Can't say I like either, so the decision is easy! I fail to see the artistic or technical or emotional merit of this photograph. I guess I must be missing something that others relish.
Slobodan's made a good point, Terry. Nobody ever claimed this is fine art. It was posted as an interesting technical exercise.
While we're on the subject, how about posting some of your work that contains artistic, technical, and emotional merit? That's a fascinating combination. We need an example.
