I use that screen on my 1D II bodies. It does a much better job of previewing DOF than the standard screen. With the fast prime lenses, the screen is very bright. With the f/2.8 zooms, it is noticeably darker but still usable. With an f/4 lens, it is very dark, but I only had serious problems when shooting outdoors in the snow (my eyes were adjusted for very bright conditions,) or indoors under very dark conditions.
Note this is for photojournalism, it would not be an issue for tripod mounted landscape photography.