Luminous Landscape Forum

Equipment & Techniques => Digital Cameras & Shooting Techniques => Topic started by: nlred on July 17, 2014, 12:31:34 pm

Title: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: nlred on July 17, 2014, 12:31:34 pm
Can someone please explain in a step by step manner where and how to focus landscape pictures with the D800E?

Live view /Manual focus??
Focus 1/3 rd into the frame/ hyperfocal??

I am otherwise using a steady tripod, exposure delay, mirror lockup. Also staying at apertures below 11.
I am having issues with the bottom of the picture being out of focus and unsharp. Tried reading numerous tutorials.

Simple straightforward advise is much appreciated.

Thanks!
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Jim Kasson on July 17, 2014, 02:52:59 pm
Can someone please explain in a step by step manner where and how to focus landscape pictures with the D800E?

Live view /Manual focus??
Focus 1/3 rd into the frame/ hyperfocal??

I am otherwise using a steady tripod, exposure delay, mirror lockup. Also staying at apertures below 11.
I am having issues with the bottom of the picture being out of focus and unsharp. Tried reading numerous tutorials.

Need to do a diagnosis before prescribing treatment. Can you post examples?

If the back of the image is in focus and the front third is OOF, you can:


focus closer (although this can only help so much)
stop down
use a tilting lens
focus stack

But first let's be sure what the problem is.

Jim
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: nlred on July 17, 2014, 10:08:28 pm
I chose an autofocus point on the top of the black tombstone.

I find the foreground oof. Here is an image shot at f/11, tripod mounted. This was with a 14-24 Nikon lens.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Steve Verrall on July 17, 2014, 11:20:33 pm
Hi,

I use the D800E (and the 14-24) and if I want a sharp shot my starting point is to:


Of course each scene is different, but this seems to do the job in many cases. If your shots are still not sharp with this basic approach, then you need to do some more troubleshooting. You need to be careful with the 14-24 as it has significant field curvature and focus shift.

Hope that helps.

Cheers,
Steve.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Colorado David on July 18, 2014, 12:00:32 am
I chose an autofocus point on the top of the black tombstone.

I find the foreground oof. Here is an image shot at f/11, tripod mounted. This was with a 14-24 Nikon lens.


Did you post an image that I am not seeing for some reason?
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Jim Kasson on July 18, 2014, 12:06:00 am
I chose an autofocus point on the top of the black tombstone.

I find the foreground oof. Here is an image shot at f/11, tripod mounted. This was with a 14-24 Nikon lens.


I don't see the image either.

Jim
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: nlred on July 18, 2014, 01:06:52 am
I apologize, I made many attempts to upload a picture, tried downsizing it too, but am just not able to get one up. I will retry.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: LawrenceBraunstein on July 18, 2014, 08:28:02 am
Quote
I am otherwise using a steady tripod, exposure delay, mirror lockup.

Did you perhaps mean "...exposure delay, or mirror lockup"? You don't need both. If exposure delay's 3 sec. maximum isn't enough, simply use mirror lockup for as long as you need. Not both. Exposure Delay Mode is nothing other than MUP for 1, 2, or 3 sec. Just asking because I've found quite a bit of confusion about this on numerous forums (no, not this one!).

Best regards,

Larry
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: nlred on July 18, 2014, 08:58:53 am
Hi

(I'm still unable to post pictures...)

Yes, I use one of those options to minimize chances of shake. My troubles at the moment lie on 'where' to focus and camera technique on 'how' to focus. I will detail it a bit more.

I am a newbie and I thank you for your patience!

"Where" to focus? Is it 1/3 rd of the way up the frame or 1/3rd into the scene? Are hyperfocal distance calculators passe now? And with my zoom lenses and limited lens markings, what is the best way to use a hyperfocal chart?

Regarding camera technique to focus....

I have been composing my frame, adjusting to my required aperture etc settings, switching the camera to manual focus, turning on live view, zooming in with the '+' button to magnify the image on live view, choosing an area I want to focus on, and adjusting the lens manually to my perceived sharpness level and then taking the picture.

I have however just come across a post that says that it's preferable to open up to the widest aperture of the lens, focus manually and then go back to my desired exposure settings. Is this right??

