy seeing it too.
...but, in the meantime I will try to get out and capture some autumn colours.
Well, good luck to you, and enjoy yourself.
Fall colors are something I don't get to see much of, here in Florida, compared to when I was in Tennessee
Jack
.