Chairman Bill, I don't know what a full member is, but your comments and images are always interesting, even if I don't often agree.
I think your image is fine, but not great. I have many such images myself and I think I have figured out why I continue to take them despite seldom being satified with the results. The human eye and our ability to see and take in the beauty of the light, the mixed areas of dark, light and everything in between registers different in our brains than on a camera sensor or film. We just can't capture what we see and feel the same way. What I don't like about this image and my own similar shots, is the great disparity in tones, which results in many areas to black out or darken, lighten too much, and the water in some areas to white out. Yet I love this scene and will continue to try and capture similar scenes the best way I can. That's why I go for walks, its not just about the images. The image is not bad at all, and most people not acquainted with advanced photography would agree.
JMR