In my tests of this paper with the 3800, while EEF can achieve a slightly higher dmax with the premium luster setting, using the premium glossy setting instead results in a smoother curve all the way through the maximum densities until the very last step where there is a very slight reversal. With the luster setting, there is a more significant reversal in the curve near the top end where it drops from 2.61 to 2.58 and then recovers, and reverses again! You probably have to hit it with a lot of light to really see that, but it might be part of your problem.
I'd try the premium glossy setting and see if it's better.
Good luck and Aloha,
Aaron