Eric,
I am sorry if I upset you with my post it is not my intention, I am just the messenger here.
mcphoto said: " If anyone a year ago predicted what has unfolded with MFD to this date we would have thought they were crazy!
Denis". Yes some people could see some of it and yes, we got -and we get- a lot of heat for posting our opinion.
I wonder if everyone here wants posters to say only "positive" things, not to criticize, not to state "crazy" ideas like: -hey, this system is lacking a 28mm AND even a 35mm- because it may upset people that are busy spending $50k on such system. Even a Maserati is no good if it comes without a back-up gear.
We may never know what really killed the Afi/Hy6. You where/are correct in the points you make about the system -and about Mamiya-, but it was just not enough given the other design flaws. There is one undeniable fact: this system is now waiting for its postmortem...
OK so what do you want a prize? an IPA honorable mention? That we all declare that actually we were wrong to say that Rollei/Scheider optics were the best, and that the Hy6 was the most sophisticated MF camera out there and instead that really Mamiya with the slow 1/125 shutter and mirror vibration and tiny viewfinder is really a way better camera .... what were we all thinking about. What, what?