Also, the live view is extremely hard to view in ambient light, I cannot see much and have been making serious focus errors. What is the best way to go about this procedure??

With the 800E, what is the best way to achieve corner to corner sharpness?

TIA!
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: LawrenceBraunstein on July 18, 2014, 10:27:27 am
Unfortunately, there aren’t any hard and fast rules governing where to focus to achieve “...corner to corner sharpness”. What you’re talking about is depth-of-field. The 1/3rd rule is just an approximation, though it sounds to me like you’re demanding more of yourself (and your photography) than just that. Besides, the 1/3rd rule doesn’t hold up at all distances. Whether something is perceived as sharp or not depends on several factors including the amount of enlargement and, of course, your own criteria for sharpness. Using the smallest possible aperture will certainly give you the maximum depth-of-field your lens is capable of producing, but it will also increase diffraction resulting in a photograph with great depth-of-field but lousy sharpness. There’s no free lunch (certainly not in photography!).

If ‘corner to corner sharpness’ is what you want, stitching might be your best bet. Depending on the scene, a tilt & shift lens (for Nikon, PC-E lens) can also help quite a bit. It is easiest to determine optimal sharpness at (or near) max. aperture because it is here where your depth-of-field is at its smallest. However, inaccuracies can result from lenses which have a considerable amount of focus shift. Concerning your LCD in bright light, a loupe is really an indispensable accessory. Those from Zacuto are generally considered the best (and also the most expensive). However, I’ve had good experience with the Hoodman loupes.

As far as your technique is concerned, everything sounds quite correct (with the possible exception of focusing at max. aperture). Live View with the D800E isn’t a pretty matter (I’m hoping the D810 improves on this).  Using a loupe and focusing at 100% magnification helps considerably. By-the-way, if you change your ‘AF activation’ setting in ‘custom settings’ (A4) to ‘AF-ON only’, you don’t need to switch to manual focus each time you take a shot. Assuming your lens is set to M/A, the manual override will allow you to focus, and the ‘AF-ON only’ setting will prevent any re-focus when you release the shutter. I’ve gotten so used to using the AF-ON button to focus, I would hate to have to do without it.

All the best with your focusing efforts,

Larry
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: PeterAit on July 18, 2014, 10:53:47 am
All the responses suggesting self-timer or remote release are nonsense. It's only the bottom part of the image that isn't sharp, and camera shake would affect the entire image. Please, people, think before you respond!

I suspect the problem is focusing at infinity. If you were to focus a wee bit closer, the depth of focus would extend out to the most distant objects and into the closer foreground. This is the hyperfocal distance, and while it can be calculated, that is totally unnecessary.

Here's a hypothetical example. Suppose I am photographing a meadow that has some flowers on the ground about 10 feet away, a treeline 100 feet away, and mountains in the distance. If I focus on the mountains the flowers may be out of focus. But, if I focus on the trees, everything will be in focus.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: NancyP on July 18, 2014, 12:23:46 pm
Herein lies the reason that people willingly pay over $2,000.00 for a tilt-shift lens.  :(

I ran into that problem recently, and have a bunch of differentially focused shots to play with post-processing blending/stacking.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: EricV on July 18, 2014, 12:36:53 pm
Here's a hypothetical example. Suppose I am photographing a meadow that has some flowers on the ground about 10 feet away, a treeline 100 feet away, and mountains in the distance. If I focus on the mountains the flowers may be out of focus. But, if I focus on the trees, everything will be in focus.
Your example is a good illustration of why the hyperfocal concept can be useful.  The focus distance between 10 feet and 100 feet is very much larger than the focus distance between 100 feet and infinity.  If you focus on the trees, the flowers will still be way out of focus.  If you want the flowers and trees to be equally well in focus (or more probably equally blurred by defocus), you need to focus around 20 feet.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 18, 2014, 05:44:14 pm
FF cameras offer less DoF compared to smaller formats, all other things being equal.

There are 3 options in increasing order of complexity/value:
- stop down to f16-f22, focus close enough and sharpen adequately to compensate for the loss of sharpness resulting from diffraction,
- use a tilt lens such as the 24mm T/S,
- use DoF stacking which means take several shots at different focusing distances and mix them in software such as Helicon focus.

