Yes it is an Epson printer, I forgot to mention that fact.
Sure is confusing. I am sitting her looking at CS 3 Print dialog box, on Color Management, has 3 buttons,
"Color Controls" then "Color Sync" and last button is "Off"( No Color Adjustment) the same exact words as in CS5 installed on my other mac. On the CS5 with No color adjustment selected my prints look quite good.
In CS3 I had to use Off to get decent print colors.
You are confusing Photoshop and its controls with the Epson print driver and its controls. In CS5, the Print Settings
button opens the Epson driver controls. You are no longer “in” Photoshop but the Epson driver. In CS4 and earlier, you configured Photoshop’s Print dialog, hit the Print
button and the Epson dialog (the dialog you see by selecting Print Settings
in CS5) appear.
Two sets of controls, two sets that do different things. And FWIW, if you had a different print driver, you would see different items to select after clicking Print Settings
in CS5 (or the Print button in CS3).