Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5]   Go Down

Author Topic: New Hartblei Digital Tilt Shift lenses - with Zeiss optics  (Read 36337 times)


  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 69
New Hartblei Digital Tilt Shift lenses - with Zeiss optics
« Reply #80 on: April 04, 2009, 07:15:43 AM »

Quote from: AlDoori
the 35mm lenses
Hartblei 4/40 IF TS
Hartblei 2,8/80 TS
Hartblei Makro 4/120 TS

are identical optically to the Zeiss lenses
Distagon T* 4/40 IF/CFE
Planar T* 2,8/80 CFE
Makro-Planar T* 4/120 CFE
for Hasselblad

Distagon 4/40 FLE HFT PQ
Planar Rollei 2,8/80 HFT PQS
Makro-Planar 4/120 HFT PQS
for Rollei 6000.

so the Hartblei lenses can not be cheaper than the german Zeiss 6x6 lenses.
they may have to be more expensive because of the "superrotator" construction, and because the 6x6 lenses once have been mass produced in high numbers.

the Zeiss optics have an image circle for 56mmx56mm negative, so shifted or tilted they are not suitable for medium format.
this was the reason for the PC mutar for the Hasselblad 500.
optical performance of these Hartblei lenses will be identical to the Hasselblad or Rollei lenses.
photographing a test card in 2 m distance might not reflect the true performance of an optical system calculated for focus at 10 m.

the Hartblei lens for medium format
"phase one 45mm 3.5 TS"
is not a Zeiss optic, so it might be on a different quality level.
i have not seen the phase one lens yet. it will be distributed through phase one dealers exclusively.

the 35 mm lenses
Hartblei 4/40 IF TS
Hartblei 2,8/80 TS
Hartblei Makro 4/120 TS
can be touched, tested, rented, and bought in professional photo stores. at least that is the case in munich.

arno al doori

finally, its clear now. Thank you.


  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 195
New Hartblei Digital Tilt Shift lenses - with Zeiss optics
« Reply #81 on: April 04, 2009, 12:37:07 PM »

Quote from: gwhitf
... But I just found that, with that dark viewfinder in the Contax 645, and with the max Fstop of the Hartbleis, they were VERY hard to focus, even not tilted or shifted. (Remember too -- it's Manual Focus only).

I guess the 45 tilt shift on the Mamiya will be similar.

I think this a big difference between trying to do this type of work on MF or on 35mm than with a view camera.  While little about using a 4x5 view camera is easy, the large ground glass and a focusing magnifier make to possible to tilt and check focus very accurately. And if you are using a Sinar or some other advanced cameras there are simple methods to use the scale on the focusing mechanism to transfer the tilt values to the lens and back standards. E.g. you focus on one spot, set the focusing scale to zero, focus on the other spot, note the value on the focusing scale, then you tilt the lens the same amount. There are vertical and horizontal lines on the ground glass that are used as specific locations for focusing.

Now that many 35mm cameras have Live View, it is possible to check the focus at a 10x magnification. Prior to that it was very hard for me to see the result of any tilt and focusing effect through the viewfinder - even with the brighter Canon lenses. However, one reason I went with the Canon 45mm lens over the Hartblei lens was that I mostly need shift, not tilt, the lens is f2.8 and it has an electronic aperture so viewing is at full aperture.  The MF lenses are much bigger and heavier and the SuperRotator feature was not so important to me.  Anyway the new Canon 24 and 17 have independent rotation for shift and tilt so it probably won't be long before they have 45mm and 90mm versions that also do that.
Alan Goldstein
Goldsteinphoto website

I have a new fine art project. Please take a look:
Fine art site

Galleries of images at Photoshelter: Galleries
Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5]   Go Up