Good luck.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: luxborealis on July 20, 2014, 08:01:03 pm
Can someone please explain in a step by step manner where and how to focus landscape pictures with the D800E?

Live view /Manual focus??
Focus 1/3 rd into the frame/ hyperfocal??

I am otherwise using a steady tripod, exposure delay, mirror lockup. Also staying at apertures below 11.
I am having issues with the bottom of the picture being out of focus and unsharp. Tried reading numerous tutorials.

Simple straightforward advise is much appreciated.

Thanks!

Simple and straightforward here we go... For a surprising number of landscape photos (certainly not all, but many), using the central focus point works for one simple reason: a strong, three-dimensional landscape is often made with a wideangle lens tilted slightly downwards to capture a detailed foreground as well as the grand vista behind. In tilting down, the central focus point is now about ⅓ into the landscape. With the aperture at f/11 (or 16 and sometimes 22 if the foreground is really close) make an exposure then check your sharpness by magnifying on the LCD. If needed manually adjust the focus forward or back as needed, but just slightly, and reshoot. Then check the LCD again. Do this 20 times or so and you will begin to recognize where to focus.

Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: elf on July 21, 2014, 08:13:10 pm
Harold M. Merklinger can help you  8)
http://www.trenholm.org/hmmerk/
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Alan Klein on July 21, 2014, 11:49:39 pm
Although I don't have a Nikon but rather a medium format manual film camera, here's the process I use when shooting landscapes.  Calculate the hyperfocal distance for the DOF you need to cover near and far objects.    Manually focus on the hyperfocal distance calculated.  Stop down one additional stop from the calculated f/stop for good measure.  Don't worry about diffraction.  Adjust shutter accordingly.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 22, 2014, 02:35:26 am
Don't worry about diffraction.

The great value of this part of your recommendation is that it will ensure you are never tempted to buy more resolving bodies or lenses. ;)

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Hans Kruse on July 22, 2014, 09:43:20 am
I chose an autofocus point on the top of the black tombstone.

I find the foreground oof. Here is an image shot at f/11, tripod mounted. This was with a 14-24 Nikon lens.


It is always a good idea to use a DOF calculator to get familiar with the actual DOF given the lens, focal length and aperture and also how much you want the picture to be enlarged. The default CoC is not always adequate.

So when you have calculated the DOF and the hyperfocal distance and made sure that you use an aperture that will give you the needed DOF then it is simple: You focus at the hyperfocal distance and take the shot.

A couple of comments on this:

1) Focus at hyperfocal distance means that you will have infinity included in the DOF for the given CoC, Aperture and focal length. But, if you focus just a bit shorter then you will no longer have infinity included. Try and do some calculations with a DOF calculator and you will.

2) Having a D800E it is really simple to check if you will get the DOF needed. Simply shoot in live view (which btw. is a good idea anyway to avoid mirror slap) and on the D800E live view shows you the picture with the stopped down aperture. So you simply first move the the focus square to where you think the hyperfocal distance is and zoom in and hold the AF-ON button until the square becomes green. The zoomed in you move the square to the foreground and see if it is within DOF and then to the background and see if it is within DOF. If not stop down. Don't go any further than f/16 unless you really have to since f/22 will loose a lot resolution and f/16 too. For f/16 I use the sharpening parameters in Lightroom fo the D800E amount=50, radius=1, detail=100 and masking=30 (for all other fstops below f/16 (f/11, f/8 etc)) I use the same except radius=0.8 and detail=70. You can iterate the focus checking to make sure you have all needed within DOF and not stopping down too much. And shoot in live view! With a focal length <100mm I have found that even continuous shooting in live view does not create any blur on a sturdy tripod with a strong ball head and an L-bracket.

3) Make sure you do not focus with the shutter button and setting this is done in a4 which you set to AF-ON only.

If you need to go beyond what is possible by stopping down then use focus stacking or tilt/shift lenses.

