[collapsing angle problem]
I like the warm one better - no reason.
I agree with the collapsing angle problem, too.
I like the cool one better, but that's only from looking at the thumbnails.
The warm one has too little colour contrast in the reflected lights, and that kind of spoils the composition to me.
But the cool one seems to be a bit too cool. Perhaps the image could be kept warm above the horizon and cool below ...