It's good -- I've learned about some useful stuff since I started reading it, most recently, the Y strap. Most of my cameras on are Upstraps, but my "carry camera," a D300, now has a Y strap permanently attached...that discovery was worth the price of admission.
One problem I see coming up for Reid is that his reviews are concentrated on hardware (with some exceptions.) As digital settles down, when every new camera is NOT a major change or advance, I think the hardware comparisons will become somewhat less important, and certainly less urgent. It'd be nice if he could bring the same focus into other aspects of photography, like printing and software.
JC