Some examples:

Canon 5D III and Canon 24-70 f/2.8L II at 28mm, f/16, 1/20s, ISO 100
http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/Workshops/Abruzzo-Umbria-June-2015/n-c5QGR/i-DfVVZ7m/A
(http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/photos/i-DfVVZ7m/0/L/i-DfVVZ7m-L.jpg)

Nikon D800E and Sigma 24-150 f/4 OS at 24mm, f/16, 1/320s, ISO 100
http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/Workshops/Abruzzo-Umbria-June-2015/n-c5QGR/i-X4F4ZSg/A
(http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/photos/i-X4F4ZSg/0/L/i-X4F4ZSg-L.jpg)

Nikon D800E and Nikon 14-24 f/2.8 at 14mm, f/16, 1/8s, ISO 100
http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/Workshops/Abruzzo-Umbria-June-2015/n-c5QGR/i-c9tXqcV/A
(http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/photos/i-c9tXqcV/0/L/i-c9tXqcV-L.jpg)
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: PeterAit on July 22, 2014, 09:55:41 am
FF cameras offer less DoF compared to smaller formats, all other things being equal.


This is not actually true, although you hear it stated often. The sensor size itself has no direct effect on DOF. Is is "true" only because with a larger sensor, one has to either get closer to the subject or use a longer lens to get the same field of view. It's the shorter distance or longer focal length that reduces the DOF.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Alan Klein on July 22, 2014, 11:06:10 am
My point Bernard about stopping down one stop for good measure and not worrying about diffraction is that if your DOF aperture setting or focus point is off a little, it's worse to have parts out of focus with no diffraction rather than having everything you want in focus but with some diffraction. 


Which do you think is worse and under what conditions?  Are there differences between medium format film that I shoot and D800 digital?
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Hans Kruse on July 22, 2014, 12:40:01 pm
My point Bernard about stopping down one stop for good measure and not worrying about diffraction is that if your DOF aperture setting or focus point is off a little, it's worse to have parts out of focus with no diffraction rather than having everything you want in focus but with some diffraction. 


Which do you think is worse and under what conditions?  Are there differences between medium format film that I shoot and D800 digital?

This recommendation is good when you don't have live view. If you have live view on the camera then it is not really needed. However I will often just take a couple of extra shots at different fstops and then choose the best looking in Lightroom. This is quick to do and cost nothing.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Alan Klein on July 22, 2014, 02:21:10 pm
Well with film, I can use the aperture stop down view.  But I find that it usually gets so dark you can't really tell much anyway. 
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Hans Kruse on July 22, 2014, 05:29:09 pm
Well with film, I can use the aperture stop down view.  But I find that it usually gets so dark you can't really tell much anyway. 

There is no difference to film in this respect. The view finder is not food for judging DOF in my view. Live view is excellent.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: mjrichardson on July 23, 2014, 08:11:58 am
I agree with using correct hyperfocal distances and then it's just practice. I don't use scales or measurements anymore and find that requiring an image to be sharp front to back has nothing to do with the subject or composition, I know with each lens how far to back off from infinity focus based on camera height. Some things only a t/s will do or focus stacking but with landscapes it's normally pretty easy to get right. My advice is to practice and learn your equipment and most importantly, point it at something nice!

Mat
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Jack Hogan on July 23, 2014, 08:13:07 am
That's nice processing there Hans.  OT, but may I ask what is your typical workflow?
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Hans Kruse on July 23, 2014, 08:21:45 am
That's nice processing there Hans.  OT, but may I ask what is your typical workflow?

On a high level my shooting practice is what I described earlier in the thread. The post processing also was briefly described in how to select the best exposure in Lightroom. In the workflow is, of course, also the whole rating and selection process which I only do partly when on a shoot (or during a workshop I'm running). I usually wait weeks and sometimes months before I really do the rating and delete the photos that does not make it and that includes th brackets I no longer need. For the individual picture I edit almost always entirely in Lightroom. Included in my workshop is also my backup strategy. And in addition the keywording and publishing to my websites where I use Lightroom plugins for Flickr, Smugmug and Zenfolio. I also use Lightroom plugins for publishing to my iPad and iPhone.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: ErikKaffehr on July 23, 2014, 09:16:40 am
Good advice from Hans and very nice samples!

Best regards
Erik

It is always a good idea to use a DOF calculator to get familiar with the actual DOF given the lens, focal length and aperture and also how much you want the picture to be enlarged. The default CoC is not always adequate.

