I think this image is quite ordinary, and like Jules, there is not much I like about it except the dappled light in the mountainous green areas. The clustered rock formation is visually dominant but uninteresting. The rock cluster forms a circle that abuts the frame and prevents the eye from circling the entire scene. I think a sliver of water between the rocks and the frame would give the image better visual design. A secondary motif like birds on the rocks or a boat would add some interest that is consistent with the overall motif. But the real issue has to be the overall expression. So although one can argue this image is technically well taken, it lacks expression, something that one wants to convey to the viewer and is more than beautiful elements. I have hundreds of what I call post card images in my slide collection, but I seldom show them anymore, because I want my images to convey more than nice scenes. Easier said than done, I know.
JMR