So when you have calculated the DOF and the hyperfocal distance and made sure that you use an aperture that will give you the needed DOF then it is simple: You focus at the hyperfocal distance and take the shot.

A couple of comments on this:

1) Focus at hyperfocal distance means that you will have infinity included in the DOF for the given CoC, Aperture and focal length. But, if you focus just a bit shorter then you will no longer have infinity included. Try and do some calculations with a DOF calculator and you will.

2) Having a D800E it is really simple to check if you will get the DOF needed. Simply shoot in live view (which btw. is a good idea anyway to avoid mirror slap) and on the D800E live view shows you the picture with the stopped down aperture. So you simply first move the the focus square to where you think the hyperfocal distance is and zoom in and hold the AF-ON button until the square becomes green. The zoomed in you move the square to the foreground and see if it is within DOF and then to the background and see if it is within DOF. If not stop down. Don't go any further than f/16 unless you really have to since f/22 will loose a lot resolution and f/16 too. For f/16 I use the sharpening parameters in Lightroom fo the D800E amount=50, radius=1, detail=100 and masking=30 (for all other fstops below f/16 (f/11, f/8 etc)) I use the same except radius=0.8 and detail=70. You can iterate the focus checking to make sure you have all needed within DOF and not stopping down too much. And shoot in live view! With a focal length <100mm I have found that even continuous shooting in live view does not create any blur on a sturdy tripod with a strong ball head and an L-bracket.

3) Make sure you do not focus with the shutter button and setting this is done in a4 which you set to AF-ON only.

If you need to go beyond what is possible by stopping down then use focus stacking or tilt/shift lenses.

Some examples:

Canon 5D III and Canon 24-70 f/2.8L II at 28mm, f/16, 1/20s, ISO 100
http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/Workshops/Abruzzo-Umbria-June-2015/n-c5QGR/i-DfVVZ7m/A
(http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/photos/i-DfVVZ7m/0/L/i-DfVVZ7m-L.jpg)

Nikon D800E and Sigma 24-150 f/4 OS at 24mm, f/16, 1/320s, ISO 100
http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/Workshops/Abruzzo-Umbria-June-2015/n-c5QGR/i-X4F4ZSg/A
(http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/photos/i-X4F4ZSg/0/L/i-X4F4ZSg-L.jpg)

Nikon D800E and Nikon 14-24 f/2.8 at 14mm, f/16, 1/8s, ISO 100
http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/Workshops/Abruzzo-Umbria-June-2015/n-c5QGR/i-c9tXqcV/A
(http://www.hanskrusephotography.com/photos/i-c9tXqcV/0/L/i-c9tXqcV-L.jpg)
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Alan Klein on July 23, 2014, 12:36:50 pm
Hans:  Are very nice.  content color and DOF
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 23, 2014, 06:28:35 pm
My point Bernard about stopping down one stop for good measure and not worrying about diffraction is that if your DOF aperture setting or focus point is off a little, it's worse to have parts out of focus with no diffraction rather than having everything you want in focus but with some diffraction.  

Which do you think is worse and under what conditions?  Are there differences between medium format film that I shoot and D800 digital?

When T/S lenses and DoF stacking are not applicable then yes, you are of course correct that stopping down is a good solution. My tongue in cheek point was just that it hurts to spend a lot on top lenses and not really tap into their resolution potential. But artistic result is of course more important.

Nowadays, my preferred approach is a combination of 2 rows stitching and moderately stopped down image for the foreground that is focused closer than would have been with a single image. Live view is indeed the easiest way to find the optimal focus point both in the foreground and near infinity for the upper image row. The technique can of course be generalized to multiple rows.

I am in the process of writing an article to describe this technique that, as far as I know, I have invented. The image belw was shot with a D800 and the Otus. 2 rows pano, 8 images total.

(https://farm8.staticflickr.com/7457/13964946529_629817feac_o.jpg)

The key difference btwn film and digital is how easy it is with digital to see that the resolution potential of the lens/sensor was not tapped into.

In the end it depends on the print size you are targeting for a given series of images. If you print at A3, then stopping down with good sharpening is all you'll ever need.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Alan Klein on July 23, 2014, 10:46:31 pm
Very nice picture Bernard.  Sharp throughout.  I would think that DR and range of stops for the right exposure may have been a problem as well.  Was it?
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 23, 2014, 11:47:31 pm
Very nice picture Bernard.  Sharp throughout.  I would think that DR and range of stops for the right exposure may have been a problem as well.  Was it?

Thanks Alan,

In fact DR was not a problem with the D800. I simply used the C1 Pro shadow lifting capability. There is hardly any visible noise for this level of correction.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Alan Klein on July 24, 2014, 12:09:40 am
Is that mainly due to the D800?
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 24, 2014, 12:16:26 am
Is that mainly due to the D800?

I would think that, at least, any recent Sony/Toshiba sensor based DSLR should be able to deal with this. Besides, as often in snowy landscape, you have a degree of natural fill that prevents contrast from becoming ad high as it can be otherwise. It is hard to know how much it helps though.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: ErikKaffehr on July 24, 2014, 12:43:34 am
Hi Alan,

This article I have written long ago may give some insight: http://echophoto.dnsalias.net/ekr/index.php/photoarticles/49-dof-in-digital-pictures?start=1

Best regards
Erik

My point Bernard about stopping down one stop for good measure and not worrying about diffraction is that if your DOF aperture setting or focus point is off a little, it's worse to have parts out of focus with no diffraction rather than having everything you want in focus but with some diffraction. 


Which do you think is worse and under what conditions?  Are there differences between medium format film that I shoot and D800 digital?
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: CptZar on July 25, 2014, 10:38:51 am
Bernard,

when you go in the mountains, the only lens you take with you is the Otus? That is of course a light walking package. But what, if you need longer lenses?  I still wonder why going for stitching if you have a 36MP D810, which will be enough for most prints. Even if you do very large prints, the distance of the viewer will make it possible to print with lesser resolution and still get the same impact.

What kind of equipment are you using for your multi row panos? And what about the light? How do you manage to get a 6 Shoot pano done if the light changes rapidly? Especially when you have to refocus for the upper row, too.

I would be very interested in the article you mentioned.  


Cheers

Jan

Image 40 mm TS and 1.5° Tilt
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Bart_van_der_Wolf on July 25, 2014, 12:25:54 pm
I still wonder why going for stitching if you have a 36MP D810, which will be enough for most prints.

Hi Jan,

Printing a D800 image at 720 PPI will give you an image of 10.22 x 6.82 inches, so for larger images one can stitch.

Quote
Even if you do very large prints, the distance of the viewer will make it possible to print with lesser resolution and still get the same impact.


One can always reduce image quality when people are not supposed to look too close, but what if they do? I don't think one purchases an Otus to then blur the image detail by upsampling to more than what the human visual system can resolve ... Larger viewing distance will then allow to enlarge further.

Quote
And what about the light? How do you manage to get a 6 Shoot pano done if the light changes rapidly? Especially when you have to refocus for the upper row, too.

Practice/experience and a good pano stitching program that can blend well, go a long way.

Cheers,
Bart
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Alan Klein on July 25, 2014, 10:09:33 pm
Hi Alan,

This article I have written long ago may give some insight: http://echophoto.dnsalias.net/ekr/index.php/photoarticles/49-dof-in-digital-pictures?start=1

Best regards
Erik


Erik  Please explain what this shows and the results.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 26, 2014, 03:38:06 am
when you go in the mountains, the only lens you take with you is the Otus? That is of course a light walking package. But what, if you need longer lenses?

Hi Jan,

I typically pack the Otus and the Leica R 180mm f2.8 APO. It is IMHO the best 35mm long(ish) lens ever for distant landscape. It is also light, compact and easy to focus with live view.

The upcoming article will answer the other questions. ;)

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: CptZar on July 26, 2014, 03:42:15 am
Hi Bernard,

thank you, very interesting. What Tripod head do you use? Do you manually expose new for the sky, or do you use the same exposure as for the landscape.

Thank you for sharing

Jan
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 26, 2014, 11:57:09 am
Hi Bernard,

thank you, very interesting. What Tripod head do you use? Do you manually expose new for the sky, or do you use the same exposure as for the landscape.

I am using Really Right Stuff pano heads, I typically use the same exposure for the whole scene and expose to as to avoid burning highlights in the brightest part. There is enough DR in the D800 files for make it easy to lift shadows without any visible noise.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: CptZar on July 26, 2014, 12:16:21 pm
Thank you!
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Ligament on July 26, 2014, 04:26:24 pm
Bernard,

You are an excellent photographer and very demanding regarding image quality. When you are doing these 8 shot panos, how are you minimizing ghosting, particularly with moving clouds, moving vegetation, etc. I doubt you would tolerate this stuff, so wondering how you deal with it. Thanks.
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Bart_van_der_Wolf on July 26, 2014, 05:42:09 pm
Bernard,

You are an excellent photographer and very demanding regarding image quality. When you are doing these 8 shot panos, how are you minimizing ghosting, particularly with moving clouds, moving vegetation, etc. I doubt you would tolerate this stuff, so wondering how you deal with it. Thanks.

Hi,

I'm not Bernard, but I am experienced in Pano-stitching (which I already did with film-scans, and print montage even before that).

Good/dedicated stitching software usually has a pretty good built-in image Blending module, and some even allow other blending engines as a sort of plug-in. These blending enhines take care of most of the image movement in the overlap between the image tiles that make up the image. Sometimes even these engines can use some manual help, and allow to do that in e.g. Photoshop with layers (manual mask adjustments, manual warping, or plain cloning/healing).

Cheers,
Bart
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Bart_van_der_Wolf on July 26, 2014, 06:44:23 pm
Bart, my apologies. I don't know where I got Bernard from!

LOL, a momentary lapse of realization that you posted this in a public forum instead of a PM? I was just poking a bit of fun, but hopefully also answering part of your question. So I took the liberty to intrude (which I am not accustomed to do, so consider it a bold step on my part) ...

Cheers,
Bart
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 27, 2014, 04:07:37 am
You are an excellent photographer and very demanding regarding image quality. When you are doing these 8 shot panos, how are you minimizing ghosting, particularly with moving clouds, moving vegetation, etc. I doubt you would tolerate this stuff, so wondering how you deal with it. Thanks.

Bart is indeed an excellent photographer! ;)

Timing is key, successive shots can be taken within 1 sec of each others. Most if the time adjacent parts if the landscape don't change that fast.

Cheers,
Bernard
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: Bart_van_der_Wolf on July 27, 2014, 04:44:21 am
Bart is indeed an excellent photographer! ;)

Thanks (http://www.luminous-landscape.com/forum/Smileys/default/tongue.gif). I don't have a D800 so these pictures may be a bit OT, but for those who may think I'm only interested in technique, anyway LuLa is about photography:

(http://bvdwolf.home.xs4all.nl/temp/Pelican.jpg)

(http://bvdwolf.home.xs4all.nl/temp/OPF/3058_hf.jpg)

(http://bvdwolf.home.xs4all.nl/temp/OPF/Seeds_or_Sentinels.jpg)

(http://bvdwolf.home.xs4all.nl/temp/OPF/Doel_8526-31_TFP.jpg)

(http://bvdwolf.home.xs4all.nl/temp/OPF/TheSwan.jpg)

(http://bvdwolf.home.xs4all.nl/temp/OPF/Boot2010_2583_S.jpg)

(http://bvdwolf.home.xs4all.nl/temp/OPF/3041-3045_S.jpg)

The last one is a Panostitch, focused with a Tilt and Shift lens, to get back on topic...

Cheers,
Bart
Title: Re: Focusing landscapes with the nikon D800E question
Post by: BernardLanguillier on July 28, 2014, 03:20:20 am
Thanks (http://www.luminous-landscape.com/forum/Smileys/default/tongue.gif). I don't have a D800 so these pictures may be a bit OT, but for those who may think I'm only interested in technique, anyway LuLa is about photography:

Nice images, thanks for sharing!

It is indeed funny to see that some people seem to think it is impossible to both practise photography and be interested in discussing more technical/marketing/... aspects.

The old body-builders-don't-read-books belief syndrome I guess.  ;D

Cheers,
Bernard